News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by svachalek on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:13PM (#25446016)
This reads like a textbook example of "correlation is not causation". You think there'd be ...some? people talking about how they decided not to have a child because she/he wouldn't fit in the car if it's going to have a measurable effect on birth rates but at least personally I have never, ever heard this one.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by munificent on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:21PM (#25446165)
I have elementary school age kids, so I know lots of parents. Anecdotally, there is a big jump between having two kids and having more than two. I've had a lot of conversations with friends on their third pregnancy about having to upgrade to a bigger car because with the size of car seats, you can't fit three of them in one row of a typical sedan. And I've likewise had conversations with parents who decided (like my wife and I did) to stop at two, and many of the reasons are fundamentally about logistics and resources. Transportation is a real component of that.

If you take a step back, it does make sense. The difference between zero kids and one is a major qualititative lifestyle change. It's the transition from parent to non-parent. It means not easily going out at night, schooling, etc. Everything changes.

The transition from one to two kids is a qualitative change for the kid because it means going from no siblings to siblings. That transitively makes it somewhat of a qualitative change for parents. It means the kids always have a playmate and someone their age on vacations. But for parents, it's mostly a change in degree. More work, more cost, more time parenting, but the overall lifestyle is basically unchanged.

The transition from two to three is really just quantitative. 33% more space in the house for sleeping, 33% more food costs, 33% more car space for transportation, etc. So the decision about when to stop is mostly just "how much of this experience do you want?" The transportation overhead here in the US where you do a lot of driving is a pretty big piece of that.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by drfuchs on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:33PM (#25446354)
"Going from two kids to three, you have to switch from one-on-one to zone defense."
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by _carbyau_ on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @10:23PM (#25452068)
:-) I only have one. And we think we'll have a second and leave it at that. Partly for the reason of not wanting to be outnumbered.

But also partly from a social/environmental point. Two kids means we replace ourselves when we die.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by mensetmanusman on Thursday December 17, 2020 @08:38AM (#25455424)
But you don’t replace your bachelor uncle, which is why on average the population replacement rate is greater than 2. :)
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by _carbyau_ on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:51PM (#25462080)
Yeah. But the population has to stop growing sometime. And could do with coming down a bit. We take care of ourselves, let others do the same. If they choose NOT to have kids, then the numbers come down.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by arwhatever on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:50PM (#25446672)
> The transition from one to two kids is a qualitative change for the kid because it means going from no siblings to siblings. That transitively makes it somewhat of a qualitative change for parents. It means the kids always have a playmate and someone their age on vacations.

... Or fightmates, as my mother herself warned me. :-)

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by lucretian on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:52PM (#25451835)
> The transition from two to three is really just quantitative.

not from the perspective of the women who bear the health risk.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:27PM (#25446259)
I absolutely buy the step-wise argument, especially for housing, but I do not buy it for cars. Americans buy way more large SUVs and trucks than the rest of the world, even those with fewer than three kids (or no kids). The idea that car size is a meaningful barrier to the number of children one has, especially compared to housing and education costs, simply does not pass the sniff test to me.

From a pure financial standpoint, I'd look more to the cost of education, healthcare, and housing. All of which have been growing much more rapidly than the cost of cars or gasoline.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:56PM (#25446757)
> Americans buy way more large SUVs and trucks than the rest of the world, even those with fewer than three kids

Having had two kids in the age where they needed large car seats, trucks are no help at all and even fairly decent sized SUVs don't handle more than two well. Car seats for young children are a significant issue, and I suspect almost anyone whose had two or more children under the current safety regime would both recognize that fact and likely consider it before intentionally having a third.

> From a pure financial standpoint, I'd look more to the cost of education, healthcare, and housing.

Young children don't necessarily have a big impact on housing costs (they can share some easily), often because of the structure of health insurance costs don't have much impact on healthcare costs after the first, and education costs are largely deferred if you aren't going private/homeschool. Day care costs / career impacts are probably more significant than any of those given the frequency of two-working-parent families, but car transportation logistics are quite palpable.

(“Source”, have two kids under 5.)

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @10:46PM (#25452211)
> Having had two kids in the age where they needed large car seats, trucks are no help at all and even fairly decent sized SUVs don't handle more than two well.

Nonsense. They don't fit your seats maybe, but that's not the same as it not being possible. 15 seconds of Googling finds tons of lists with car seats that'll fit 3 across, including tests for a Honda Civic. Some on the list include convertible ones that'll work up to 120lbs.

Bigger SUVs might be more convenient, especially when loading and unloading, but the idea that you can't fit three car seats into a larger vehicle is simply not grounded in reality.

