News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by rheide on Monday May 09, 2011 @03:17PM (#2529853)
vupen: "Hey Google, your browser has a very nasty bug that allows for potentially horrible things to happen. We thought we'd share that with the world. If you'd like to know where it is though, you'd better give us money."
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by lawnchair_larry on Monday May 09, 2011 @03:27PM (#2529878)
Why not? This is highly specialized research that not even well-paid Google employees were able to do.

This is actually quite common in recent years for bug hunters and exploit developers. I can think of a dozen or so companies that do the same thing. Immunity is another example.

Trying to use a moral argument to get out of compensating someone when you have the resources to do so is shameful. Sorry, but this stuff is worth far more than the (up to) $3133 they are offering.

No More Free Bugs, as they say.

They can either pay a nominal fee for doing their security work for them, or they can hire some equally talented people and fund this type of research on their own internally. Fair is fair. There is no reason this isn't worth compensating but something like pagerank optimizations is.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by _delirium on Monday May 09, 2011 @04:28PM (#2530085)
Publicly announcing a security vulnerability, claiming that you're sharing it with other clients with the intent of using it for "weaponized ... offensive missions", and then demanding a fee to gain the information to protect against said weaponization, sounds an awful lot like extortion. In the offline world, I don't think you can legally run a business with a strategy of: discover a problem in the security at one of Exxon's plants, publicly announce that you've discovered a vulnerability and will be selling the information to third parties, and then demand $N from Exxon for the details.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by forensic on Monday May 09, 2011 @04:55PM (#2530179)
I don't see why not. As long as you don't actually break into Exxon and commit I crime.

The real reason your scenario is unlikely is just that Exxon practically owns the government, so they would change the laws or something to fuck you over.

But I mean what if you discovered a security vulnerability at McDonalds or something, a way to pick their locks. Why are you morally obligated to disclose it without compensation?

On which moral principle are you condemning them?

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by seabee on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:56PM (#2530544)
It is possible to be an accessory to a crime. If you plan a bank robbery and give the details to somebody else to perform, you're still guilty. Hell, you're still guilty even if you never perform the crime (conspiracy to commit ...)!

If you send a letter to a bank saying "I have found a breach in the kind of vault you use at your banks, I'm giving the details to some expert robbers but you can't have it unless you pay me $10m", with evidence you've done it, I'm pretty sure you will find yourself waking up at gunpoint at 6am, courtesy of the FBI.

Since unauthorised access of a computer is a crime in many places, I'm sure you can see the relevance, even if the consequences aren't as drastic. One hopes that we have misinterpreted this and that they have performed 'responsible disclosure' by telling Google all the details.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by lawnchair_larry on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:51PM (#2530667)
FYI, the industry has rejected the doublespeak term "responsible disclosure". Even Microsoft has issued statements denouncing the term. Most prefer to call that "coordinated disclosure". This accurately communicates the idea, without sneaking in someone's moral judgement.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by shasta on Monday May 09, 2011 @04:52PM (#2530169)
This is probably why they keep repeating that their customer is the government. You could probably sell Exxon's security vulnerabilities to the government and demand $N dollars from them to show them how to fix the problem. It's advertising the vulnerability with posts like this that seems most questionable (similar to extortion) to me.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by _delirium on Monday May 09, 2011 @04:58PM (#2530192)
Yeah, that's the part that seemed odd to me as well, though someone knowledgeable in this area of law (at least in the better-settled offline case) could give some better info.

I believe it'd be okay, and probably actually happens, for a private security consultant to do threat assessments for a (non-criminal) client, e.g. prepare a report for DHS on the security of U.S. oil installations. But it seems like they'd be crossing a line if they posted a press release trumpeting a major vulnerability they discovered, mentioning by name which company and approximately where the vulnerability was located, but then refused to disclose it to the company in question.

