Re:I Have Resigned from the Google AMP Advisory Committee
by muro on Friday December 18, 2020 @03:26PM
(#25471489)
Of course. The parent argument was that the time spent differently would have the same effect. Many years of crappy slow mobile pages show differently.
Re:I Have Resigned from the Google AMP Advisory Committee
by afavour on Friday December 18, 2020 @07:55PM
(#25473950)
> The parent argument was that the time spent differently would have the same effect.
Again, no. The argument was that time spent focused on page performance would have the same effect. If Google punished slow pages in rankings that is all the incentive needed, not the creation of an entirely new platform.
Re:I Have Resigned from the Google AMP Advisory Committee
by muro on Saturday December 19, 2020 @04:39AM
(#25476342)
Ah, I missed that, thank you. I'm still not convinced it would make so much of difference, but it's definitely more likely. Any good examples out there of sites which optimized for speed and achieved similar results?
I think the point you're actually making is that without AMP forcing these sites to be faster, they would still be slow. Which I agree with. But as I said in my original post, Google ranking sites according to their performance would have the exact same effect as forcing AMP on people, except that it would let sites choose their own implementation rather than be strong-armed into one controlled by Google.