News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A family with no fingerprints by Brian_K_White on Saturday December 26, 2020 @04:43PM (#25546670)
I was thinking about that "disease" label too.

Anyone who thinks of the condition as a disease or deformity or handicap, is likely to agree that it should be "cured" if possible. After all, it's a public health harm to everyone else allowing them to breed and inflict their deformity on innocent babies that would have otherwise been normal.

And then one day an actual disease based on a germ of some sort comes along that just loves to live in the valleys of human fingerprints, and the entire human race dies because we erased the few people we had that would have been immune.

I don't understand the excuse for failing to recognize that the value of diversity outweighs it's inconvenience. I don't know how long that has been grade-school knowledge. If not multiple hundreds of years, sure at least it's been a known thing since before the brith of any currently living person?

We are turning ourselves into human Cavendish banannas.

Re:A family with no fingerprints by tgsovlerkhgsel on Saturday December 26, 2020 @04:56PM (#25546743)
I don't think the problem you're complaining about exists.

Eugenics have fallen out of fashion many decades ago, and most countries have laws to protect people with unusual medical conditions/disabilities - typically, the more developed they are (i.e. the more resources they're able to spend), the better the protections.

Re:A family with no fingerprints by handedness on Saturday December 26, 2020 @05:38PM (#25546994)
On the contrary; eugenics has been normalized.

Iceland only sees 1-2 births with Down syndrome per year, and not because they've identified a way to prevent a full or partial copy of chromosome 21. They test and terminate.

My personal experience (and that of many friends) is that western OBGYNs push prenatal testing and corrective action quite aggressively. (There is reasonable room to disagree about what their motives are, and the profit motive may be sufficient for such testing.) And many people want it.

We can debate the ethical implications separately, but regardless of where one lands on that issue, eugenics has very much been normalized.

Re:A family with no fingerprints by saithound on Saturday December 26, 2020 @08:49PM (#25548124)
Base rate information: Iceland's health system sees about 5000 viable pregnancies per year. This means that we'd expect about 4 births with Down syndrome per year. We see 1-2, meaning that about 2-3 pregnancies are terminated in Iceland due to Down syndrome each year.
Re:A family with no fingerprints by handedness on Saturday December 26, 2020 @11:51PM (#25548949)
Correct. Here's a somewhat larger set from Western Australia, showing Down terminations roughly tracking with diagnoses: https://1v1d1e1lmiki1lgcvx32p49h8fe-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/...

From: https://thenewdaily.com.au/news/national/2017/08/17/down-syn...

In the US, only 2% of expecting mothers have amniocentesis or CVS tests, but of those with confirmed positives the termination rate is 75%: https://www.kcdsg.org/files/content/termination%20rate.pdf

Re:A family with no fingerprints by in_cahoots on Sunday December 27, 2020 @01:48AM (#25549362)
That 2% statistic is a bit misleading. Those tests carry a non-negligible risk of miscarriage, so they are generally only prescribed if other tests show that a fetus is high-risk for one of various disorders. Furthermore, some women choose not to get the test even if they are high-risk, because they would never terminate. I’m not sure it’s possible to estimate the ‘true’ termination rate using these statistics.
Re:A family with no fingerprints by viraptor on Saturday December 26, 2020 @07:28PM (#25547649)
I've tried to find a definition of eugenics and it's very fuzzy. I feel like we could do better by adding some modifier that differentiates removing "undesirables" and terminating pregnancy which is likely to result in death or low quality life under constant care. Otherwise talking about eugenics in general becomes a bit silly. In the same way we have different words for murder and euthanasia.

Bunching those together only seems to empower religious extremists who want to prevent any kind of abortion. (see Poland recently)

Re:A family with no fingerprints by Brian_K_White on Sunday December 27, 2020 @03:06PM (#25553832)
RE: eugenics

If you write your idea thoroughly and leave no room for misinterpretation, it's TLDR.

If you write your idea as just the highlight of it's essence, people take the figurative/impressionistic words literally.

I do not know how to avoid both conditions. I can only ever manage to avoid one (either one) at the expense of suffering the other.

Re:A family with no fingerprints by Brian_K_White on Sunday December 27, 2020 @02:46PM (#25553690)
Euugenics is just as ridiculous as the idea that a single disease could actually kill everyone. In both cases, sure it is actually theoretically possible, but really it was just a contrast=100% illumination of the idea not literal.

Did you think that I was seriously suggesting a disease could do that literally? Have you never encountered an idea that needed to be amplified to show it's essence?

The real life form of the process, of which eugenics is the ridiculous hyperbolic contrast=100% version, is simple pressure, discrimination, disadvantage, death by 1000 cuts, attrition etc.

Things which stick out tend to get eroded smooth. Simple as that. Not freaking literal eugenics.