Russia and, certainly, China, would still be 'adversaries' if they became liberal democracies because that would not change the geopolitics, diverging interests, and views.
Likewise for Turkey. The key is that it is currently pursuing a policy of assertiveness as a regional power that clashes with the interests of other NATO members.
A submarine blockade can, like the one employed by Germany in WW2.
That would change if Russia is not your enemy, but the entire raison d'etre of NATO is to prevent war with Russia.
Sure it does: as with most UN “legislation” it would be adopted by the GA adopting treaty text and member states signing and ratifying the treaty.
> or any power to back it up.
That is the more relevant problem, especially since most of the UN’s power comes through...military alliances supportive of UN goals.
A UN with teeth wouldn’t be a very good discussion table.
While it hasn't worked out all that well in practice, if you read the charter carefully, the UN is, among other things, a military alliance with a unified military command.
Historically and mathematically military build up leads to war. There is no point in military alliance unless you intend to use it. I say that peace has (almost) prevailed in Europe despite of NATO, not because of it
Mathematics has nothing to do with it. And historically, military draw down also leads to war.
Or, a better explanation might be, historically, passage of time leads to war.
My point exactly. Say that wars break out naturally with some Poisson-like distribution. When the war breaks out, the scale of it is gonna be in relation to the current arsenal of the warring parties.
So given your comment, I can revise my comment to say:
Historically—and mathematically—military build up leads more devastating wars.
Although that is not entirely true. As if nations didn’t hold militaries, there wouldn’t be wars between nations.
Whether Turkey should be in NATO is hard to say without having a deep understanding of the situation. Turkey staying in NATO has pros and cons.