> Young children don't necessarily have a big impact on housing costs (they can share some easily), often because of the structure of health insurance costs don't have much impact on healthcare costs after the first, and education costs are largely deferred if you aren't going private/homeschool. Day care costs / career impacts are probably more significant than any of those given the frequency of two-working-parent families, but car transportation logistics are quite palpable.

My understanding, at least from people I know with 3 or more children, is that daycare and career costs dominate, depending on your location. All my colleagues had to decide between paying out the nose for city daycare, punching an even longer gap in someone's career (obviously reducing earnings), or simply not having a third.

Well, except for that one colleague who had five. According to him logistics got very expensive very quickly. Even "cheap" flights for a family of seven hits the $1K mark very quickly.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by souprock on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:46PM (#25459520)
There is a natural ceiling on the costs for daycare and career, at 100% of the mother's income. It can't get worse than that unless you just like to pay money, because the mother can care for the kids.

Having 2 or 3 kids in a city is probably the worst plan. Costs are high, but not not quite high enough to make the career obviously a mistake.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by christinamltn on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:03PM (#25461678)
100% plus future losses that could be attributed to loss of career progression during those years. I’ve known people who paid nearly 100% of their salary to childcare after tax but determined it would be countered by future raises and leave them in a better position long-term.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by souprock on Thursday December 17, 2020 @06:51PM (#25462084)
Future losses are included in the 100%. My assumption is 100% of lifetime salary. One can easily blow past that with a large family.

There is probably an unspeakable truth behind the people you've known who pay nearly 100% of their salary to childcare. Not every parent really likes their children. Getting away from them might be a bonus, even if it can't be admitted.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by simmonmt on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:38PM (#25446440)
It's probably a mistake to put "SUVs and trucks" all in one bucket. Can you even fit a third car seat in a crew cab pickup, assuming two adults in the front?

See https://advocacy.consumerreports.org/research/the-rise-of-th...

That massive green chunk is for crossovers, which typically have space for two adults and two car seats. Fitting a third means graduating to a full-size SUV (or minivan), which means a significantly more expensive vehicle (assuming similar trim levels, etc).

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by cstejerean on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:58PM (#25450982)
I’ve never tried but I’d be shocked if I couldn’t easily get 3 car seats across into my F350. The rear bench is much wider and can fit 3 adults across comfortably.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by munificent on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @02:41PM (#25447455)
> Americans buy way more large SUVs and trucks than the rest of the world, even those with fewer than three kids (or no kids).

Trucks are a mostly useless metric here. Many of those are work trucks, and most won't fit car seats for three kids. While Americans buy lots of SUVs, many Americans do not have one, and for those, transporting three kids is indeed a challenge.

> From a pure financial standpoint, I'd look more to the cost of education, healthcare, and housing.

Housing definitely comes into play, but I don't think the other two end up being major factors in the decision because they are so far out. In the US, you literally cannot leave the hospital with your baby if you don't have adequate transportation and an approved car seat. So Americans are made acutely aware that they need to have a transportation solution for their family right now before choosing to have a baby.

Healthcare is a non-issue for many because their employer-provided insurance covers as many kids as they have. Education is somewhat far down the road and fairly fungible so it's less likely to be a showstopper.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by thrower123 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:36PM (#25446410)
Even in a full-size SUV, you can't fit three car seats in one row of the back seats.

Combine that with requirements to keep kids in various car seats and booster seats until they hit arbitrary age and weight limits, which stretch out longer and longer all the time, and it's still a problem.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @02:06PM (#25446919)
Here is a list of car seats that'll fit 3 across in a F-150. https://www.thecarcrashdetective.com/3-across-installations-...

Several on that list will fit children up to 57-62" in height and up to 120lbs.

This (https://www.thecarcrashdetective.com/diono-radian-r120-revie...) seat will fit 3 across in my Subaru Forester, a Honda CRV, or a Fiat 500L, and support a kid up to 57" tall and 120lbs in weight.

It might be more convenient to have a three row SUV with three kids, but the idea that you can't fit 3 seats in these cars is nonsense.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by fosap on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:20PM (#25446140)
Please RFA.

"The reduction they saw was confined to households that did actually have access to a car"

"They discovered that tightening these laws had no detectable effects on the rate of first and second children".

