News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by adrian_b on Saturday December 26, 2020 @02:48PM (#25545910)
The 4+4 big.LITTLE configuration is not "laptop-class".

It is the right configuration for a CPU with 10 W or 12 W TDP, which is OK only for a fanless ultrabook, like MB Air.

For the laptops intended for more serious work you want a CPU with 15 W to 60 W TDP, in which case the right configuration must have at least 8 big cores.

Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by kayodelycaon on Saturday December 26, 2020 @04:51PM (#25546715)
Benchmarks show a passively cooled M1 out performing Apple's highest end laptops with actively-cooled 8-core 9i CPUs.
Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by adrian_b on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:06AM (#25550752)
Apple's laptops have always been extremely slow compared to alternatives, so it was very easy for Apple to do better.

In single-thread performance Apple M1 at 3.2 GHz is equal with Intel Tiger Lake @ 4.8 GHz or AMD Zen 3 @ 4.8 GHz (e.g. scores around 1750 in GeekBench 5 ST), but while consuming more than 3 times less per core.

While the higher energy efficiency is impressive, it does not matter much in a laptop, where enough power is available. It will matter only in the future, when Apple will include enough cores in its CPUs, to be able to exploit the higher TDP available in a laptop.

On the other hand, if the power consumption of Tiger Lake / Zen 3 is reduced to be equal with that of Apple M1, their clock frequency is reduced from 4.8 GHz to around 3.5 GHz ... 3.6 GHz, remaining higher than that of M1 (which does more work per clock cycle).

Therefore at equal power per core Apple M1 is faster, but only by around 35%. This advantage is not enough to enable 4+4 Apple cores to match 8 Intel/AMD cores.

In conclusion, the laptops that will be launched in early 2021, with 8-core Tiger Lake H or AMD Cezanne, will have the same single-thread performance as Apple M1, but higher multi-thread performance. The slower laptops with AMD Renoir already have better multi-thread performance.

Moreover, while Apple M1 has an average IPC 1.5 times higher than the average IPC of Intel/AMD, which enables high scores in benchmarks like SPEC or GeekBench, in computational benchmarks with optimized programs that have higher IPC than the average IPC, Apple M1 is disadvantaged and it is slower in single-thread than even an old Ryzen 7 3700X, unlike in single-thread SPEC or GeekBench, where you need a new Ryzen 9 5900X to exceed the Apple M1 performance.

Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by sradman on Sunday December 27, 2020 @09:53AM (#25551404)
> This advantage is not enough to enable 4+4 Apple cores to match 8 Intel/AMD cores.

The M1 is a hybrid 4+4 big.LITTLE SoC and it is the first of its kind that is competitive with the 8+0 pure big Intel and AMD chips.

The M1 has a .LITTLE side that gives it battery powered efficiencies comparable to tablets. This is a very balanced general purpose hybrid architecture. It will be interesting to see the technical strategies used in response.

Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by africanboy on Saturday December 26, 2020 @08:27PM (#25548002)
I think you meant i9

M1 wins in single core benchmarks, but it loses in multi core.

Also, it beats 9th generation i9 for mobile, not the newer ones (that are still 14nm Vs the 5nm of the M1)

I'm not an Intel fan and I think it lost edge over the years, but M1 doesn't beat the i9 in pure performances, only in controlled benchmarks where the conditions are favourable to M1

Of course the M1 on Apple laptops are faster than every other Apple laptop, but that's only natural.

https://www.anandtech.com/show/16252/mac-mini-apple-m1-teste...

EDIT: for the downvoters

An image is worth thousands words

https://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph16252/119365.png

[dead]
Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by sradman on Sunday December 27, 2020 @11:00AM (#25551857)
From the Hacker News Guidelines [1], in comments:

> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[dead]
Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by sradman on Sunday December 27, 2020 @11:56AM (#25552314)
Unilateral kindness in the face of unkindness, is the key here I think. Read the four paragraphs following the graphs in your AnandTech link and square that interpretation with your own. Yes I did notice that the OP wrote 9i and in the context of the thread I knew exactly what they were referring to. A charitable interpretation is a typo or autocorrect while typing on a mobile device, maybe from someone who has written about Oracle 9i before.
Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by sradman on Saturday December 26, 2020 @04:29PM (#25546588)
As Apple did not publish official TDP numbers for the M1, AnandTech tried to estimate the TDP of the M1 in the Mac Mini [1]:

> In multi-threaded scenarios, power highly depends on the workload. In memory-heavy workloads where the CPU utilisation isn’t as high, we’re seeing 18W active power, going up to around 22W in average workloads, and peaking around 27W in compute heavy workloads. These figures are generally what you’d like to compare to “TDPs” of other platforms, although again to get an apples-to-apples comparison you’d need to further subtract some of the overhead as measured on the Mac mini here – my best guess would be a 20 to 24W range.

Lakefield is a 1+4 hybrid architecture with one big Intel Core (the laptop CPU brand name) core and four little Intel Atom cores. I'm not sure what the ideal x+Y combination is for big.LITTLE hybrid silicon for the laptop-class nor the ideal TDP target. From what I've seen, the M1 seems to be the processor to beat along price-per-peformance, performance-per-watt, and all-day-battery dimensions. Independently, the SoC GPU and Universal Memory seem to be in a class of their own.

[1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/16252/mac-mini-apple-m1-teste...

Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by JustFinishedBSG on Saturday December 26, 2020 @04:59PM (#25546763)
> For the laptops intended for more serious work you want a CPU with 15 W to 60 W TDP,

I didn't know we were measuring performance in TDP. /s

All benchmarks show Apple's 12W chip crushing Intel 45w chips (that boost up to 60w).

Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by adrian_b on Sunday December 27, 2020 @08:28AM (#25550883)
In large laptops, i.e. gaming laptops or mobile workstations, the CPUs with 45 W nominal TDP are actually configured with TDPs up to 60 W or 65 W (the steady-state value). The boost power is higher in those cases, e.g. 72 W or even 90 W.

This is true for example in my Dell Precision laptop, where the CPU is configured for 60 W steady-state TDP, because the laptop has good cooling, which can easily cope with that, unlike in thinner laptops.

Your sarcasm is misplaced, because the TDP is the factor that determines the achievable multi-threaded performance of any computer.

Given the domain of application for any computer, e.g. handheld, tablet, thin laptop, thick laptop, desktop and so on, you get certain dimensions, which, together with the available cooling technologies, determine the TDP.

The TDP, together with the characteristics of the CMOS process used for making the CPU, determine the multi-threaded performance of the CPU, if the CPU designers are competent and do not make mistakes leading to lower performance than optimal.

Therefore, while the high single-thread performance of Apple M1 is due mainly to its clever design with high average IPC, its multi-threaded performance is determined mostly by the newer 5-nm CMOS process.

The higher efficiency of the 5-nm process would have allowed a higher performance within a laptop TDP, but Apple has chosen, for now, to reduce their costs by using only 4 big cores, instead of reaching the performance that would have possible for them when using more big cores.

It is likely that next year Apple will introduce models that will be limited by TDP, not by chip size, like this year. Until then, Intel & AMD will be better for multi-threaded tasks and equal in single-threaded (but at much higher power per core).

Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by lowbloodsugar on Saturday December 26, 2020 @05:49PM (#25547062)
"All serious lightbulbs need to draw 60 to 120 watts."
Re:How Apple’s rivals plan to catch up with the M1 chip by africanboy on Saturday December 26, 2020 @08:39PM (#25548068)
IIRC the current x86 processors consume more power because they have more IO lanes that are still on 14-12nm (even AMD on their 7nm CPU)