News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by strictnein on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:19PM (#25361775)
Another example of tech "disruption", which typically just means siphoning money from an established system and adding little in return.
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by twelfthnight on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:55PM (#25364786)
Agreed. This is everything wrong with the tech industry. This company isn't profitable, so this IPO is effectively a way for the shareholders to offload their bad stock to the public [0]. And if that's not bad enough, the company itself is using dubious tactics [1] which in the short run appeal to customers but in the long run may drive many restaurants out of business [2].

[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2020/12/08/do...

[1] https://www.saddlebackbbq.com/how-google-doordash-grubhub-co...

[2] https://laist.com/2020/08/10/why_so_many_restaurants_hate_fo...

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by jeff18 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:30PM (#25364366)
You were able to get sushi, dim sum, boba, bagels, or even steaks promptly delivered in a few clicks before 2013? DoorDash is an easy example of a startup that has made my life better, especially during a pandemic.
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by Skunkleton on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @08:20PM (#25368284)
I was able to get many things delivered for free by the restaurant pre 2015. I can’t even get pizza delivered anymore unless I want BigCo pizza, or pay doordash’s overheads.
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by tomjakubowski on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @08:33PM (#25368391)
Most of the pizza joints by me in LA are on Slice or Chownow. I'm surprised more restaurants aren't on Chownow, really, with the flat monthly fee structure and no commissions. Is it hard to get enough order volume to make that worth it?
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by jannotti on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:43PM (#25365611)
Grubbhub, Seamless, Eat24, Foodler, DiningIn. They were all around and fairly large by then. But they didn't go big on spending VC money, so over time DoorDash wins. Pretty interesting, however it turns out.
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by rkho on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:10PM (#25365963)
Sorry I'm going to have to call on this.

Until on-demand delivery companies like Doordash/Postmates came onto the scene, the vast majority of places I could have ordered delivery from were the standard fare of pizza, Chinese, Indian, and Thai food within a half mile radius from my home.

What this generation unlocked was the ability to pay someone to grab you House of Prime Rib on Van Ness and deliver it halfway across the city. The value add here was "quality from halfway across the city, not just restaurants within a tiny radius who had large enough margins to afford to keep a driver on payroll".

This also resulted in what we now see as the normalization of national fast food brands having a coordinated delivery offering.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by throwdbaaway on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:15AM (#25370024)
I think the problem is that this achievement is unlocked mostly by subsidy. Without subsidy, many would just go back to the standard fare of pizza, Chinese, Indian, and Thai food within a half mile radius.

We will first have to wait and see whether the on-demand delivery business model will work out in a cheaper country, e.g. GrabFood in Indonesia. Even in such country, my sense is that the restaurants are still getting charged too much to cover for the subsidy given the customers, while the delivery riders are still being paid too little and have to rely on infrequent big tips.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by jxramos on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @07:35PM (#25367817)
Thank you, this does well to answer the "compared to what" question--compared to a former world where these things did not exist.
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by graaben on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:07PM (#25366676)
What I just can't understand about companies like DoorDash, Uber Eats etc. is that it seems to be a lose-lose-lose proposition. It's more expensive for the consumer with restaurants often raising prices and delivery fees etc; the restaurants make less money per order; and the delivery drivers are often making less than minimum wage and rapidly depreciating their cars. And on top of that, these companies themselves are mostly unprofitable!

So who is benefiting here? Where is the true value for society being created? Yes I can get any restaurant meal delivered to my home in 30-45 min, but is that one small benefit really enough to sustain a $60bn market cap?

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by danenania on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:31PM (#25362002)
The users apparently feel they are getting something in return. Otherwise why download and use the app (and pay extra for the food)?
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by strictnein on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:42PM (#25362298)
Users get something, restaurants lose, delivery people are abused and underpaid, but the founders will be very rich.

Looking at the entire system there was very little added, there's just a lot of money being shifted to a small group of people.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by akarma on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @02:01PM (#25362756)
At least in DoorDash's YC application, they pitched that delivery drivers wanted to make more money.

When the drivers worked for one restaurant only, they would be sitting around most of the time waiting for an order.

By delivering for many restaurants at once on DoorDash, they would be able to make more money and have less idle time.

I'd love to see data, but I can intuitively imagine this being true, and the common view of "underpaid" being a view that isn't consistent with the history of the space.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by dmitriid on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @02:47PM (#25363597)
> I'd love to see data, but I can intuitively imagine this being true, and the common view of "underpaid" being a view that isn't consistent with the history of the space.

Except, you know, the history of the space is consistent with delivery drivers being consistently underpaid, cheated out of tips and hazard pay etc. etc.

With Doordash alone multiple lawsuits against it for payments alone. So far Doordash has been settling those for millions of dollars ($5 mln in California, $2.5 in Washington).

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by akarma on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:24PM (#25364263)
> the history of the space is consistent with delivery drivers being consistently underpaid

If that's the case, how can one say that, for all of history, they have been underpaid? What is the standard that defines underpaid? If we agree that this is an issue that DoorDash has done better on than historical alternatives, should they receive as much flak as they do?

> With Doordash alone multiple lawsuits against it for payments alone

I would never argue that DoorDash isn't acting in its own self-interest and has been quite misleading when it comes to tips, to the point where they should be losing lawsuits. When we talk about delivery people being underpaid, though, that seems directly against the initial pitch of DoorDash, and it seems to have instead fulfilled its pitch to help drivers make more money than they did previously.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by dmitriid on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:57PM (#25365823)
> If that's the case, how can one say that, for all of history, they have been underpaid? What is the standard that defines underpaid?

