News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by sreejithr on Friday December 18, 2020 @09:39AM (#25467493)
Does this mean information can be transmitted faster than light speed?
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by pontus on Friday December 18, 2020 @09:53AM (#25467620)
No, while entanglement acts instantaneously across a large distance, there's no way for that "signal" to carry any information. In order to complete the teleportation the two parties must somehow communicate in order to convey an additional piece of information. This communication would be classical and slower than light.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by boie0025 on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:51AM (#25468196)
This reveals my severe ignorance about quantum mechanics; but I've always wondered if entanglement could be used to transmit binary data by way of timing and presence or lack of presence of a transmission. So maybe every 1ms is a position, and either something is sent or not.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by roywiggins on Friday December 18, 2020 @11:42AM (#25468819)
You can't. There's a theorem and everything. If there is some way to do it, QM must be wrong.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by boie0025 on Friday December 18, 2020 @12:41PM (#25469677)
Thanks for the link; I had no idea what to even search for to understand this.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by walkerbrown on Friday December 18, 2020 @12:41PM (#25469676)
Thank you. For me, this clears up a long held misconception.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by tgb on Friday December 18, 2020 @11:24AM (#25468567)
Quantum teleportation is a process that both sender and receiver have to coordinate. Part of that coordination is that the sender measures 2 classical bits of information on their entangled qubit and transmits those two classical bits to the receiver. Then the receiver uses those two bits to perform certain operations on their half of the entangled qubit pair in such a way that their qubit is now exactly the same as sender's original qubit. As you can see, there's no way to use timing in this, other than the timing of the classical bits being transferred.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by jv22222 on Friday December 18, 2020 @05:58PM (#25473120)
Whey can't they just have an agreed upon stop point?

Like, keep parsing the incoming information until you see a period (for example).

(I know it's not using actual characters, just using the idea to illustrate the point).

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by thwd on Friday December 18, 2020 @06:44PM (#25473508)
You have a box with random garbage in it. I have a box with a football in it. We entangle the football and the garbage. You stand far away from me. If you randomly open your box now, you may either see a football or random garbage. If I call you on the phone (classically) and tell you to open the box tonight at precisely 8:12pm, you're guaranteed to find a football then and hence, I will have the garbage.

There's no parsing; it's all or nothing.

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by Mizza on Friday December 18, 2020 @09:59AM (#25467686)
Any chance that communication could happen _before_ the measurement?

Entangle some matter, give half of it to the space team and then have inter-stellar walkie talkies?

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by pontus on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:12AM (#25467808)
In some sense the two systems that are entangled are connected instantaneously. The problem is that the information doesn't reside in either system but rather in them as a whole. So, if you were in space with one part of your "walkie talkies" you wouldn't be able to make sense of the information unless you have access to the other system. This access would usually occur through some slower than light channel.

Imagine that you have 2 coins and give one to someone on earth to flip and one to someone on the moon to flip. The outcomes in either location is random 50/50, but interestingly they are perfectly correlated (H<->H, T<->T). When you flip a coin you don't have the ability to pick it's outcome. The only thing you can pick is whether or not to flip it at all. So, imagine you want to communicate one bit of information from earth to the moon and decide that a 1 will be encoded as "flip the coin" and 0 as "don't flip the coin". When you're standing on the moon and want to reveal the information you flip the coin and see e.g. H. There are two ways this could have happened: either the earth coin had already been flipped and showed H or the earth coin had not yet been flipped and you just randomly got a H. In other words, the outcome by the flip is useless by itself.

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by cambalache on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:36AM (#25468040)
No communication is possible BUT, I have this toy scenario where a "quasi-communication" may be possible in FTL speed.

"2 generals command 2 armies hundreds of km apart. They want to attack a common enemy, there are 2 options, A) And all-front attack. B) From the flanks. The generals want the plans to remain uncertain until the last second before the attack. So from an intermediate point, they send two "entangled coins" , one to each general, the coins will arrive at both sites at the exact start of the battle.Both will show the same face when "measured". The generals have agreed previously that if they turn out "heads" they will both attack from the flank, in the other case, they will do a front-attack.

Of course you dont need a quantum system for this, you could have agreed on other stuff (like it if it is raining that day at certain place or sending a framed coin by regular mail) but I think the quantum solution is the more elegant, assuming no 3rd party snooping.

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by roywiggins on Friday December 18, 2020 @11:41AM (#25468801)
There are game theoretical proofs that show that you can use entanglement to enable better-than-classical performance on games that reward cooperation but disallow actual communication.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_pseudo-telepathy

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by bluesign on Friday December 18, 2020 @01:09PM (#25470006)
Sorry but this example doesn't make sense, how it is faster than light?
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by Poc on Friday December 18, 2020 @03:06PM (#25471283)
It is not faster than light. I think what he wanted to show was a situation, in which entanglement and quantum mechanics, are superior to classical physics. i.e someone using quantum mechanics would have an advantage over someone who don't.

