News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by heyrhett on Sunday May 15, 2011 @06:17PM (#2550930)
Since the author didn't bring this up, I think that the biggest technical problem with bitcoin is that it takes 10 minutes to verify a transaction. It can't be used in real stores until someone figures out a way to get that down to under a minute.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by shazow on Sunday May 15, 2011 @07:24PM (#2551077)
You can include a transaction bounty (traditionally 0.01 BTC) with your payment which the verifiers receive if they're the first to verify your payment. Effectively, this puts your transaction at the top of the priority queue. When you're connected to a healthy number of peers, this can bring down the verification time down to seconds.

Another approach is to have "trusted sources" which are Bitcoin banks/ewallets. If your customer is using a Bitcoin bank like eWallet to send a payment, you can pretty much assume that the transaction is valid based on the source, without verification.

Either way, this is merely a short term problem. As more Bitcoin infrastructure springs up (more banks, more verification hubs, more incentive on transaction fees rather than mining, when mining gets too expensive) then these problems will be organically mitigated. If the Bitcoin infrastructure were to remain the way it is now forever, it won't scale for many other reasons (like requiring peers' wallets to store significant transaction history that could grow at the rate of gigabytes per hour with "real world" volume).

Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by arst on Sunday May 15, 2011 @08:38PM (#2551221)
You can include a transaction bounty (traditionally 0.01 BTC) with your payment which the verifiers receive if they're the first to verify your payment. Effectively, this puts your transaction at the top of the priority queue. When you're connected to a healthy number of peers, this can bring down the verification time down to seconds.

Isn't transaction verification tied to block generation, and isn't block generation limited to about 1 every 10 minutes?

Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by shazow on Sunday May 15, 2011 @08:49PM (#2551235)
Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think transaction verification is tied to generating new blocks.

From how I understand it, verification involves:

1. Confirming the privately-signed transaction against the public key of the source wallet (transactions not forged).

2. Confirming against the historical transaction chain that the coins actually belong to the source wallet (coins not forged).

3. Passing the verified transaction along to other peers.

Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by Groxx on Sunday May 15, 2011 @09:13PM (#2551268)
The generating of new blocks is what sets the transaction "in stone". And the more blocks past a transaction's inclusion, the harder it is to reverse that transaction - more blocks = more certain you have actually received the money.

Prior to being included in a block, it's entirely possible for the payer to issue the same money to multiple recipients. Once it's in, it's assured that only one is included, and others are therefore invalid. So it's in recipients' best interests to wait for a few blocks before totally accepting something as "paid".

Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by shazow on Sunday May 15, 2011 @09:27PM (#2551301)
Ah that makes sense. Thanks for the explanation.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by Groxx on Sunday May 15, 2011 @09:10PM (#2551266)
It is. Transaction fees are (theoretically) supposed to provide incentive to be a block solver, and the solver can choose what transactions to include and what to ignore, so it's in their best interest to include ones that have fees. As usage increases, this means more and more work for the solvers, so they're more likely to drop things they can't make money on.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by eof on Sunday May 15, 2011 @06:18PM (#2550932)
People accept checks..

edit: When someone sends you a transaction, it registers more or less immediately. It is only the confirmations in the blockchain (that happen every ~10 minutes) that give you confidence that the coins were not double spent.

Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by ceejayoz on Sunday May 15, 2011 @06:20PM (#2550936)
Checks have legal penalties for passing fakes. Not so for bitcoin.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by eof on Sunday May 15, 2011 @06:32PM (#2550957)
I was really just commenting on the technical side. From a technical standpoint bitcoins are far more convenient than checks; which have been successful by any measure.

There is no reason there couldn't be a law that says "it is illegal to attempt to defraud merchants by trying to double spend bitcoin."

From a technical standpoint, if you send me a payment and I have no reason to mistrust you (similar to my accepting a check for payment), seeing the payment show up in my account immediately is pretty satisfactory.

Further if it becomes a problem, services similar to clearcoin could pop up; allowing users to 'store' coins in a trusted third party, like a generalized escrow-service that companies could trust.

So unlike clearcoin which has coins transfered per-transaction, they might offer a service where you can just store your coins there, and business will trust unconfirmed transactions from clearcoin; thus they wouldn't have to trust you.

Really though, I doubt it will become any more of a problem than bad checks are.

Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by ceejayoz on Sunday May 15, 2011 @07:53PM (#2551138)
> There is no reason there couldn't be a law that says "it is illegal to attempt to defraud merchants by trying to double spend bitcoin."

There's a big reason - government hostility to bitcoin.

Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by caf on Sunday May 15, 2011 @08:29PM (#2551201)
For such a law to be operative, you would have to give up the anonymity that bitcoin transactions allow.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by rprasad on Sunday May 15, 2011 @07:49PM (#2551130)
Which still brings us back to the fundamental flaw of bitcoin: it is a fiat currency without a fiat.

If bitcoin transactions are only trustworthy in jurisdictions with laws governing such transactions (i.e., none), it is safer and more convenient to simply use the local currency. And of course, governments will not voluntarily protect transactions in competing currencies.

Bad checks are an enormous problem. One of the reasons that merchants favor credit cards, despite the high transaction fees, is that the incidence of non-payment fraud is both lower and less costly. If Bitcoin is susceptable to nonpayment fraud, it is a non-starter as far as widespread adoption is concerned.

Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by DenisM on Sunday May 15, 2011 @07:11PM (#2551041)
Fraud is fraud, no matter the medium.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by ceejayoz on Sunday May 15, 2011 @07:51PM (#2551135)
Sure, but if the government is indifferent or actively hostile, good luck getting restitution.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by wtallis on Sunday May 15, 2011 @08:15PM (#2551177)
Are you saying that you think a court would dismiss a civil suit over a bitcoin transaction, or did you just fail include the scare quotes around "the government"?
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by ceejayoz on Sunday May 15, 2011 @09:38PM (#2551319)
Government antipathy could range from being uninterested in prosecuting criminal fraud to actively outlawing the currency. If it's outlawed, you've no more chance getting a civil suit through than the nitwits who call the cops when someone stole their marijuana.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by DenisM on Monday May 16, 2011 @01:03AM (#2551714)
Government is not a singular entity. The courts will generally judge a civil lawsuit, even if executive branch hates the subject with a passion. In fact, many of the lawsuits are against the government, and they get heard. All you need to do is show that you were wronged, and you can sue, and have your day in court. Of course if you open yourself up to criminal prosecution (which could be if legislative outlaws bitcoins, directly or not) then it's best not to pursue that route.

But that doesn't matter, government is not the only entity that can resolve conflicts. Online reputation management, trusted third-party processors (escrow), the mob, and insurance companies can all reduce fraud to manageable size.

Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by DenisM on Sunday May 15, 2011 @07:10PM (#2551038)
This is easy to do - a payment proxy company will spring up that will accept buyer's bitcoin payment and remit a different bitcoin to the seller, minus their commission. That payment company will pool the risks, develop profiles for users they trust more, develop technical and other expertise to predict and prevent fraud etc. The seller will then work only with reputable payment proxies to instant payments, or directly with buyers who don't mind waiting.
Re:Betting on Bitcoin: Fundamentals vs Technical Analysis by Groxx on Sunday May 15, 2011 @10:02PM (#2551364)
That's largely solved by intermediaries, though. Much of our current economy can be re-created on top of Bitcoin. In this case, a credit card like intermediary would guarantee the transaction once they saw it, providing insurance against duplicate spending, so the recipient can get their money regardless.

Intermediaries kind of defeat part of the purpose of a decentralized system, but very very importantly, they're optional with such a system.