I imagine it's IBM leadership that decided this one.
"It's unclear how restricted that free version will be"
Probably not directly restricted. Just restricted in the sense that it won't be an LTS type distribution that matches RHEL's LTS product, package versions, etc. That was the value prop for CentOS.
This is IBM signaling that the good-ole' days are in the past. If you want to run RH stuff, they will get their pound of flesh. If you're not paying, you are not something they're concerned with.
When the corporate tone projected externally changes, that usually signals more than just a product change.
1. Red Hat was no longer the "go to" platform for anything
2. IBM was absolutely desperate
All the kerfuffle just made me move to macos. Now I'm looking to move back...
Sounds like a great opportunity for Ubuntu and SuSE to pick up market share as the CentOS replacement.
Compared to Ubuntu, it tends to be more conservative and better tested on server or workstation hardware. What finally drove me away from Ubuntu was a very painful episode when the SAS driver would freeze randomly about 4 times out of 10 when loading. It is also far less opinionated than Canonical regarding which desktop you should use. The main drawback is that OpenSUSE Leap is supported for 2 years, so no equivalent to Ubuntu’s LTS releases.
OpenSUSE also uses systemd, but this should not be a shock for someone coming from Red Hat. It works decently with nVidia’s proprietary driver. Well, as decently as this garbage can run, anyway. I haven’t tested Wayland, as AFAIK XFCE still requires X.
So if that's the case, what's the difference between a free RHEL without a commercial support contract/license and CentOS other than Red Hat not having to maintain those IP-related changes for CentOS?
The alternative scenario that most people seem to be assuming, where there will be no free RHEL or RHEL-like OS, seems impossible to me as somebody somewhere will just recompile RHEL source and release it under a new name just like CentOS did before. And of course Red Hat knows this.
The difference is that a free RHEL without support doesn't exist, while CentOS does.
You can get RHEL for free through various developer focused programs, but that is most certainly not the same as having an unencumbered ISO available for unlimited downloads with no EULA or sign-in requirement.
Ie. CentOS takes those users who won't pay, RH takes those who will, RH controls both and there's no niche for anyone else.
Evidently I was wrong.
I don't disagree with the sentiment that RHEL also controlling the free alternative doesn't make sense. I do disagree with repeated assertions that people can just use RHEL for free - for the most part, they can't.
But economically speaking, it's cheaper for Red Hat to not pointlessly rebrand their own product. CentOS as a Red Hat-owned brand is stupid.
My comment was focused on the confusion/exasperation at why people keep implying this is no problem, because we can just use RHEL for free, as that is not true.
Why on earth not announce the free RHEL offering now. Or wait until those details are ready to deprecate CentOS 8.
It sounds like some CentOS users might be able to migrate to some free version of RHEL, but it's unclear how restricted that free version will be. Probably good for home users, but how about medium or large businesses? And then, why should anyone even use a restricted RHEL when Rocky will be full RHEL for free.