However, as he said, in this situation the two generals could have agreed on something else, like if it was raining or not.

In fact, something they could have done is to flip a coin, and split with a copy of the result, which they only look at when they launch the attack. It would have the same effect.

With a random variable (the coin flip), that is hidden until revealed, we achieve the same results as quantum mechanics.

Scientist call them "hidden values" and Einstein hopped we could explain the "spooky action at a distance" with such hidden variables. But we can't, Bell proposed an experiment with entangle state which measurement could not be explained by such hidden variables, and Aspect did the experiment and obtained the predicted results.

So there exist situation where we can use entanglement to achieve better results, for example in "non-local games", where players sharing entangled state can win with probability 1, when "classical player" with probability < 1

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by cambalache on Friday December 18, 2020 @07:13PM (#25473678)
> In fact, something they could have done is to flip a coin, and split with a copy of the result, which they only look at when they launch the attack. It would have the same effect.

Yes but the difference is that in this case, the plan already exists from the moment the coin is flipped until the result is revealed to the generals. In the QM case no one (not even God) knows what the result will be until it is actually measured,but once that happens the result is known "instantly" at both places (assuming both coins arrive at the same time), so in that sense is a FTL communication (of course it is not real communication)

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by Poc on Saturday December 19, 2020 @04:01AM (#25476201)
Ah yes, you're right, I hadn't seen it from that angle.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by bluesign on Friday December 18, 2020 @03:37PM (#25471622)
“ So there exist situation where we can use entanglement to achieve better results, for example in "non-local games", where players sharing entangled state can win with probability 1, when "classical player" with probability < 1”

Do you have an example for this? This is really interesting

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by roywiggins on Saturday December 19, 2020 @12:34AM (#25475355)
It's called "pseudo-telepathy." The wikipedia page has an example of a game:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_pseudo-telepathy

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by _underfl0w_ on Friday December 18, 2020 @02:47PM (#25471091)
I think key is that both generals have already agreed on a predetermined "meaning" of each coin flip outcome, rather than having to communicate it on a different, slower medium after the coin has been flipped.

So really it just front-loads that portion (I.e. removes it from consideration as part of the proposed solution) instead of allowing it to slow down solving the overall problem. It requires precomputation/agreement beforehand, rather than during the time allotted to the problem.

The speed of that precomputation would still be unchanged, and still be the slowest portion.

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by cambalache on Friday December 18, 2020 @07:45PM (#25473886)
Yes of course that is why it is not real communication, but in a sense is better than a classical solution because nobody actually knows the final decision until the last second. Of course you could get philosophical and say that an enemy can intercept the quantum coin and measure it, thwarting the plan, so in that sense is the same thing that sending just a pic, but then you will be pulled by the same kind of discussion the physicists has spent the last 100 years doing. Check for example the correspondence between Einstein and Born https://www.amazon.com/Born-Einstein-Letters-1916-1955-Frien...
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by cambalache on Friday December 18, 2020 @07:34PM (#25473801)
The "communication" of the final decision is FTL. If you choose a non-QM method, like checking it if rained in some place or using the pic of a flipped coin, that final decision can only be "communicated" at a sub-luminar speed.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by roywiggins on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:10AM (#25467796)
You can't use entanglement (on its own) to communicate at all.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by moron4hire on Sunday December 20, 2020 @01:45AM (#25484439)
What's funny to me is that this topic comes up A LOT. Like, people hear about entanglement, and then decide they are smarter than those dumb physicists and have figured out FTL communication in 15 minutes.

Why is that? This keeps happening. Quantum entanglement is not a new concept. It's almost certainly older than 99.9% of the people on this site. Yet the myth that it could enable FTL communcation continues to persist.

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by magicalhippo on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:09AM (#25467773)
The whole point is the other party needs to know the result of your measurement, and you don't know that before you measured (otherwise the particles wouldn't be entangled).
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by lemonspat on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:35AM (#25468030)
I think OP is asking, can you entangle, measure, discuss, and then go travel to another galaxy with real time communications?

Edit: or can the communication only happen once and then you need to remeasure over classic communication?

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by magicalhippo on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:49AM (#25468174)
> travel to another galaxy with real time communications?

As I said, no. How would you relay your measurement results in real-time? Without those measurement results, the receiver would in essence just hear white noise.

That's the perplexing part of entanglement. Somehow it feels like information is instantaneously transferred from A to B, yet the information content is somehow zero so can't be used for proper communication.