Also, if i understand it correctly, you have about 50 quasi experiments, one for each state.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by Nacraile on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:45PM (#25446575)
Please RFA more ;)

"the third-child deterrent appears stronger among wealthier families"

So this has both the most and least effect on families that have little reason to care about needing a bigger car (because they can easily afford it, or they can't afford any car at all, respectively). When you go fishing for a correlation, form a post-hoc hypothesis for its mechanism, and then other data fits that hypothesis poorly, it's a strong sign you've found yourself a red herring. Which is the usual result of failing to properly understand the distinction between correlation and causation.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by souprock on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:58PM (#25446797)
With increasing wealth, per-child cost goes up. It's self-imposed of course.

Getting a larger Porsche or BMW or Mercedes is going to be harder than getting a larger used Hyundai or Kia. At the extreme, you're just out of luck; there is no Ferrari with more than 4 seats.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:23PM (#25459252)
Most well-to-do families that I know drive a very large SUV as their secondary car, often a Q7 or a Land Rover.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by imron on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:15PM (#25450627)
> You think there'd be ...some? people talking about how they decided not to have a child because she/he wouldn't fit in the car if it's going to have a measurable effect on birth rates but at least personally I have never, ever heard this one.

We have 3 kids. When talking to friends with only 2 kids, this comes up all the time and is a non-trivial concern in having a third child.

You need a bigger car, a bigger house and bigger everything, and many things are not geared towards families of 5 - family passes at museums/zoos are often 2 adults + 2 children etc.

When we had our third we upgraded our car (from 5 seats to 8 seats) and our house. If we had a fourth we'd need to upgrade the house in a few years again. It's definitely a concern and is definitely talked about by people who are affected by it.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by megablast on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:02PM (#25451474)
This is good news then. We should be thinking hard about having more kids. 2 is more than enough. The damage each extra child does, especially in the west is insane.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by Robotbeat on Thursday December 17, 2020 @01:31AM (#25453192)
Speak for yourself! After past generations have screwed over the world, my kids are going to have to be the ones to fix it.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by milesvp on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:51PM (#25446679)
I wasn't going to have more than 2 kids, partly for reasons around travel logistics, and car seats play a surprisingly large role in that. Car seats needs to be rear facing until children are big enough, but most cars expect everyone to be leaning back and so rear facing car seats can be tricky for tall drivers. Part of our planning involved spacing children so we'd only have 1 rear facing car seat at a time. I'm tall enough that I can't have a rear facing car seat behind me in most cars (even SUVs). If I hadn't had twins the second go round my calculus would have stuck. Instead we had to get a minivan.

Now I'm not saying this is a strong effect nationally, the effect wasn't particularly strong for me since other costs were a bigger deterrent than a new car payment, but there is an effect and I'm sure I'm not the only one who did that math.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by watwut on Thursday December 17, 2020 @05:42AM (#25454366)
> personally I have never, ever heard this one

I did and find it completely normal? "What everything we would have to buy" is completely normal consideration. So is "if we dont fit in a car we need to stop doing all these things" is another completely normal consideration.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by rm445 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:49PM (#25446646)
I've heard it, and said it, pertaining to not having a fourth child. Semi tongue-in-cheek but having to buy a van would be one extra inconvenience.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:24PM (#25446206)
Just to reinforce your point: the idea that Americans are deciding not to have children because they can't fit modern child seats in their cars is outright laughable. Americans drive massive cars compared to the rest of the world; if there is any society where car size would not prove to be a hindrance to having children it would be America.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by kube-system on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:33PM (#25446362)
It is not easy to fit three car seats in the back of seat of the average vehicle in the US.

I bet this is not a hinderance in the rest of the world because many of those other places have either:

1. a lack of child seat laws

2. effective public transportation.

It's not like Europe is full of A-segment cars with 3 car seats in the back.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:58PM (#25446806)
The median vehicle in the US is fully capable of seating three child safe seats.

Yes, if you get a Honda Civic you're going to struggle. But sales of sedans are absolutely swamped by SUVs and trucks. The best selling car in America by a long shot is the F-series pickup truck, with about 900,000 units sold. You can easily fit three child seats in it[0]

Oh, the number two and number three best selling vehicles are the RAM 1500 truck and the Chevy Silverado, at 633k and 575k. The Silverado is a bit smaller, but it too will fit three seats[1] across. You have to get to number eight in the list before you find a sedan at all, the Toyota Camry. You have to get to nine and ten on the list before you start finding sedans that would get uncomfortably tight fitting three seats, specifically the Honda Civic and Toyota Corolla, and even those will fit three if you're careful in your shopping. The top selling car that I'm pretty comfortable you simply could not fit three car seats in is the Nissan Sentra at number 19, with only 184k sales last year.

