If a almond takes the same amount of water per calorie as a strawberry, does it matter that it has a husk?
No. But it sounded like you were surprised that almonds were so consumptive it the first place. I don't know off the top of my head that they are consumptive relative to any given metric, but it shouldn't be surprising that they are, considering how almonds "work" and how much they are produced in CA.
Especially since you compared against wine. Wine can be extremely drought tolerant; there are wine fields in california that are only watered for the first season of growth and the remaining productive years are sustained by waters from the local aquifers (rainfall).
I think the confusion comes because people don't take calorie density into account.
An acre of grapes produces 375 million calories and uses 2.5 Acreft of water An acre of almonds produces 580 million calories and uses 3 acreft of water Beef is much much worse.
As an aside, Husks take up negligible water in terms of the trees consumption and are not a good indicator. 99% of the water used by nut trees goes into evaporation.
Since you're saying 99% evaporation, I assume for most everything most water follows air flows which through the pareto principle collect to places which don't need water? (& may actively not want water in the case of flooding)
The valuable output of the water (H20) is converted to other molecules (eg sugar, cellulose, ect). You could measure this by the change in plant mass from the start of the season to harvest time.
Some of the water will also seep into the ground deeper than the tree can reach, and some will be lost as evaporated vapor from the leaves and tissue.
This water would is generally gone from the system. This can and cause increased humidity and cloud formation and be blown to different locations. There is some literature on the subject.
https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/hydr/15/3/jhm-d-1... https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00382-008-0445-z
They aren't saying people should go after wine makers for wasting water. They're saying going after almonds is scapegoating. Calorie density will tend to come up in that context because the premise is that vegans are increasing demand for almonds which is squandering water on poor nutrition. This plays on memes about vegan diets being insufficient nutritionally
As it turns out neither almonds nor wine are really to blame for California's droughts. So yes, ferment some alcohol & be merry
IF we use almonds for food, I think it is reasonable to compare almonds to other foods, and ask how much water they use. As such, I used numbers for edible table grapes.
IF the end goal is to to change state policy to make water use more efficient, I think we need to answer the question of why some foods are allowed to use more water than others.
I had Californian almonds in Europe and Asia. I don't get Califarnian beef there. (The beef on offer is usual from places with fewer water problems. There's no big need to conserve water where it ain't scarce.)
So almonds are very visible.