And right, it's professional usage where that would fall short, I doubt that it would help as much when the image file I open fills the ram completely or when parts of the IDE are swapped away.
Maybe if you're solely focused on performance.
But the other reason why M1 is so ground breaking is because it offers this performance with ~2x the battery life and minimal cooling compared to its competitors.
> Given the little chance Intel or anyone else is going to keep up with this new level of performance
"All of the technologies in the SoC can access the same data without copying it between multiple pools of memory. This dramatically improves performance and power efficiency. Video apps are snappier. Games are richer and more detailed. Image processing is lightning fast. And your entire system is more responsive."
Of course if you need 12 GB of data in memory than sharing 8 GB won't be enough but for most current uses of 16 GB its possible that 8 GB could feel as responsive between the shared memory and the faster access speeds (due to faster components and smaller distances)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heterogeneous_System_Archite...
It's easy to type a comment about bad decisions and garbage, but the world doesn't work in terms of absolute truths, the decisions we make are made under certain circumstances and the success of the results is subjective. I risked something, I know it, so far I'm happy with my choice.
Given how overpriced the bigger memory configurations are I understand why you took that risk.
The earlier parts of my comment just reflect my impression that you overestimate the performance of that laptop compared to available alternatives. 10x faster is just not accurate. Remember the context: A huge group of Apple fanboys that buy everything the company produces without being aware of the alternatives and drawbacks. That's why it feels important to point out misconceptions like that, whether they are really there or just the interpretation.
For $1000 the base model Air is a hell of a machine.
People sometimes forget that macOS has had automatic RAM compression since Mavericks (10.9) [1]. Think about how fast this must be using Apple's SoC combined with the extremely fast SSD at 2190 MB/s writes and 2675 MB/s reads. With compression, the effective speed is at least double.
It would take a whole lot for there to be any appreciable slowdown running lots of apps simultaneously with 8 GB of RAM.
[1] https://www.lifewire.com/understanding-compressed-memory-os-...
That's Spotlight indexing the email, PDFs, Word files, etc. on your hard drive. Once it's done, your Mac will be much more responsive: https://www.macworld.com/article/3388134/spotlight-dont-take...
That's what I'm thinking.
Having said that, according to the article "Intel’s Disruption is Now Complete" discussed in HN before, Intel's lowest end of Celeron CPU line was introduced just to delay the inevitable [1][2]. But what the article did not mention is that Intel purposely crippled its low end CPU with the minimum amount of RAM. Until very recently the most RAM you can get with Celeron based processors is only a few GBs. However, perhaps due to the competition of AMD and other ARM based manufacturers, Intel has done the unthinkable and with the latest Gold processor series (11th Gen) you can have up to 128GB of RAM [3][4]. FYI, the Gold processor series is conveniently placed in between the Core and Celeron back in 2016 and essentially it's a beefed up Celeron. Not only that, it can now supports Optane, a new Intel's proprietary non-volatile or persistent memory technology that can provide its lower end CPUs with potentially more than TB of working memory [5]. Imagine using a tablet/PC/home server in the year 2021 having an equivalent of humongous terabytes of RAM!
[1]https://jamesallworth.medium.com/intels-disruption-is-now-co...
[2]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25092721
[3]https://newsroom.intel.com/news/iot-processors-industrial-ed...
[4]https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/199288/...
[5]https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/architecture-and-tec...
And then likely 2022 we see the M3 chip for the Mac Pro, Mac mini Pro and iMac Pro.
I think Mac has their own, but I use NoMachine and it basically just works and can work with different client and server OSes. On the client side it is just video decoding so it is not very demanding - and it uses less bandwidth than I would think.
Yeah, that line made me take the entire review less seriously.
"All of the technologies in the SoC can access the same data without copying it between multiple pools of memory. This dramatically improves performance and power efficiency. Video apps are snappier. Games are richer and more detailed. Image processing is lightning fast. And your entire system is more responsive."
What if you are barely using that GPU though? Wouldn’t most the GPU RAM just be wasted while you did CPU intensive tasks?
Likewise in your example you might be using the GPU more so less RAM could now be allocated to the CPU to improve GPU performance by more efficiently using the available RAM
Outside of the CPU, you're really not using the other processors for "many tasks."
In the end, honestly, I don't care that much if it's the processor, RAM, or a pixie dust. The machine's snappy whatever I do on it and that's all that matters. I'm happy with my choice so far, but only time will tell, of course. If you do RAM-intensive stuff on your computer and have the money, buy RAM, good for you.
But this isn't completely true. ARM compiles down to significantly smaller binaries than x86, because it doesn't have to support legacy extensions.[1]
[1] http://web.eece.maine.edu/~vweaver/papers/iccd09/ll_document...
That's naive and wrong. The M1 seems to be an excellent processor with good performance. It's not worlds better than a Ryzen 5 5600X or its mobile variant.
> I decided I don't need more RAM than 8 GB, because nobody from the first reviewers managed to give the RAM a hard time. It seemed to me it's a different beast altogether and it doesn't make sense to just compare numbers and say that more is better.
The processor is not a magical thing that changes how much memory is needed for workloads. When the first reviewers did not look at your workload it's meaningless that they did not complain.
Your memory requirements completely depend on your workload. It's quite possible you do not use more than 8GB, but I had IDEs and GIMP use more than that. And it's of course (it's Apple) not upgradeable, 8GB will not be enough if your usage changes, and then that laptop will just be expensive garbage for you.