News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Grenfell Tower inquiry is uncovering a major corporat... by jrochkind1 on Sunday December 06, 2020 @06:53PM (#25327841)
This is I think generally (although not exclusively) used for "buying" an apartment (ie a "flat" in the UK), rather than a free-standing house -- what in the U.S. would be a condominium. Such as it would be in the case of Grenfell Tower.

Condominium ownership required specific legal authorization in the U.S., which only happened mid 20th century. Before that there was no way to have different people owning different units in a larger building. The closest thing to it was a cooperative, in which you also don't really own your unit as real estate, although it isn't quite the same thing as a UK leasehold, it overlaps.

So, the UK didn't even pass similar legislation to legalize a condoninium-like ownership structure ("commonhold") until the 21st century. And it's still not quite the same. And for whatever reasons hasn't taken off much, maybe because the leasehold system was already so developed at that point. Switching over ownership structures in existing properties is of course a big hassle (why are there so many more cooperatives than condominiums in NYC, even decades after condos were legally authorized? that's part of it)

So, people do it, because that's what evolved from the particular historical and political context to allow "ownership" of an apartment in a building. There's noting "natural" about condominiums, they needed specific legislation to make them possible in the USA too.

In the context of council estates specifically, well there's a bunch more historical and political context. Land ownership and tenure is a social and political construct, it isn't "naturally" any particular way, it turns out.

Re:The Grenfell Tower inquiry is uncovering a major corporat... by gpderetta on Monday December 07, 2020 @05:35AM (#25330912)
One reason it hasn't taken over is because the banks are reluctant to lend for such properties as there is less clarity on who's responsible for maintenance.
Re:The Grenfell Tower inquiry is uncovering a major corporat... by jrochkind1 on Monday December 07, 2020 @08:20AM (#25331864)
For some reason not a problem with US condominiums, I wonder if there are different legal factors involved. But yeah, ownership is it turns out built on a whole suite of legal structures and social practices built up over time, there's nothing surprising about a different configuration existing in the UK than the USA.
Re:The Grenfell Tower inquiry is uncovering a major corporat... by gpderetta on Monday December 07, 2020 @08:50AM (#25332062)
It is not a problem in most of the world. It is just good old inertia and I guess lack of legal precedents.