I'm not sure how much it survives, but I believe there was traditionally even a common-law "duty to warn" if you were aware of significant risks to someone's person or property.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by chopsueyar on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:21PM (#2530446)
Google could easily sue them into oblivion for libel. They would be forced to reveal the exploit during proceedings to prove their innocence.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by sswam on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:46PM (#2530656)
one is not obliged to prove innocence in a sensible court of law
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by mmagin on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:04PM (#2530830)
At least in the US, civil court cases do not have the presumption of innocence, only criminal cases do.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by shpxnvz on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:00PM (#2530382)
I'd imagine that depends on which government you're talking about. Seems like selling the info to a foreign government could be treading into "espionage" territory.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by chopsueyar on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:17PM (#2530422)
Which government(s)?
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by leif on Monday May 09, 2011 @03:59PM (#2529987)
"Why not? This is highly specialized research that not even well-paid Google employees were able to do."

Correction: not even well-paid Google employees did. They may yet be able, and an existence proof may be all the help they need to find and fix it. Don't give up hope yet.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by sswam on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:47PM (#2530658)
I can fix it right now. Delete the flash player - problem solved. Chrome still works.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by daeken on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @01:38AM (#2531491)
There's absolutely no evidence that this has anything to do with Flash. In fact, even if it was via Flash, there would still have to be another vulnerability to escape the Chrome sandbox, which could very likely be exploited via other means.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by watty on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:35PM (#2530897)
I don't see how Flash can be the culprit or solution considering it is sandboxed. Chrome must contain a massive exploit.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by leif on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:47PM (#2530929)
I thought the point was that they broke the sandboxing.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by leif on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:55PM (#2530681)
Sadly, one aspect of security is psychological acceptability. If nobody will do the secure thing, it's not secure.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by blocke on Monday May 09, 2011 @03:46PM (#2529940)
"They can either pay a nominal fee for doing their security work for them, or they can hire some equally talented people and fund this type of research on their own internally."

What makes you think they don't already? You make it sound like Google doesn't give a shit about security. That clearly isn't the case.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by tptacek on Monday May 09, 2011 @04:06PM (#2530016)
Google employs several of the best well-known security researchers in the world, and no doubt many more that we haven't heard much about.

That doesn't mean they're going to find everything, though.

At the end of the day, private companies are perfectly within their rights to do offensive research against Google products, to be selective about how they disclose their results, and to tell the public whatever they want about those results. As long as they aren't lying, there's nothing unethical about it.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by mauriciob on Monday May 09, 2011 @04:01PM (#2529994)
I doubt Google will hire them. They seem to be a very unprofessional company, even with their skilled people. They may pay to know about this security breach, though.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by orblivion on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:38PM (#2530315)
I think you'd be biting off the hand that feeds you. If you eliminate what is arguably a distasteful arrangement here, you also eliminate the incentive to continue doing it. You might get this bug for free, but you get a hidden loss, a bunch of future bugs that you'll never hear about.

Think about the audacity of farmers, who make a profit for food, which you need to live. But nobody thinks like that for some reason.

Earning profit just means you've done something for someone who really wanted it done. It's a necessary signal.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by syllogism on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:58PM (#2530374)
I felt the same way until this comment below:

> http://www.vupen.com/english/services/ > As the world leader in vulnerability research, VUPEN Security provides weaponized and highly sophisticated exploits specifically designed for Law Enforcement and Intelligence Agencies to help them achieve their offensive missions using tailored and unique codes created in-house by VUPEN for vulnerabilities discovered by our researchers. Note also the "under contract with VUPEN" part of the disclosure bit.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by trotsky on Monday May 09, 2011 @03:43PM (#2529936)
The "no more free bugs" campaign has gained a fair amount of support:

http://trailofbits.com/2009/03/22/no-more-free-bugs/

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by code_duck on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:22PM (#2530263)
I'm tired of doing volunteer work for corporations, personally.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by nitrogen on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:33PM (#2530892)
Don't think of it as volunteer work -- think of it as a non-financial exchange of value. You provide beta testing in exchange for significantly more affordable software and/or earlier access. If you want rock solid reliability, there are companies and operating systems that provide it, with the price tag and turnaround time to match.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by code_duck on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @02:58PM (#2533673)
I'm not talking about open source or beta programs. What is VUPEN getting out of giving the fruits of their research to Google for free? They would receive neither more affordable software nor earlier access.

The 100% unhackable browser and OS... how much does it cost? I think the turnaround time is going to be infinite. I'm not sure what you're saying.

These companies have employees, who have a nice situation with a financial exchange of value. Let them do their own work. If I'm going to do something their employees should be doing, they're free to hire me or pay me as a consultant.