News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by xiphias2 on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:14PM (#25459139)
Is there any reason to invest in it instead of jusr buying Bitcoin?

I remember the ,,thin protocol vs thick protocol'' comparisions that said that for Internet it was worth investing in the companies over the internet, as with Bitcoin, just buying it can give a better return.

Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by ve55 on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:24PM (#25459268)
Coinbase is more about the ecosystem than BTC itself. It's likely that BTC doing well is good for Coinbase, yes, but they stand to benefit from many other things, including other cryptocurrencies, more users adopting it (while the price may not increase), and other areas like custody services, decentralized finance services, and whatever other products they're still working on.

Ideally (from the perspective of Coinbase) they end up offering an absurdly broad range of services to consumers in the entire sphere of cryptocurrency, similar to how some banks don't just let you hold money with them, but may offer 10 different services as well, from exchange to lending to credit to trading and so on.

Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by Melting_Harps on Friday December 18, 2020 @03:09AM (#25464948)
> Coinbase is more about the ecosystem

And making it worse for people who simply don't know any better and catering to high-net worth people? Amazing business model.

> Ideally (from the perspective of Coinbase) they end up offering an absurdly broad range of services to consumers in the entire sphere of cryptocurrency, similar to how some banks don't just let you hold money with them, but may offer 10 different services as well, from exchange to lending to credit to trading and so on.

So, they're a bank? The very incarnation of Bitcoin's persona non grata ever there ever was one.

The apologists around here trying to suck off YC and VC money teet may be more complaint, but I hope this new wave of customers goes to Square/CASH (an easier transition since so many already have it on their phones) in order to steer them to companies that do actual meaningful work in this ecosystem, instead of act as a parasite as Armstrong and Coinbase do.

Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by xiphias2 on Friday December 18, 2020 @08:33AM (#25466867)
We need companies like Coinbase, I think they provide great value, although what they did with the BCH push and trying to centralize Bitcoin was a huge overreach.

Bitcoin is stronger than the current financial system, so I'm not afraid of companies that bridge the two systems.

Personally I stay with Bitcoin, as it has a monopoly position, unlike Coinbase that has great competitors for all their important products at this point.

Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by Melting_Harps on Friday December 18, 2020 @08:04PM (#25473989)
> We need companies like Coinbase, I think they provide great value, although what they did with the BCH push and trying to centralize Bitcoin was a huge overreach.

They once served as training wheels, but we have moved on from needing Coinbase a long time ago, and now they're a drag on over all UX of onboarding new users as they quickly realize how intrusive, invasive and altogether bad the experience is with delays, transactions being reversed, and accounts being frozen or canceled arbitrarily.

It's clear their focus is operating as an investment/bank platform for wealthy investors, see Microstratgey's position, but it remains to be seen what they have done in the last 5 years that isn't antithetical to the values of the Bitcoin community as they simply cancel accounts they deem invalid (wikileaks), they sell information to 3rd parties and banks and the IRS, they serve as gatekeepers into a walled garden system that plays judge/jury/executioner if you transact with what they deem to be 'inappropriate' wallets.

The list goes on, but over all we're worst off having them associated to Bitcoin at all at this point and we would be better off if Armstrong just focused on alt trading entirely as it seemed we had finally achieved getting rid of a lot of deadwood with the bcash fork. Sadly, most of us in the Community are actual staunch advocates of free market enterprise and commerce so we cannot do to them what they do to others out of sheer principal.

To this day the best exchange in my opinion was BTC-e, it served as the axiom of what we wanted most from an exchange which is to simply work, and despite all the hallmarks of being a massive exit scam they were the most honest of all until it got shutdown in 2017: its very telling the FBI/DOJ went after an anonymous Russian (Online only really) based exchange for 'money laundering' at a time when neither the SEC or the IRS considered Bitcoin 'money' at all. This was after having jailed Ross Ulbrich for Life plus 40 for simply hosting a website and acting as middle man and HSBC was caught red handed laundering money for the mexican drug cartels and they walked away with a fine.

Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by xiphias2 on Saturday December 19, 2020 @10:40AM (#25478029)
The great think with Bitcoin is that it's a Trojan horse: Coinbase and the whole world can act like it's following all AML rules, can be controlled by IRS, and can create arbitrary blacklists. It's better to give regulators the feeling that they are in control, as this way they allow people to ,,hack'' the current financial system.

What Microstrategy did with getting $650 million debt with 0.75% rate and moving to Coinbase institutional Bitcoin storage is to use the vulnerability of the current financial system that was used by bankers for a long time for financing wars to finally do something good and move us closer to a non-debt based financial system.

What matters is having the option of total freedom, not using it all the time. Sure, I could make anonymous payments with Bitcoin if I really wanted, but as long as the laws don't get to the levels of gold confiscation, I'm OK with being 100% legal and being tracked.

Ross Ulbrich was not using the fact that Bitcoin is a trojan horse: don't talk about the vulnerability of the central banking systems, just use all the legal tools and loopholes it gives and get rich.

Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by gruez on Thursday December 17, 2020 @03:13PM (#25459794)
> Is there any reason to invest in it instead of just buying Bitcoin?

"In a gold rush, sell shovels"

Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by kylebenzle on Thursday December 17, 2020 @04:28PM (#25460689)
Yes! Bitcoin (the BTC chain) got it's GitHub repo hijacked years ago by corporate interests and the company Blockstream. The whole concept is a dead end and they are actively trying to push people into using their "second layer" solutions to the congestion and problems they have introduced.

People like Greg Maxwell and Adam Back were able to kick out the original maintainers and are hell bent on making Bitcoin not work.

Bitcoin Cash is the closest thing to "Bitcoin" now but Blockstream employees an army of Twitter and Reddit trolls to block any real discussion. Greg is basically a one-man-army himself at this point.

Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by cheaprentalyeti on Thursday December 17, 2020 @05:21PM (#25461292)
I just checked... it's about three to four years post-fork, and the size of the "Bitcoin" blockchain (as you call it) is (minus indexes) about 315 Gb. The size of the Bitcoin Cash blockchain is roughly 170Gb.

I don't know what it was when they forked, but it should have been the same size.

The people you accuse of hijacking Bitcoin seem to have a much higher transaction rate since the fork than the Bitcoin Cash team has achieved.

Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by sna1l on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:17PM (#25459169)
If another cryptocurrency rises to overtake Bitcoin, or even just grow larger, Coinbase will profit from that (assuming they support it) vs Bitcoin.
Re:Coinbase announces confidential submission of draft regis... by xiphias2 on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:49PM (#25459549)
Bitcoin was made more and more secure over 10 years by disabling every feature that was not necessary to make it a digital store of value (like addition/substraction as they could overflow). If there are new ways to take away even more features from it, I'm not sure why they couldn't be taken away from Bitcoin as well to improve its security.

Ethereum is a complementary to Bitcoin that's a more complex and less secure, less scarce store of value, and it's much more about running complex financial contracts.

As these protocols have strong network effects that give their value, it's really hard to just ,,overtake'' them.