All of the entities I mentioned (including Robhinhood) have created a ton of wealth/jobs/income/etc. for a lot of people (easily 100k+ individuals).
How do you reconcile that with "only exist to cause harm"?
Instagram has provided immense value for millions not only in the ability to connect with others, but opportunities for photographers, videographers, actors, venues, musicians, and almost every other type of creative and small business, that they otherwise wouldn't have gotten.
I know the prevailing view on HN is that social media is bad for society. I disagree. The amount of knowledge and experiences shared through social media has had a huge positive impact on the world, of course with it has come some negatives. But in general, through social media the world is now connected to a level where we can see what the real, on the ground experience is like in other places and events. I think this is key for bringing more empathy to the world, especially when it comes to relating to other people's struggles in places where most people don't really think about.
I think as a society, we are in an adjustment phase with social media, and the internet in general.
Frankly, we know enough about human psychology to definitively say that this is not true, or at least not workable or useful.
We know that different technologies provide environments with different affordances. They influence us to think, feel, and behave in different ways by providing different possibilities and making some of them more appealing or lower-effort than others.
We are not simple automatons, but neither do we have unfettered free will as the Enlightenment philosophers conceived of it. Rather, we are unavoidably affected to some degree by our environment. We have well-known and easily exploitable cognitive biases and addictive triggers.
Our underlying nature was always there, but different environments and different incentives can bring out the best or the worst of it. Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook bring out the worst. And it's not an accident: they consciously seek to leverage psychological research in order to addict us, be. Unfortunately, the things that addict us are fear, anxiety, envy, anger, tribalism, and self-loathing.
Robinhood is analogous. They have created an easy, free, addictive way to ruin your life, and they profit handsomely from it. They aren't ignorant of how many people have lost everything, and they aren't innocent, because their product actively invites you to do it. It doesn't matter what the fine print says.
Would you say HN does the same?
Fear triggered through the many posts spreading FUD
Anxiety triggered by that same FUD
Envy triggered by posts about 18 year old prodigies / success by others
Anger triggered by politics, tech choices, etc
Tribalism triggered again by politics and tech choices
Self-loathing triggered by seeing what others are capable of
In my younger years, I experienced all of these feelings more from the likes of HN, than Instagram. Since I know that IG/FB/etc are fake representations of people's lives. HN on the other hand showed people's real accomplishments.
In my opinion, this is a problem of the internet, not any particular social media app. We should be teaching children, and people in general, how to have a healthy online life.
> They aren't ignorant of how many people have lost everything, and they aren't innocent, because their product actively invites you to do it.
Other than providing more investment options for the average person, what is Robinhood doing that you believe is particularly egregious?
HN political discussions, bad as they can be, are tame and rational compared to Twitter or Facebook, because the design of HN does not go out of its way to reward inflammatory rhetoric. And why would it? That would only hurt HN, whose business model is simply to make tech people have a positive opinion of Y Combinator in the hope that we will apply if we one day found a startup. Facebook and Twitter’s business model, by contrast, is to maximize the number of users and the amount of time that each user spends on the site. This is accomplished via an algorithmic feed that decides which content to display to keep the user addicted. Unfortunately, the most inflammatory and emotionally damaging content is what does the best job of this, so that is what they show. HN doesn’t intentionally do this because it has no incentive to do so.
Similarly, HN-driven envy is real, but it is not causing an epidemic of anxiety among young people like Instagram envy is. Again, the vast difference in degree is due to the business model. HN doesn’t have an incentive to addict millions of people and turn their anxiety up to 11. This is exactly the awful incentive that is created by the advertising-focused business model of the major social media companies.
Instead of their sites unwittingly having some negative effects on some people, like HN does, the social media giant explicitly design their sites to have these effects, to the greatest possible degree, on as many people as possible. They are an adversary and we are the target. It is not the responsibility of the target to be a little better educated or a little more disciplined. The adversary needs to be brought to heel. Not all business models are legal—and I would contend that the advertising-based attention economy should not be legal.
As for Robinhood, let’s be honest about what it provides to its users. Robinhood’s value proposition is not “investment options”. Day trading is not investment—it has a negative expected value, and there is abundant research showing that over a long enough time horizon, every day trader loses. Day traders have done somewhat well over the last eight months in beneficial market conditions (soaring valuations are the best environment fo day traders [1]) that will not last forever. Day trading is not investment, it is gambling (an activity which also has a negative expected value). Robinhood provides no-fee gambling, with the full knowledge that this is addictive, has a negative expected value, and will ruin many people’s lives (it’s very easy to find examples on Reddit or any other day-trading forum).
Robinhood makes its money by selling order flow, and not everything that’s been said about that business model is true, but what is true is that the more order flow they have available to sell, the more money they make. In other words, the greater the number of trades that are made on Robinhood, the more money Robinhood makes. This is why trades are free. Unfortunately for users, traders’ expected return is inversely related to the number of trades they make [2]. In other words, Robinhood makes money by designing a user experience that encourages you to lose money. They make money by making it easy, fun, and addictive for as many people as possible to engage in an activity that predictably destroys the user’s wealth.
[1] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.2469/faj.v59.n6.2578?...
[2] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10293523.2012.11...
Instagram is a walk through a shopping mall where one is constantly trained to feel good or bad about certain actions and decisions. They have behavioral psychology and marketing specialists working and designing features against the user.
Also, in the past couple years, IG has rolled out functionality that does the opposite of what you suggest. e.g. They no longer prompt you with your "likes" notifications. I know they are AB testing removing "likes" from view, though not sure if that will get normalized.
Other than the likes, what exactly are they doing that is designed against the user?
Honestly, I don't think we should knock Instagram for mental health issues, that's really up to the user. Instagram's responsibility should be in providing tools to block users/content you don't want to see. If your child is suffering from Instagram, that's on you as a parent (why the fuck are they on Instagram). You don't need Instagram to be bullied, though social media in general, does increase its reach. But what do you expect when you put your life on display for the internet?
> Do we knock tobacco companies for making cheap/addictive products that are detrimental to health? Yes.
Tobacco only has one use. There is no benefit to it. Robinhood is an investment tool that has significantly lowered the barrier to entry for all investors (isn't that what everyone has wanted all along?). I would not consider what they are doing gamification, they've just unlocked investment options to the average Joe that make it very easy to shoot yourself in the foot.
> Do we knock MLM companies for predatory behaviors? Yes.
MLM companies are created for one purpose, scamming people out of money.
Robinhood serves a purpose. Instagram serves a purpose. Both services provide a ton of value for millions of people. You can't compare them to entities that only exist to cause harm.