News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @05:18PM (#25461255)
So that's how games are being seen by the gamedevs :) It was interesting - would be interesting to read something like this also about the RTX-parts, their description sounds so great - I hope they will some day show us the new horizon in rendering. Hope it's not just marketing cheap trash like it was with DLSS.

I have RTX card and I see (pretty noticeable) difference when I turn on RTX reflections and shadows in Cyberpunk, but I can't see what is the difference in RTX-lightning.

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by mhh__ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:49PM (#25462068)
DLSS is game-changingly brilliant if it continues to improve.

"DLSS is just [an approximation]" is a common comment, but it's bollocks because everything in a modern game engine is an approximation to some underlying phenomenon. Even raytracing is basically a bunch of noise to our eyes before the magic makes it viewable.

Is it perfect? Of course not, but being able to fake detail that our eyes don't take issue with could be enormously helpful to smaller game studios who can't achieve the same results - I'm specifically thinking of flight simulators which often don't run very well, where 60% of the pixels on the screens are effectively filler (Terrain, Clouds etc.)

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @07:00PM (#25462164)
You really said nothing to change my opinion. Saying "brilliant" about this pile of garbage is just ridiculous. I don't care how complicated technology, I care about the result. I see results from the RTX-reflections - they are great and it's not some kind of trick or simplification or "optimization for performance". I see the opposite about DLSS - huge FPS boost, but the price is upscaling which looks like cheap upscaling. You can do the same in many games, even old games, using a "rendering resolution" setting or something named like this. I would be happy to jump into the wagon of those who love the new shiny tech called DLSS, but for that, I need to see opposite results. Right now it's a disaster.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by mhh__ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @07:02PM (#25462178)
But it doesn't look like cheap upscaling.

It's that simple, try the fidelityfx options if you want to see what bad upscaling looks like.

DLSS will let people run games who otherwise wouldn't be able to afford to play them, end of argument.

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @07:07PM (#25462212)
It does look like cheap blurry upscaling. I was trying to be respectful to the opinion of people who love it, but you can't be respectful to my opinion. You are saying ”doesn’t look cheap” and ”can’t afford” in the same comment - think about this. You don't need to be a rich person to buy 3070/3080 - smartphones are less affordable nowadays.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by NikolaeVarius on Thursday December 17, 2020 @07:14PM (#25462255)
No it doesn't

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ggro8CyZK4&t=931s

It looks amazing, possibly more detail than native

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Friday December 18, 2020 @02:26AM (#25464682)
What a ”proof”, muhaha. Let’s play this game together:

https://www.reddit.com/r/cyberpunkgame/comments/cxqm1u/every...

https://www.reddit.com/r/pcgaming/comments/aqmffc/is_dlss_ju...

https://www.gog.com/forum/cyberpunk_2077/cyberpunk_is_really...

I have 3 times more ”proofs”! :)

It's ridiculous how you can’t just accept mine ”ok, let's disagree”. Looks like it touches some really important side of your souls ;)

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by c0de517e on Friday December 18, 2020 @06:37PM (#25473465)
Author here.

DLSS is not the end-solution to rendering, well, nothing is, but it's an AMAZING piece of technology. All these temporal and dynamic resolution techniques are here to stay as they -improve- the look of games no matter the HW.

What do I mean? Obviously dynamic resolution and temporal reprojection are worse than say, a fixed 8k rendering at 240hz! Yes, true! But, that's not the correct math.

The more correct math would be, on a given hardware, say a 3080, would you rather spend the power to render each single pixel exactly, or would you rather "skip" some pixels and have smart ways to recover them for a fraction of the price, almost equal to the real deal, so now you have extra power to spend somewhere else?

Of course if you just do less work with DLSS or similar technologies, you're losing something, it's bad. But that's never the equation. The real equation is that no matter how powerful the HW, the HW is a fixed resource. So if you spend power to do X, you cannot do Y, and you have to chose whether or not X is more valuable than Y.

Makes sense?

Now, all that said, it's also true that sometimes you max out everything in a game, you cannot have more of anything because that's literally all the game has to render, and at that point sure, it's reasonable to spend power even in things that are not that great bang-for-the-buck because literally you cannot do anything else anyways! So for the very top PC HW, you end up doing silly things, like rendering in native 4k because you cannot use that power in any other way.

But that's in a way "bad", it's a silly thing that we have to do as there is no other option! If we had the option though, it would be much better even on a 3080 to render say a 2k or 1080p upscaled to 4k via DLSS, and use the remaining power to say, have 2/3 times the detail in textures or geometry or number or shadow-casting lights etc etc...