Your original statement was: "the common view of "underpaid" being a view that isn't consistent with the history of the space."

And this statement is false. Now you're trying to wiggle out of this by pretending that "being underpaid" is undefined because we haven't decided the concept of paid/underpaid and other demagoguery.

1) Delivery drivers are underpaid

2) Doordash and all the rest of gig economy businesses systematically underpay and make conditions even worse because they force people into becoming external contractors with zero rights and protections, and shift many additional costs to these contractors.

> When we talk about delivery people being underpaid, though, that seems directly against the initial pitch

The pitch doesn't matter in the least. Especially if you essentially argue that "Doordash's pitch is true because the common view of "underpaid" isn't consistent with the history of the space."

1) Delivery drivers are underpaid

2) Doordash and all the rest of gig economy businesses systematically underpay people who work for them

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by akarma on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:04PM (#25366625)
> Your original statement was: "the common view of "underpaid" being a view that isn't consistent with the history of the space."

No wriggling. :)

To me, that statement would be backed by evidence that DoorDash allows drivers to make more than they previously made as drivers for specific restaurants.

To you, that wouldn’t satisfy the notion that they are fairly paid, because you believe they have always been underpaid.

I’m looking at “underpaid” through a lens of historical data, but you’re looking at it through a different lens, so I asked how you define underpaid.

Do you see what I mean?

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by dmitriid on Thursday December 10, 2020 @05:34AM (#25372157)
> through a lens of historical data

You keep saying "historical data" as if that should make everyone node their head in agreement: "hmmm, yes, yes, you're right, historical data".

I'd love to see the "historical data" you allude to.

> but you’re looking at it through a different lens

Nope. I'm looking through the same lens: history tells us that couriers are underpaid and overworked, especially in the US. And they keep being underpaid and underworked with DoorDash and other vultures.

You pretend that DoorDash is somehow good.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by 908B64B197 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:37PM (#25364500)
I like how the drivers are always depicted as underpaid yet... they flock to the app!

If it paid more to have a minimum wage job, why are there so many drivers on the platform?

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by dmitriid on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:58PM (#25365835)
- Because the economy isn't doing that great

- There are not that many jobs to go around

- More and more companies force people into the gig economy

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by bsder on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:05PM (#25366646)
Drivers were so underpaid they were stealing food.

Many of the restaurants had to repackage their food in such a way that it could be sealed so that they could deny claims for theft.

That's not the sign of well-paid employees.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by strombofulous on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:58PM (#25367383)
I mean, there's a lot of reasons they might have been stealing food. To presume it must have been because they were so poor and not because they had delicious smelling food in their car and a near-guarantee that theft wouldn't be noticed is, imo, disingenuous

To say that the only reason someone steals food is for hunger is to say that nobody has ever stolen food for any reason other than hunger. Otherwise, there would necessarily be multiple reasons to steal food. I don't think that could possibly be true.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by bsder on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @07:13PM (#25367550)
Dude. People don't steal food if they're not hungry.

You are trying to justify THEFT.

Not IP theft. Not Copyright theft. Real, actual, physical theft.

Of someone's food. And there was so much theft that companies retooled their packaging.

Go back and contemplate on your ethics. Like ... a lot.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by strombofulous on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @07:30PM (#25367756)
This is such a wildly incorrect interpretation of what I said. After re-reading my original comment I'm honestly confused as to how you arrived at the conclusion you did (that I was attempting to justify theft).

I wasn't saying they should be stealing. The only thing I was saying was that there is more than one reason to steal food. If anything, I was arguing against theft (but in the moment, I was just responding to GP).

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by miked85 on Thursday December 10, 2020 @05:05AM (#25371946)
> Dude. People don't steal food if they're not hungry.

I take it you have never worked in the food service industry.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by benlivengood on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:21PM (#25366090)
Drivers can easily put in consistent overtime which is harder to do at a traditional job. Removing some of the friction of overworking themselves while giving the illusion of choice.

Migrant workers consistently show up at farms too; it doesn't mean they're paid well.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by strombofulous on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:46PM (#25366399)
The reason migrant workers pick ("pick") farms is because they legally can't work anywhere else.

Uber/DD/Postmates/... all do citizen verification checks.

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by benlivengood on Thursday December 10, 2020 @07:21PM (#25380702)
That conflates undocumented workers with migrant workers when there is more like a ~50% overlap (at farms).
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by jnwatson on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @02:02PM (#25362762)
yet all are willing participants...
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by umeshunni on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:54PM (#25365785)
> restaurants lose

I don't know if you've noticed, but we're in the middle of a pandemic and something like 85%[1] of restaurants have closed in some areas. For most restaurants, something like Doordash is the only way they're actually staying alive at this time.

[1] https://www.sfgate.com/food/article/It-s-decimated-down-here...

Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by treis on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:01PM (#25363844)
At the moment Doordash is an elaborate scheme to funnel VC money to the restaurant/grocery business. So yes, it's good for customers and those businesses now. But their valuation implies that at some point that's going to change and they're going to start extracting ~$10 billion a year in value. It's hard to see how they're going to do that in a way that ultimately is good for customers.
Re:DoorDash from Application to IPO by ProAm on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @02:44PM (#25363535)
It's the restaurants and drivers that are losing out. Small local businesses that are eating this loss in profits.