There's a good chance Apple wouldn't exist without Microsoft (and vice versa):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Apple_Inc.#Microsoft...
Without Office, etc on Mac the adoption could have been severely limited. Would Apple have had the cash to develop the iPod?
I think of them as competitive symbiotes. Together they are more valuable than the sum of the parts.
Apple's own marketing campaigns targeted at "switchers" tout this fact: http://www.apple.com/why-mac/its-compatible/#office
http://ask.metafilter.com/30833/How-much-of-Apple-Computer-d...
From Apple's 2003 SEC filing:
"In August 1997, the Company and Microsoft Corporation (Microsoft) entered into patent cross license and technology agreements. In addition, Microsoft purchased 150,000 shares of Apple Series A nonvoting convertible preferred stock ("preferred stock") for $150 million. These shares were convertible by Microsoft after August 5, 2000, into shares of the Company's common stock at a conversion price of $8.25 per share. During 2000, 74,250 shares of preferred stock were converted to 9 million shares of the Company's common stock. During 2001, the remaining 75,750 preferred shares were converted into 9.2 million shares of the Company's common stock."
My post is about management, not stock picking.
But given patience and money and a willing seller, I'm sure Microsoft could buy anyone and find a way to get the deal approved. We are talking about a world where Adobe can buy anyone it likes just to kill off their competition.
I am saying that they couldn't have managed Apple if they'd bought it as well as Apple managed Apple, not that they did or didn't invest 150 million in Apple as part of an attempt to weasel out of punishment for their illegal monopolistic behaviour.
Which is, I think, the arch point of Gruber's quip. If Microsoft had bought Apple in 2006, does anyone seriously think Microsoft today would have a dominant position in phones, music players, music distribution, and tablets? Would it have a world-class retail chain?
Moving forward to 2011, people point out that B$8.5 could buy a lot of startups. Assuming that they could identify it, Microsoft probably could buy the next Apple or Google. Heck, they could probably buy it just by trying to buy everything. But does anybody seriously think that if Microsoft does buy the next big disruptive company, it would still be the next big disruptive company?