I lead the frontend development for a very large (and successful regardless of what the press says) command and control system. We completely decoupled our UI from our logic years ago into config files, and use QtScript for GUI events. This allows us to deploy on a large number of form factors with a single code base. Performance has not been effected as the logic is still C++. QML will be a huge improvement over that because it makes it so we don't have to manually build effects using QPainter, QGLWidget, or QGraphicsView.
I understand being resistant to change, but I am 100% behind them looking forward, building for the future, and not just assuming we will to continue doing things the way we do now.
Note though, that you don't have to use the scripting framework. You can define your GUI simply in C++ if you want.
Now, it isn't just that JS is easier to learn for 'artistic types', but it really is a quicker development process than traditional C++. My worry would be performance, just like everyone else. If you have already decided that a web application isn't good enough, why are you going to be okay with the JS penalty?
Most people in the real world care about development turnover time. And as you say, developing in Javascript is a lot quicker than in C++, so why not write the non-performance-critical parts in JS?
That said, the piece that is in most need of performance in a desktop application is often the GUI itself. Imagine Microsoft Word taking a split second more when it updates the ribbon, for example.
Perhaps there is an exception for desktop apps that need direct connections to hardware.
As long as the drawing is fast (which is the case, as it is handled by the GPU), it really doesn't matter in human time whether it takes 0.01ms or 0.001ms to react.
In the end, I'm under the impression that there's a brillant guy who has been recently hired and who is backed by the execs. That guy came to the office one morning with his 7 pages "technical" proposition (because the guy has a bit of technical background, y'a know) and said Qt was cool stuff but he had a vision for the app^Wproduct.
Or.. they are trying to kill Qt.
Oh, and I'm disappointed.