News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by lucb1e on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:01AM (#25399036)
I'm sad to see HN can't seem to have a normal conversation about anything related to USA politics. Can we try to maintain some sort of reasonableness?
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by tpoacher on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:09AM (#25399110)
I'm pretty sure this is 'normal'. You probably mean 'rational'.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by lucb1e on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:10AM (#25399120)
For HN, I would say that rational is the normal that we hope to maintain.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:08AM (#25399099)
Unfortunately my countrymen are not known for their rational level-headed discourse, and tech workers really aren't inherently better people just because they know computer stuff.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by lucb1e on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:12AM (#25399138)
> my countrymen are not known for their rational level-headed discourse

How does this help? Also it's not about being tech-savvy or not, yes we're all normal people. It's trying to maintain a level of reason on this forum. I'm genuinely interested in what people think of what Twitter does, but the tone of nearly every reply in the thread is somewhere between mildly polarized and extremist/conspiracy theorist.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:19AM (#25399217)
Your post implied that you believed HN users above devolving into political bickering. My reply is meant as explanation as to why that belief is unfounded. Should we be better? Yes, but as long as we aren't banning political discussion entirely it's going to happen.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by lucb1e on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:25AM (#25399276)
It's easy to say that people simply aren't better than this and this will simply continue to happen. I don't completely believe that. I was hoping that writing the above comment might inspire those not already crazed to maintain a more rational tone and perhaps flag and downvote more on the level of "merits the conversation" than "I (dis)agree with this".
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:47AM (#25399498)
> It's easy to say that people simply aren't better than this and this will simply continue to happen. I don't completely believe that.

Trusting in people's good nature alone has never worked. If the community doesn't implement some mechanism to control the activity it doesn't want, then it will be done. You can refuse to believe that if you want, but I think you will find that belief challenged by reality.

Not coincidentally, a mechanism of control for dealing with undesirable behavior is exactly what this whole Twitter thing is about in the first place. Since we've agreed that people here are not inherently better than the general populace, what makes you think that HN is more immune to this sort of thing than a community like Twitter or reddit?

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by lucb1e on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:36PM (#25399945)
We do have some mechanisms to control activity that we don't want, but we do need to be level-headed enough to use it.

> what makes you think that HN is more immune to this sort of thing than a community like Twitter or reddit?

I've always perceived HN as fairly elitist, e.g. composed of many top earners and skilled people. The term is often meant negatively; in this case it might be a positive feature. Reminding people that they're on HN, where I think most expect a higher standard than on Twitter or reddit, might make them try to be better. I'm not saying we are composed of some elite, just observing that it's often perceived that way and that we can actually try to use that notion in a good way, to improve the conversation.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:06AM (#25399084)
I mean, there’s an attempted coup going on. It strikes me as unreasonable to expect a normal, dispassionate conversation on the topic of “the outgoing government says they might refuse to leave”.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by lucb1e on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:14AM (#25399160)
Do you think there are many people here that would support a breakdown of the democratic process, a coup? I'd hope that those people are in the vast minority. You can be passionate about a topic but that's different than extremist. I'm passionate about privacy but it's not like I think that people using Facebook are retarded and write about it in full caps.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by iaHN on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:46AM (#25399495)
> Do you think there are many people here that would support a breakdown of the democratic process, a coup? I'd hope that those people are in the vast minority.

Your naivete is being taken advantage of by bad faith actors.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by lucb1e on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:38PM (#25399969)
This is what I mean. The comment I would have expected to see on HN goes something like:

* This is not true because <some sound logic or data source>

Instead, you just wrote that I'm naive and pretty much left it at that.

Why does this topic make you do that?

(Edit: just noticed that your profile even says you're a data scientist of all things!)

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by iaHN on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:09PM (#25400185)
It's a bit ridiculous at this stage to suppose that those supporting Trump's coup attempt are doing so in good faith.

If you are not an American, I suppose it makes sense that you are not aware of the current political climate. If you are American, then you've been deliberately ignoring the obvious.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by anigbrowl on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:28PM (#25401398)
Do you think there are many people here that would support a breakdown of the democratic process, a coup?

There's enough. Aggregating various recent polling, it seems that about 1 person in 8 is OK with that, and maybe 2 more (for a total of 3/8) are passively in favor - that is to say, they won't do anything about it, but won't object if it happens. You don't need a majority of people to support a coup; indeed, that's kinda why it's such an attractive option to the unscrupulous.

An important problem nowadays is that our media and interpersonal communications take place at lightning speed, but out political technology is many respects still rooted int he 18th century, and our administrative technology covers a span from 19th century unresponsive bureaucracy to 21st century oppressive surveillance. Politics as presently constituted does not work well for a lot of people, and so they are not invested in maintaining the status quo.

Put simply, our economic infrastructure is highly distributed, but power is highly centralized and that makes a lot of people angry.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by NearAP on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:36AM (#25399383)
>>> Do you think there are many people here that would support a breakdown of the democratic process, a coup?<<<

1) Have you taken a look at Parler?

2) The Chair of Texas state GOP has called for the state to secede in the wake of the supreme court ruling

3) Diamond and Silk (and they are famous in the US in some areas) have called for a coup.

