News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kill Math by hessenwolf on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @09:34AM (#2532391)
Ugh. Math is a collection of concrete symbols for simplifying different problems. It's evolved over thousands of years to help us understand difficult things. We don't make it that way just to piss people off.
Re:Kill Math by michael_dorfman on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @09:47AM (#2532434)
But math is more than that.

His argument is that analyzing a differential equation without exploring it in phase space was like analyzing a piece of sheet music without actually hearing it.

And if music education were taught in that way-- by looking at music purely as the manipulation of concrete symbols-- I imagine some of us would be writing "kill music (as it is currently taught)" blog posts as well.

EDIT: minor grammar fix

Re:Kill Math by hammock on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @09:48AM (#2532441)
I doubt anyone here learned math (at least up through calculus) without concrete examples. They were called word problems and lab assignments.
Re:Kill Math by hessenwolf on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @11:22AM (#2532760)
I'll be honest; I absolute love graph theory. If I had a million lives and financial independence, I would spend several of them solving graph theory problems. I don't really give a shit what the nodes and edges are. Computer network? Rigid structure? Conditional independence of personality traits? I don't care!
Re:Kill Math by generalk on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @09:58AM (#2532483)
Word problems are still abstract manipulation of symbols, you just have to hunt around in the phrasing for the right operands or operations, which arguably makes it harder.
Re:Kill Math by fhars on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @10:08AM (#2532524)
But the jury is still out on the question of whether concrete examples are usefull in maths education: http://researchnews.osu.edu/archive/mathed.htm
Re:Kill Math by hessenwolf on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @11:16AM (#2532743)
Weak study.

They made some students learn something using concrete examples only, and then expected them to be able to abstract. That's just dumb.

I learn the maths, and apply to various situations in my head to make sure I understand it.

Re:Kill Math by simpleTruth on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @10:04AM (#2532506)
Talking about Math as a single subject is like talking about Sports. Chess, Boxing, Baseball, Snowboarding, Curling, and Luge may have some things in common. However, suggesting that DiffEq and Fractions are equally meaningless to most people seems just as out of place as assuming a chess grandmaster is also a champion snowboarder.
Re:Kill Math by _delirium on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @09:54AM (#2532470)
Most of the symbols are pretty recent; if you read mathematics from even 300 years ago, there's a much bigger proportion written in prose. Along the lines of, "Consider two quantities, such that the latter is at least twice the former ...".
Re:Kill Math by StefanKarpinski on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @10:06AM (#2532515)
The shift to more symbols and more and better notation has also drastically increased mathematical productivity and rigor. In fact, most of the notation emerged together with the axiomatization of the foundations of mathematics in the early 20th century.

If we were to follow this guy's ideas it would cause even more of a class divide between those who can understand the "magical symbols" and those who can't. Doing what he suggests would mean that the non-cognoscenti wouldn't even have access to the understanding of simple algebraic equations.

Re:Kill Math by eru on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @10:06AM (#2532517)
And you will understand, why we switched from prose to symbols. But that doesn't mean we should go overboard with the symbols.
Re:Kill Math by StavrosK on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @11:34AM (#2532815)
Exactly. Why do devs shout "comment your code" but academic papers have no explanation next to the equations?

"Next, calculate the fitness of the algorithm and add it to the pool if it is better than the worst of the last generation: <math here>"

Re:Kill Math by xyzzyz on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @01:48PM (#2533428)
Why do devs shout "comment your code" but academic papers have no explanation next to the equations?

That's exactly the opposite of my impression. Most papers are full of text, and symbols are not the main feature. For instance:

http://ttic.uchicago.edu/~yury/papers/kuratowski.pdf Graph theory, the symbolism is next to nonexistent.

http://math.berkeley.edu/~aboocher/math/tietze.pdf Topology, still symbolism does not take much space.

http://www.jstor.org/stable/1989708 Classical and very highly technical, yet the ratio of text to symbolism is still in favour.

Re:Kill Math by StavrosK on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @02:02PM (#2533480)
I remember trying for hours to understand Adaboost before it all clicked (it's an ingenious algorithm, by the way). The paper could certainly do with some more explanation, rather than just "this is the weight updating function, this is the evaluation step, done".
Re:Kill Math by _delirium on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @02:18PM (#2533544)
I think AI and machine learning are worse than math in that respect for some reason. Part of it might be the greater focus on 6-page conference papers, which tends to require everything to get squished.
Re:Kill Math by hessenwolf on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @11:34AM (#2532814)
Re:Kill Math by eru on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @02:08PM (#2533502)
Depends on how you embed it in text.