* Prismatic Schema, immensely popular, was "replaced" by spec, which is not yet complete and still in the research phase
* leiningen (one of the best language tooling out there) was "replaced" by Clojure CLI that can't do half of what leiningen can
* transducers (a brilliant concept) are not easy (as in close at hand) because the code is quite different to normal lazy-sequence based code (I wrote a library [1] to address this)
I still prefer Clojure for all my side projects, but it is very clear that the community is tiny and fragmented.
In general I agree that it would be best if a small community does not spread itself too thin, but on the other hand, can't Hickey, Miller et al work on what they are interested in? They have published rationales for why those "splintering" works are of interest and they make sense. It seems incongruent to happily use a tool that was born out of an opinionated design, and then complain when the authors keeps pushing their opinionated PL design.
[0] https://github.com/thi-ng/umbrella/tree/develop/packages/tra...
Every time I need to use another language outside of Clojure, it feels like most other languages are... confused. A bad case of "designed by committee" experience.
Just out of curiosity, what do you mean by this? I've never used Clojure, but have done a fair bit of hacking in other Lisp dialects. Do you (or anyone with an opinion) think there's some insight benefit to Clojure specifically vis-a-vis Racket/Scheme/etc?
Racket extends Scheme with useful stuff too for everyday programming but Clojure's immutable data structures with its big library of functions for manipulating them in a nice abstract generic way, with the fact that in runs in the JVM gives it a big edge for "real world" programming IMO. You do need strong knowledge of Java and the JVM for critical services.
Almost all your knowledge of Racket and Scheme will transfer and be valuable for Clojure, so you already know most of it and have a big head start if you plan to learn it.
* immutability with persistent data structures
* csp with core.async
* encourages designing a data-driven functional core with an imperative shell
* powerful REPL (better than python / scheme / racket, worse than SBCL)
* multi-platform (backend / browser / mobile through react native)
* easy and comprehensive testing because of several factors: functional nature, dynamic binding of vars, generative testing, etc.
Last time I used Clojure (probably 5 years ago to be honest) the lack of static typing combined with the functional nature made complex imperative code (which you're sometime forced to write, and there are examples of such code in standard library) almost impenetrable.
Odd, I can just step through my code with Cursive if I need to.
"Debugging clj / cljs is hardpartly due to transducers" -> "I can step though my code with cursive" -> "how does cursive handle transducers?" -> "you don't need a debugger"
In scheme, the srfi-158 based generators are slower than my own transducer SRFI (srfi-171) only in schemes where set! incurs a boxing penalty and where the eagerness of transducers means mutable state can be avoided.
Now, I know very little clojure, but I doubt they would leave such a relatively trivial optimization on the table. A step in a transducer is just a procedure call, which is the same for trivial generator-based laziness.
IME (admittedly in a different context, doing UI development) Clojure's seqs and other immutable data can be a huge performance drag due to additional allocations needed. If you're in a hot loop where you're creating and realizing a sequence immediately, it's probably much faster to bang on a transient vector. Same with creating a bunch of immutable hash maps that you then throw away; better to create a simpler data structure (e.g. a POJO or Map) which doesn't handle complicated structural sharing patterns if it's just going to be thrown away.
Transducer's would help in the author's first case to take the map/filter piped through the `->>`, which is going to do two separate passes and realize two seqs, and combine it into one.
I understand that there might be some overhead to creating new sequence objects, but removing intermediate sequence object creation should be simple, at least for built in map-filter-take-et-al.
Edit: I seem to be wrong. People are recommending transducers over clojure's lazy map-filter-take-et-al because of overhead, which to me seems off, but there might be something about clojure's lazy sequences that I haven't grooked.
Take the case: (->> (for ,,,) (map ,,,) (filter ,,,))
`for`, `map` and `filter` will all create lazy sequences, holding a reference to the previous one. The problem here is when the `filter` seq gets realized, it will first realize the `map` seq, which will realize the `for` seq. Each sequence will wait for the next one to realize before iterating over it. So in this case it will iterate twice; once for the `map`, and then again for the `filter`.
As you know, transducers combine these steps together so that you only iterate over the initial collection once.
