News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wall Street Begins Trading Water Futures as a Commodity by dnautics on Friday December 11, 2020 @12:20PM (#25388140)
why is calorie density your metric of choice, though? Grapes, for example, have a much higher commercial alcohol density than almonds.
Re:Wall Street Begins Trading Water Futures as a Commodity by __s on Friday December 11, 2020 @04:30PM (#25391281)
I think you're missing their point

They aren't saying people should go after wine makers for wasting water. They're saying going after almonds is scapegoating. Calorie density will tend to come up in that context because the premise is that vegans are increasing demand for almonds which is squandering water on poor nutrition. This plays on memes about vegan diets being insufficient nutritionally

As it turns out neither almonds nor wine are really to blame for California's droughts. So yes, ferment some alcohol & be merry

Re:Wall Street Begins Trading Water Futures as a Commodity by s1artibartfast on Friday December 11, 2020 @04:56PM (#25391734)
I think my point was that before we judge if almonds use too much water, we have to ask what we use almonds for and how they compare to similar products.

IF we use almonds for food, I think it is reasonable to compare almonds to other foods, and ask how much water they use. As such, I used numbers for edible table grapes.

IF the end goal is to to change state policy to make water use more efficient, I think we need to answer the question of why some foods are allowed to use more water than others.