4) General Flynn who was once the Director of the Defense Intelligence Agency endorsed a call for Trump to declare martial law and redo the election

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:01PM (#25399634)
While I don't entirely disagree with what you're saying, I think you have to be pretty cautious about looking at social media. You could (and many people I'm familiar with did!) scan Twitter around the time of the Seattle autonomous zone and see lots of people calling for the rule of law to end.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:37AM (#25399395)
Just last week there was a case filed with the Supreme Court, asking them to throw out the election results in Georgia, Pennsylvania, Nevada, and Arizona. (Hopefully we can agree that this would be a coup if it happened?) The President, most of his party in the House, and almost 20 states explicitly endorsed it.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by tetrometal on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:21AM (#25399236)
Challenging the validity of an election is not a "coup". We need these challenges to keep our elections secure. I cheered Hillary for telling Biden not to concede under any circumstances.

The left-biased media was worried about election fraud for months before the election (good!) and are now declaring it the "most secure election in American history" in spite of the broad introduction of mail-in voting.

People living in democracies should scrutinize the hell out of their elections.

https://spectator.us/reasons-why-the-2020-presidential-elect...

https://thefederalist.com/2020/11/23/5-more-ways-joe-biden-m...

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by naiveai on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:30AM (#25399328)
They challenged the validity of the election, and they failed. Yet they continue to insist on fighting a losing battle and possibly refusing to leave the White House.

That's called a coup attempt. A pathetic one, sure. But a coup attempt nonetheless.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by tetrometal on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:33AM (#25399356)
No, they are challenging the validity of the election and have so far failed. This is an ongoing process. You don't get to declare it a one-and-done just because you don't like that it's happening.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by anigbrowl on Saturday December 12, 2020 @03:38PM (#25401487)
To quote Justice robert Jackson on the nature of the Supreme Court, "We are not final because we are infallible, but we are infallible only because we are final."

I agree with you int hat I think people should have a chance to deploy their arguments but you need to bear in mind that there are a lot of people who are willing and able to resort to force in place of argument.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by netsharc on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:39PM (#25403839)
But the challengers have not proven themselves to be honest/trustworthy players so far. They go on camera and claim to have seen "massive fraud" but so far have presented no compelling evidence to the courts, just rambling confused arguments that judges have thrown out...
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by tetrometal on Sunday December 13, 2020 @01:34AM (#25404760)
There are many cases being presented in the courts, by many plaintiffs. I'd be surprised if there weren't some frivolous ones in there. That doesn't mean they all are, and we can't know until they are presented. If your argument is simply "No good case has been made yet, therefore no good case can be made," well, I don't think anyone with sound reasoning skills will agree with that.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by Dylan16807 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @05:16AM (#25405532)
No good case has been made yet, out of a hundred cases. To believe that a good case could be made but they simply didn't is to believe in a ridiculously high level of incompetence of the best minds the president could assemble. It's extremely strong evidence that no good case could be made. It's not 100% but nothing is 100%.
Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by tetrometal on Sunday December 13, 2020 @01:21PM (#25408722)
No, your argument requires that we ignore the fact that good cases may take time to develop.

Consider the Voter Integrity Fund by Matt Braynard. It's one of the more convincing arguments I've heard to date, and involved making many thousands of phone calls, analyzing the resulting data, generating reports, and collecting sworn testimony. All that didn't happen overnight, and they didn't begin immediately after the election.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by netsharc on Sunday December 13, 2020 @08:08AM (#25406318)
>I'd be surprised if there weren't some frivolous ones in there.

But the frivolous ones are being made by a team of "presidential" "lawyers"...

> If your argument is simply "No good case has been made yet, therefore no good case can be made"

That's not my argument, nice effort trying to use your powers of deduction, but I'd take it back to the supplier and tell them it's defective.

> we can't know until they are presented.

So should we give Team Total Landscaping all the time they'd like?

I would bet some money that there was at least 1 fraudulent vote during the whole election. I would bet more money that there weren't that many fraudulent votes that if they were cancelled it would flip the results and give Trump the win. Trump and Giuliani are screaming "massive fraud", which sounds like they have a good case, but they've shown up to the court empty handed. Some have argued "they're just preparing the very good case", geezus christ that's not how that works, and besides, their time is running out.

If a team of astrophycists from a famous university started screaming "Something's happened to the sun, it won't rise tomorrow", we'd pay attention. If we ask them to show us what data they have, but they refuse, and they just continue yelling shit, we'd start wondering if they're still sane. And if the sun rose tomorrow, we'd be more certain that they've lost the plot. Maybe they'd change their claims, still offering no proof, but if the sun still rose the next day...

If a group of homeless people claimed the same thing, we'd probably laugh and continue with our day. Sadly some people are being fooled by a bunch of "homeless" people, probably willingly because they can't admit to themselves that they've been fooled by conmen.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:29AM (#25399316)
Election challenges are fine! If Trump concedes on Monday after the Electoral College vote, I'll happily admit that I was wrong about this issue and I let my paranoia get the better of me.

I think he's made it clear that he will not do that, and election fraud challenges are just the easiest strategy currently available to pursue his objective of staying in power.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by tetrometal on Saturday December 12, 2020 @11:40AM (#25399427)
I think I mostly agree with your first statement. I have a different take on the legal proceedings (there's still the vote count, at which point congress can make challenges, etc.)

But certainly there are limits to how far the challenge can go. I'll be right there LOLing with you if he needs to be bodily removed from the WH. I disagree that he's given any indication that he'd go that far, though. Once his options are exhausted, he'll leave.

Re:Twitter limits users interacting with Trump's tweets abou... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday December 12, 2020 @02:11PM (#25400638)
I'm wholeheartedly glad to hear this. Thanks.