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Sunday December 20, 2020 @06:04AM (#25485411)
> almost equal to the real deal

Here is our disagreement. For my eyes DLSS is unacceptably blurry (even in ”Quality” mode). You can look at it - ok, but it's only one of the opinions. You can spend 1 minute in google to find quite contrary opinions. Whole your long comment is based on the idea that upscaling is an optimization - you are forgetting that upscaling is a tradeoff.

My main complaint about DLSS ”hype” marketing is exactly about this: do not promise ”incredible quality” when under the hood it's just a pity upscaling. Some HW is not good enough, some games are not optimized enough - it's fair and it's okay, there are things to sacrifice, there are workarounds. Just don't lie.

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by c0de517e on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:17PM (#25489171)
Respectably, I don't care about "your eyes" - all people are different and that's ok. Nor I care -specifically- about DLSS, obviously technologies are always evolving, it's not that DLSS is the best ever that the concept can be. Also its implementation varies among games.

What I meant to say is that we live at a time where rendering every single pixel all the times is simply a waste of resources - that can be better spent somewhere else.

And you're still saying it's "blurry" - that's not the point. Certainly temporal reprojection will -always- be blurrier than not using it. But you're not considering what you're -gaining- by that blur. The real question is - would it be better to say, have a world with 1 million objects at 4k, a bit blurry, or a perfectly sharp image, at 2k, with 100k objects...

Temporal reprojection saves time that then can be invested in other things.

Lastly. CP2077 ALWAYS uses temporal reprojection. ALWAYS. If you disable DLSS it uses its own TAA instead. If you disable TAA (which cannot be done in the settings menu, but there are hacks to force it) is STILL USES temporal for most of its rendering before the final image.

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Sunday December 20, 2020 @05:56PM (#25490389)
> all people are different and that's ok

I'm happy to see at least one person on HN can agree with this.

After re-reading your and my comments I concluded that my real issue is lack of the settings in CP2077. I do respect opinion of people who want to use TAA and DLSS, I’m just upset that I can not pick something I like, can’t decide what to sacrifice and what to prioritize.

Your article is quite interesting and I’m grateful for it. Please keep writing things like this.

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Sunday December 20, 2020 @06:10AM (#25485445)
To let you better understand me: I have vomiting calls when I remember how TAA+DLSS image looks. I just can't force myself to use it, it's like torture. FPS drop or aliasing are much smaller problems.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by mhh__ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @07:16PM (#25462261)
You can literally buy a perfectly functional car for the price of a 3080
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @09:19PM (#25463075)
And 2 of them for a phone!
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by lame-robot-hoax on Thursday December 17, 2020 @08:35PM (#25462792)
A 3070/3080 is only one piece of the puzzle, unlike a smartphone.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by ramidarigaz on Thursday December 17, 2020 @05:20PM (#25461282)
Disagree about DLSS being cheap marketing trash. Especially on the quality or balanced settings, it produces a significant framerate improvement in Cyberpunk without any noticeable quality loss.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @05:39PM (#25461462)
Ok, let's disagree. Quality loss is non-acceptable, image is blurry as hell. DLSS is just stupid upscale.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by knowaveragejoe on Thursday December 17, 2020 @05:57PM (#25461640)
I'm going to have to side with the other poster here as well. Enabling "DLSS" on auto significantly improved framerate without noticeable quality loss(to me). I'm on a 2070 Super running "high"ish settings @ 1440p.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by EugeneOZ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:04PM (#25461687)
Ok, people are different, demands to image quality are different. I'm playing on RTX 3090, 1440, 27''. All max settings except DLSS.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by corysama on Thursday December 17, 2020 @07:14PM (#25462251)
DLSS is just smart upscale. As far a upscaling goes, it's pretty amazingly good.
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by mhh__ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:50PM (#25462077)
Blurry as hell is the FidelityFX options, DLSS looks fine but still noticeable.

Perspective

Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by takeda on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:47PM (#25462045)
Linus talked about it and other settings: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kK45BxjSLCs
Re:Hallucinations re: the rendering of Cyberpunk 2077 by friedman23 on Thursday December 17, 2020 @08:12PM (#25462637)
You probably wont get convinced by what anyone here is saying so just watch this video from gamersnexus where they nitpick everything about dlss and their conclusion is that you should run it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zUVhfD3jpFE

In some instances it add detail, in other instances it removes detail.