News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by kryogen1c on Thursday December 24, 2020 @03:58PM (#25531345)
> Yes you may have proven a tactical point, but you have just set yourself up to lose the war.

you glossed over this point, but it is nonobvious. how exactly does making your users skeptical of email "lose the war"? are they going to type in their passwords out of spite now?

the gp is exactly right. if you have a line you wont cross to train your users, then youre leaving a vulnerability. if you want to make the argument that the vuln is worth not "being mean" to your employees, then make that argument, but don't pretend its more secure.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by mcphage on Thursday December 24, 2020 @10:01PM (#25533827)
> how exactly does making your users skeptical of email "lose the war"? are they going to type in their passwords out of spite now?

No, they’re going to quit, or put less effort into their job (which is often worse for the employer than quitting), or tell other people not to work there, or—as in this case—tell everyone on the internet what you did and then your company’s reputation takes a well deserved hit.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by runarberg on Thursday December 24, 2020 @10:46PM (#25534020)
Or they will learn not to trust any email they receive. Or they will learn that phishing email come from internal training, and therefor do not need to be reported.
Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by horsawlarway on Thursday December 24, 2020 @10:46PM (#25534016)
>if you want to make the argument that the vuln is worth not "being mean" to your employees, then make that argument, but don't pretend its more secure.

This is not a good scam. People fucking notice when they expect a 650 dollar bonus and it doesn't come. It's not some arbitrary "check out this cool link" style email that an employee might click and then forget they've ever engaged with.

Not to mention that it caught nearly 10% of the fucking company - That's an insanely high click through for any phishing test I've ever seen at a software company. And I don't even know if they sent it to all 7k employees (my guess is no). So either GoDaddy has incredibly incompetent employees, or this looked fairly real (and the email does actually look pretty damn good for a phishing email - custom image, no spelling mistakes, internal domain, aware of different geos the company operates in)

So you pissed of 10% of your company with an email that wouldn't ever be sent as a real scam (because a week later the employee is going to ask where the 650 bucks is and alarm bells will go off).

I don't have the context of a Godaddy employee, so maybe there's an obvious mistake in there, but general speaking - this was a dumb play by the security team. It's now also losing them goodwill in public.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by stu2b50 on Thursday December 24, 2020 @11:46PM (#25534277)
Phishing doesn't have to be a literal scam. The more insidious kind that companies are actually wary of are the ones intended to steal credentials and get into internal systems.

Phishers can easily get what internal company emails look like. Send an email that looks like "Hey, we're giving you a $900 bonus. Make sure to fill out these forms on workday", with a link that is a Phishing website that looks exactly like workday.

Fill in your credentials - hey, also need your 2factor code - and bam, hackers have an in to the system. It doesn't matter that the employee realizes 10 days later they were phished.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by horsawlarway on Friday December 25, 2020 @12:48PM (#25537865)
It absolutely does matter that they realize a week later.

Security is like an onion - It's layered into place across different levels, and different systems.

If you just want access to a single employee's machine, for a short duration - sure this would work. If you really want to compromise the whole internal net, it's going to take longer than a few hours to work your way into other systems. Generally you either need your target to access the system you want, or you have to spread to other machines to find a machine with the access you need.

The most effective attacks are the ones that get in, and have weeks to spread through the whole internal network. Take the Target breach in 2013 - They were in the system undetected for 20 days, nearly 3 weeks.

As soon as the company knows they have a problem, any decent security team is going to check every system on record.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by stu2b50 on Friday December 25, 2020 @01:16PM (#25538027)
Maybe "doesn't matter" was too strong, but the point stands. The fact that the employee may eventually realize the folly in no way prevents damage from being done.

In the 10 days or 1 day that it takes between realizing they were phished, all sensitive information they can get access to can be stolen. Furthermore, more sophisticated phishing links can then be sent from their account. After all, who's going to suspect an actual email send by a colleague as a phishing attempt?

A holiday bonus type of phishing attack absolutely can work, and be extremely effective at credential theft. It may not be effective at literally scamming money from the employee, but who cares.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by 0xbadcafebee on Friday December 25, 2020 @01:16AM (#25534659)
Fake phishing is not some great methodology to better security, it's a tool to embarrass people and hope that that embarrassment leads to better security, like the Wall of Sheep. (Which, by the way, don't anyone ever implement that at work)

Know what doesn't build better security culture? Trying to trick your users. Know what does? Working with them closely to help them understand security, finding out when and how people get tricked, and working to solve those issues.

The anti-phishing efforts I've seen so far have been lame and ineffective. Rather than trying to find new ways to make people fail, security teams should be finding new ways to prevent people from falling victim.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by bluntfang on Thursday December 24, 2020 @04:06PM (#25531421)
if you make your employees feel bad on purpose and have a track record of insensitivity, they won't like you. People who don't like you won't act in your interest to a high capacity.

I don't think GP was ambiguous at all, to be honest. This point was extremely clear. It feels like you came to the discussion with an axe to grind.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by watwut on Thursday December 24, 2020 @06:27PM (#25532551)
You are teaching your users that security teams are assholes who deserve whatever petty revenge is possible.

And people will treat you like that, most often behind your back.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by WrtCdEvrydy on Thursday December 24, 2020 @04:20PM (#25531534)
> if you have a line you wont cross to train your users, then youre leaving a vulnerability.

How about a phishing test that downloads something that nukes your hard drive?

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by Supermancho on Thursday December 24, 2020 @04:28PM (#25531602)
> > if you have a line you wont cross to train your users, then youre leaving a vulnerability.

> How about a phishing test that downloads something that nukes your hard drive?

The phishing weakness opens that possibility. The act of wiping the HD does nothing to improve behavior or identify weakness.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by utucuro on Friday December 25, 2020 @12:27AM (#25534427)
Now that's a good idea - where I work, our security policy is such that I should be able to destroy any (company) computing equipment an end user is using and the loss of data should be restricted to their unsaved changes. A test like you propose would be a very memorable reminder for information security awareness, and so might be really effective before infrastructure upgrades if restricted to people with hardware about to be phased out, you need to nuke old hard drives at that point anyway...
Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by jcims on Friday December 25, 2020 @04:09AM (#25535294)
Not exactly related but 7-8 years ago a company in the region had a major virus outbreak. There was some kind of zero day worm running through their environment and despite having updated endpoint protection they still got got.

They didn't feel they had any choice but to hire about 50 temp folks from a local contracting company and run through the entire desktop environment and pull drives, re-image, reinstall. They did this over the course of a weekend and on Monday when employees came back they found their desktops wiped clean. Within an hour the site lead started getting calls and visits from panic stricken employees that had kept all sorts of personal info on those machines...photos, emails, documents, etc.

All gone.

They ended up missing one machine that got powered up that Monday and re-infected the entire campus. Had to do the same thing again.

Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by inerte on Thursday December 24, 2020 @08:35PM (#25533406)
How about gov sec launching nuclear attacks on every major country?
Re:GoDaddy employees told they were getting a holiday bonus ... by leetcrew on Saturday December 26, 2020 @10:26AM (#25543959)
some people run scripts that deliberately kill prod nodes at random to test for resiliency.