News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by abstractbill on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @03:36PM (#2533799)
None of Y Combinators competitors have anything like that to offer new entrepreneurs.

Y Combinator competitors would be foolish to try to compete on the money axis anyway - the cash has always been minimally important. They would do much better by identifying and focusing on YC's actual weaknesses.

Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by stevenj on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @05:28PM (#2534164)
What are YC's weaknesses?
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by pg on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @06:06PM (#2534269)
The biggest is probably the meta-weakness of not focusing on any specific market. How much that matters depends on how unusual the market is. Education, for example, is a very unusual market, and Imagine K12 has a unique advantage in the network of schools they have access to.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by acangiano on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @07:39PM (#2534515)
In my opinion, some of your biggest strengths are also what leaves room for competitors.

For example, you focus on Silicon Valley where you are extremely well connected. Competitors could do very well by simply focusing on less glamorous, but emerging startup hubs.

You require people to relocate to Silicon Valley for a few months. This shows commitment from both parties and is a smart choice for you, but it also makes the program inflexible and unsuitable for a great deal of talented, perhaps more experienced people who cannot easily relocate. Your typical candidate is a student who is fresh out of college. Your competitors may capture the value in other demographics which have less flexibility when it comes to relocation, ability to quit their job, and so on.

Imagine an Untyped Lambda which offers similar terms to yours, but is also very flexible. You don't have to relocate (you can work remotely). Oh, and you can also apply if you are going to do this part-time, if at the moment you are employed and want to see where the startup goes before quitting your job.

You may think that this idea is grounds for a complete disaster, that such candidates might not committed, and so on - but perhaps, just maybe, such a degree of flexibility would lead to all sorts of new talent giving entrepreneurship a honest shot.

I'm not advocating that you do all that, but rather that a smart competitor may use it to their advantage.

Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by nl on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @08:36PM (#2534646)
Oh, and you can also apply if you are going to do this part-time, if at the moment you are employed and want to see where the startup goes before quitting your job.

To be honest, that doesn't sound like a very promising investment opportunity.

YCombinator isn't a charity - they need things to succeed.

Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by acangiano on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @09:12PM (#2534715)
That may be an edge case, but it wouldn't be the first time that someone built a great company out of a side project or an idea developed after work either. My point is that such an investor wouldn't exclude people a priori because they can't relocate to Silicon Valley. Instead it would evaluate each case and select only the most promising investments, including the outliers who happens to have little flexibility at the time of the investment.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by garry on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @11:53PM (#2535119)
In practice, quitting your job is the ultimate litmus test of faith. Why would anyone else take on risk if the founders themselves take no risk?
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by MenaMena123 on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @11:29PM (#2535065)
Why would they even consider it? When you have many already willing founders to move down and give 110 percent. Also, face to face contact is a bonus especially at the start.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by pg on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @01:27AM (#2535280)
We experimented once with not making a startup move, and on Demo Day they seemed about where the other startups had been at week 2.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by prpon on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:40AM (#2535550)
I would be interested in knowing the reasons why that startup was so far behind. Is it the constant feedback about the startup/idea from mentors and other YC members that make the startups better Or the ability to solve technical issues quickly because of help from others?
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by pg on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @12:49PM (#2537147)
Almost everything YC supplies, they missed, from specific things like face to face conversations with us and the insights of the speakers to more general ones like the contagious spirit of rushing toward Demo Day and the startup-friendly atmosphere in the Valley.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by stevenj on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @06:11PM (#2534281)
What makes a market unusual?
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by SkyMarshal on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @06:41PM (#2534365)
Some guesses:

* Barriers to entry not commonly seen in the web/mobile space (complex bureaucracy + entrenched players with opposing interests able to grease that bureaucracy, etc.).

* Lots of disparate stakeholders that all have to be coordinated and managed (healthcare: govt, taxpayers, patients, doctors/staff, insurance companies. Education: Parents & taxpayers, teachers unions, students, local+state+federal govt.)

* The market is not traditionally tech-savy and/or early-adopting. Users have to be actively convinced. Getting traction is even more of an uphill battle.

* Anywhere the risks to loss of investment are not transparent or clearly understood.

Maybe all markets are like this to an extent, but some moreso than others?

Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by siavosh on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @08:15PM (#2534597)
I think yc generally does best with consumer products where the founder could put himself int he place of the user. Industry products (good example is health care) has such a high barrier to understanding that someone who hasn't been in the field would have a very difficult time designing a useful tool.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by Dn_Ab on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @06:39PM (#2534357)
Based on his single example I suspect any market which requires intimate familiarity with and the ability to minimize what bureaucratic ritual dances must be taken before, after and in-between any action.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by a5seo on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @08:07PM (#2534577)
non-economic decision making

government regulation

Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by puredemo on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @01:58AM (#2535335)
Government.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by MenaMena123 on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @11:35PM (#2535075)
At the end of the decision making, do you feel many other great startups are being left out, due to the amount of startups you can only choose? Or you feel the others just don't have something going on.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by pg on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @01:34AM (#2535291)
We know we have to be missing a few every time, but I would not say many.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by david927 on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:29AM (#2535528)
That's a dishonest thing to say. The truth is that you can't possibly know which companies, if you had funded them, would have become great companies.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by pg on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @11:21AM (#2536767)
One way we know is by seeing how they do afterward. A company that would have been great if we funded them is probably going to do at least ok if we don't.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by david927 on Saturday May 14, 2011 @01:34AM (#2547210)
I assumed that was your line of reasoning but probably is a big word here. I don't think it's something you can really know in that it's finding proof in a negative, such as when a doctor says to a patient, "The tests didn't find cancer -- you're cancer free!"

If Larry and Sergey had done their post-graduate work in Moldova, the world wouldn't have Google. (Remember they shopped Page Rank to places like Yahoo, who didn't want it. As an idea, no one believed in it.) The connections at Stanford gave them access to capital which they otherwise would not have had, which allowed them to prove the concept. Without that funding, Page Rank would be just another dissertation.

Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by brlewis on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:37AM (#2536164)
He's answering a "do you feel" question. You can't possibly know if he's being dishonest.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by prpon on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:52AM (#2535579)
If recognition from YC is the only piece that is missing from a startup's puzzle, I would be disappointed if they cannot make it on their own. Many of us are at different levels of competence at being a successful entrepreneur. Many drop off from the startup world altogether, some drop off from applying to YC and endup with a small business, a tiny few will show up as groupons of the world.
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by sampsonjs on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @12:08PM (#2536975)
Acting like a college admissions board, instead of seeking out and meeting entrepreneurs year round?
Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by neurotech1 on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @03:45PM (#2533834)
Agreed 100%. Every program is different, but trying to imitate YC is not going to work as well.

One area of innovation is to encourage more hardware/software combination start-ups. eg. WakeMate

Re:Y Combinator Accepts Record 60+ New Startups For Summer 2011 by phlux on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @03:53PM (#2533867)
Agreed, this is why I am more encouraged by others such as RockHealth where they have a very specific vertical they focus on.

The market, needs, barriers etc are wildly different in the consumer internet and mobile space than in health care -- and something like RockHealth is greatly needed so that vertical can mature.