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by lemonspat on Friday December 18, 2020 @01:19PM (#25470116)
So you have to measure every time you want to transmit?
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by magicalhippo on Friday December 18, 2020 @03:50PM (#25471791)
No, you have to transmit every time you want to transmit.

When measuring one particle of an entangled pair and you get say "spin up", you know immediately that if someone measures the other particle (with the same measurement settings) they'll get "spin down", and vice versa.

The chance that you get "spin up" or "spin down" is 50/50 and, as far as we know, cannot be affected or determined in advance.

So, on the receiving end, they measure some random combination of "spin up" and "spin down". Without anything else, this information is for all intents and purposes noise.

What you can do however, is to send a message using regular means with what you measured: "up, down, down, up, down". Ok, at least now they can check that what they got was the exact opposite. However that still doesn't tell them anything.

So instead what you do is that you change the measurement settings, and send via regular means not just your measurement results but also your measurement settings. So you'll send "H left, V down, V up, H left, H right". The recipient will then take the measurement settings (H or V) and measure the entangled particles in the same way you did, and then note down that they get the opposite.

Note now that you suddenly got a way to communicate some actual information. By agreeing in advance that a Vertical measurement means 0 and a Horizontal measurement means 1, you can send information to the recipient.

However also note that you had to make a measurement of your particles and then send the results using regular means, limited by the speed of light. So why bother with this complicated setup? Why not just send the data without all this entangled stuff?

And indeed, for just sending plain messages it makes no sense to use entangled pairs.

However as I noted in my other post, the inability to clone entangled states means an eavesdropper can be detected using the entangled setup.

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by lemonspat on Friday December 18, 2020 @04:18PM (#25472166)
That was a very clear explanation, thank you. So all my grand ideas about how quantum communication might work are now sadly dead
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by magicalhippo on Saturday December 19, 2020 @06:26AM (#25476743)
Yeah, it seems we're doomed to pay the price of time.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by rodiger on Friday December 18, 2020 @01:55PM (#25470524)
There is no "transmission." When you measure you learn the state of one of the particles, and you can use that information to deduce the state of the other (which until measurement is indeterminate). You can see that this information is useless unless communicated classically.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by djxfade on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:48AM (#25468166)
So what can this really be useful for?
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by dodobirdlord on Friday December 18, 2020 @02:43PM (#25471042)
Another response already mentioned one aspect of how this can be used for secure communication, for detecting signal interception. But there’s a second aspect as well. Since the signaling is broken up into two parts (send the entangled state, send the measurement result), both parts have to be intercepted to decode the communication. The entangled state can be sent over a secure channel in advance, and the measurement sent over an insecure channel at the time of information transmission. This is analogous to sharing a one-time pad in advance, but the key distinction is that the no-cloning theorem guarantees that it’s impossible for someone to have stolen a copy of your one-time pad. They can only have stolen your one time pad, in which case you would notice.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by magicalhippo on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:57AM (#25468298)
I'm no expert, but AFAIK one thing is secure communication, in the sense that the recipient can detect if anyone is eavesdropping.

As I've understood it, to "listen in" the eavesdropper has to destroy the entangled state by measuring it, and there's no way to perfectly clone the entangled state before doing that.

The recipient can compare the entangled data with the measurement results (sent via classical means) and detect statistical inconsistencies if there is an eavesdropper.

edit: I see their page[1] mentions quantum metrology, which I found reference to in a page[2] describing work to improve GPS and similar detection using quantum entanglement. Not sure if it's directly related but seems like there should be room for some interesting work using this quantum network in this area.

[1]: https://ieqnet.fnal.gov/

[2]: https://news.engineering.arizona.edu/news/quantum-entangleme...

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by pif on Friday December 18, 2020 @11:03AM (#25468360)
Yes and no.

Yes, information can travel with infinite speed.

No, cause-effect relationship cannot travel faster than light.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_nonlocality

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by kazinator on Friday December 18, 2020 @11:19AM (#25468521)
> Yes and no.

Could a QM answer be otherwise?

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by mhh__ on Friday December 18, 2020 @11:42AM (#25468821)
The idea that QM means anything can happen is a popular misconception, at a very basic level the probaility P(X) of X happening can quite happily be zero.
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by rodiger on Friday December 18, 2020 @01:57PM (#25470544)
I think this was more a joke about superpositions than "anything can happen"
Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by moron4hire on Friday December 18, 2020 @09:51AM (#25467612)
No. Long range quantum networking means that guarantees on the security of communication between quantum computers in the network can be made. Short range means that quantum compute clusters can be made, to make quantum computers that can process more qubits.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_network

Re:Sustained, high-fidelity quantum teleportation by mathgenius on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:31PM (#25474743)
Correlations are "transmitted" faster than light speed. You could call this information. Quantum information theory is way more complicated (and many open questions) than Shannon information theory.