Now, 184K sales isn't nothing. There are clearly cars sold in America that will not fit three car seats. But the sales of those cars are dwarfed by large trucks and SUVs. In 2019 Ford sold more f-series trucks than the top three sedans combined. And that's before we consider the sales of three row SUVs which can easily fit 4-5 child safe seats in them.

So, if Americans are willing to buy massive vehicles capable of seating three seats safely by the literal millions, how in the world is that consistent with "the cost of upgrading to a car capable of seating three seats is a major barrier to having more children"?

0 - Here's a list of all the child seats that'll fit three across in a F-150: https://www.thecarcrashdetective.com/3-across-installations-...

1 - https://www.thecarcrashdetective.com/3-across-installations-...

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by kube-system on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @02:14PM (#25447080)
Looking at vehicle total sales figures is a very bad way to determine what families drive. Those numbers you cite include corporate fleet sales, which heavily skew domestic truck sales figures. Nor are all of those trucks in a crew-cab configuration.

But yes, even many mid-size cars and SUVs are difficult to fit three seats in.

https://www.consumerreports.org/car-seats/how-to-fit-child-c...

> we assess a vehicle’s ability to securely and easily accommodate three child restraints in the second row. Our test results have shown that unless you’re driving a full-sized crew-cab pickup truck or an Audi Q7, the installation is going to be difficult, if it's even possible.

(It is kind of funny that your source shows a picture of a single cab 97-03 F150 in regards to fitting child seats three across... :D )

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by pandaman on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:26PM (#25451636)
You assume any SUV is automatically the size of Suburban so you skipped over CR-V and RAV4, which should be just under the tucks in any best selling vehicles list? They do not have much more passenger room than a Civic (more headroom but the size and distance between the seats is basically the same). A "compact SUV" is a thing.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @10:34PM (#25452133)
There are plenty of car seats that’ll fit 3 across in a CR-V. There are plenty that’ll go 3 across in a civic, although the lack of trunk space for strollers would obviously be an issue with three children. You can’t buy any random car seat, of course, but an ounce of up front research will help you pick one that’ll fit.

I find it kind of perplexing how many people pretend that you simply cannot put 3 child seats in a small SUV, it’s incredibly trivial to Google and find ones that will fit. This isn’t rocket science, I found a site that’ll list which seats will fit 3 across in which cars in the first hit on Google.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by DanBC on Thursday December 17, 2020 @11:06AM (#25456811)
Which Civic are you talking about? Here's a review that shows they can only really fit two seats (and this car only has two ISOFIX fittings on the outside seats).

https://babydrive.com.au/reviews/hatches/2017-honda-civic-vt...

> Installing child seats came with a few difficulties too. I could fit two child seats in the Civic in the outer back seats, there was not enough room for a middle child seat too.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Thursday December 17, 2020 @11:36AM (#25457146)
Obviously not the coupe.

I’m not sure about ISOFIX anchors, but here in the US the LATCH anchor system actually has a relatively low weight limit, typically 40-65 lbs (including weight of seat) depending on how it’s installed. Beyond that weight limit, you’re supposed to skip the anchors and just use the regular seatbelt.

This would be an issue if you have 3 children that need rear facing seats. But given that we typically transition kids into forward facing seats between 1-4 years old, realistically you’d need twins or triplets before this is a necessity. A parent with 3 kids could attach a seat in the middle via seatbelts for the oldest child, and use the anchors on the outside seats for the younger child.

Not as convenient as a 3 row SUV, I’ll agree. But far from impossible.

https://www.thecarcrashdetective.com/3-across-installations-...

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by pandaman on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @11:24PM (#25452436)
The problem is that you don't just put child seats into the car for fun - you are supposed to put children in them too. Children are not going to teleport in and out and they need to crawl/be put in their seats. The middle seat will be a hard reach in a compact.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Thursday December 17, 2020 @10:58AM (#25456712)
That is a wholly different argument from “they won’t fit”.

I absolutely agree that a larger vehicle is more convenient for people with 3 or more kids. But that isn’t the argument people have been making in this thread. The assertions it that you can’t fit 3 car seats in these cars, an assertion which is provably false.

Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by pandaman on Thursday December 17, 2020 @12:34PM (#25457835)
I don't see anybody making the argument that no 3 child seats can fit in a compact car, I've only responded to your post claiming that Americans drive giant cars and using the bestseller list as a proof.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by ashtonkem on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:22PM (#25459235)
Read the rest of the thread.
Re:Child-safety laws may reduce the birth rate by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @06:55PM (#25450434)
> 1. a lack of child seat laws

Not even lack of, just less need to have three children in them at once.