I often get told unpaid by my friend about cool product because:
a) my friend wants to be viewed as a trustworthy influencer (trustworthy to ad execs) and hopes or expects to be paid later,
b) my friend is unconsciously parroting marketing speak from advertising they have seen,
neither of which are particularly helpful to me.
Stopping these cases would be an additional benefit of banning (or heavily taxing) paid advertising, I would expect it to be somewhat self-regulated.
So, in your examples:
Web banners: yes, Sponsored content: yes, Trade shows: no, Sales rep stopping by: no, clothing with logos: yes if the logo isn't the brand of the clothing itself, Hacker News: I have no idea how this site is funded.
And I don't even vaguely pretend to know where we should draw the line. I just think it should not be where it currently is.
I like to think about these issues because I make a living selling advertising on my website. We try to have use good practices, have the ads be high quality, targeted toward the content as opposed to the user.
On the other hand, I live in a city which does not allow billboard advertising (Santa Barbara, California) and I do enjoy it in comparison to cities with many billboards.
Maybe a "except in the cases where users/readers/individuals can create adverts, and the entire publication is explicitly devoted to such adverts" clause as well. I'm only a business grad, not a lawyer, so I expect it can be framed better than this.
This is how you create hostility toward your product, not desirability.
I am uncertain if you are saying that I was engaging in the behavior you are describing or if you are describing behavior you have observed regularly in discussions like these.
My question was meant more to think about what constitutes an advertisement for the purposes of a hypothetical "50% tax on all advertising revenue" proposed by the parent comment.
i think this is a misfire on my part and should be a reply to [Marcus] up thread.
So I think the goal is to make it not work. Like any other antisocial behaviour that we'd like to tone down in our society - tax the shit out of it.
At least you'd kill the ad supported business model because clarity of the transaction required.
Web banners? Sponsored content? Trade shows? Sales rep stopping by and buying lunch and talking about a product? Clothing with logos? Hacker News?
There are lots of ways to capture people’s attention to build awareness of your business that probably technically fall under advertising but would be quite difficult to regulate in any meaningful way.