My other comment was making the point that the author has conflated "laziness" with "immutable data" AFAICT. The lazy seqs in the first example they give will be slower w/o transducers, but the other problem is that the overhead from all the allocations required for creating a bunch of immutable hash maps that are then destroyed immediately after is also non-negligible, and seems to be a source of the authors performance problems.
So you never really iterate over more than one collection; you only have one iteration where you successively ask each generator to produce a single element and then apply a function to it. For example, if you only asked for the first element of a lazy sequence formed by a series of maps, you would (in theory, in practice see my note about chunks) never iterate over any of the intermediate sequences and only ever examine the first element of each of them.
However, the act of asking a generator to produce an element (that is unwrapping a thunk) has overhead of its own and that's the overhead that a transducer would be removing (not iteration itself in the case of lazy sequences). This can have far more overhead than a procedure call because of bad cache locality (in the absence of fusion optimizations you're pointer chasing and potentially generating garbage for each thunk). Clojure tries to get around that by often (but not always) chunking its thunks, in which case we do have multiple rounds of iteration on smaller chunks, but never the entire sequence (unless the entire sequence is smaller than a chunk).
Does clojure's sequences not work similarly? That seems like a very lax definiti
A write-heavy system would benefit Java mutable collections out of the box. Clojure can get pretty close to Java with transients and a good dose of type hinting in all the right places.
When we say "faster" or "slower" it's equally important to specify "faster" or "slower" when and where. It's a complex question with no easy answer.
Why would Java be slower in a read-mostly regime? Your hypothetical is not convincing. Btw, you mention "real" and then move on to "hypothetical" as an example.
Are there actually OSS "production" cases of this subset of systems where Java lags behind Clojure in performance?
> When we say "faster" or "slower" it's equally important to specify "faster" or "slower" when and where. It's a complex question with no easy answer.
These sort of subtle distinctions only matter to langauge wars and debates like this. For actuals systems that need to do work and need to be maintained, we can in fact have metrics on efficiency.
That said, fundamentally, Java affords much greater facilities to "optimize" and approach white hot performance than Clojure.
Because of Clojure's default persistent in-memory data structures which allow you to obtain a stable reference to your in-memory data even when the data is being updated live. With Java's default mutable data structures, you'd have to use locking or copying to obtain a stable reference, not to mention the huge complexity of those solutions. I said real because I've built similar solutions in Clojure. Substitute "hypothetical" with "example", sorry for the word confusion.
> That said, fundamentally, Java affords much greater facilities to "optimize" and approach white hot performance than Clojure.
Taken to the extreme, the resulting Clojure would not be idiomatic, it would be effectively Java-in-Clojure, but Clojure has all the facilities that Java has, by definition.
Regarding "complexity", not sure what you mean. IIRC, someone, possibly even me ;), may have pointed out to Rich Hickey in the early days that Java code could also use those (Java or was it Scala) STM libraries. So, there is your "complexity" behind an API, just like Clojure.
> Clojure has all the facilities that Java has, by definition.
Ergo, a situation where Java can -not- be made as fast or faster than Clojure code seems unlikely.
I think all we have here is you claim of "complexity". I remember Rob Pike making a comment along the lines of "prefer libraries over language semantics" or something like that in context of Go language design. I find it a very compelling argument, based on my overall experience to date.
Another idiomatic way to improve performance are transients[0]. From the outside your function is still a function, but on the inside it's cheating by updating in place instead of using persistent data structures. See the frequencies function for a simple example[1].
Clojure and Rust are both very expressive languages and even though they both can be considered niche, they have _massive_ reach: Clojure taps into JVM and the JS ecosystems, Rust can also compile to WASM or be integrated with the JVM via JNI.
The big difference between the two, and why I think they complement each other nicely, is that Clojure is optimized for development, and does its best at runtime, but Rust is optimized for runtime, and tries its best at development. (A similar take in the article). In other words: they both achieve their secondary goal well, but resolve trade-offs by adhering to their primary in the vast majority of cases.
[0] https://clojure.org/reference/transients
[1] https://github.com/clojure/clojure/blob/clojure-1.10.1/src/c...
I also noticed that you mentioned avoiding lazy sequences is not idiomatic in Clojure. I disagree with this since using transducers is still idiomatic. I wonder if you could've noticed some speed improvements moving your filters/maps to transducers. Though I doubt this would get you to Rust speeds anyway, it might just be fast enough.