News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:23AM (#2528041)
I don't like how people get defensive around capitalism; "our ideas are not at odds with capitalism", ok, so what if they were? If an idea is at odds with capitalism, that doesn't necessarily make it a bad idea.

For instance, I think the idea of free software (RMS style) really is at odds with capitalism; but so what? This is not a good reason to agree or disagree with the idea.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by jsn on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:30AM (#2528052)
Free software isn't at odds with capitalism (you don't have to extract monetary profit from everything you do in capitalism). Neither is bitcoin. Government-controlled paper money, on the other hand, definitely is at odds with free market.
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by barrkel on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:31AM (#2528183)
Nobody wants a free market. That's a market that includes slaves, child pornography, assassination contracts, etc.

At the level of globally integrated economies, I think the gold standard has been pretty well proven to be disastrous. It especially doesn't deal well with trade imbalances that unwind suddenly. The trouble you see in the Euro area can be seen as a microcosm of what a gold standard is like; countries like Greece, Ireland, Portugal, Spain don't control their money supply - more or less, it's like gold - so they're caught in an extremely painful bind, when what would be best for them is to devalue their currency some. Instead, they're having to struggle under huge debt burdens, and some might have to default, or leave the Euro (i.e. by analogy leave the gold standard).

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:43AM (#2528344)
> Nobody wants a free market. That's a market that includes slaves, child pornography, assassination contracts, etc.

Those things are perfectly compatible with democracy but completely incompatible with capitalism. An inherent idea to capitalism is the protection of individual freedom which those things clearly violate in some way or another. On the other hand, those things are perfectly compatible with democracy given that 51% of the population are OK with it. In fact, what nobody believes in is democracy (that's why most democratic countries have a constitution).

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMb_72hgkJk

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by barrkel on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:27AM (#2528457)
Not treating people as property is a distortion of the free market. If people aren't property, what incentive do companies have to invest in their education? Rich people would be much more likely to pay for the education of their slaves if they were assured of strong property rights over them. How can you properly price human capital if there isn't a free market in it?

Etc., etc. Free markets are amoral machines that discover price levels appropriate to supply and demand through transactions. They are not intrinsically good or bad; it is in the transactions that make them up that moral judgement comes in. But if the market is truly free, then there will be no limit on the kinds of transactions.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:45AM (#2528499)
I've yet to hear of someone who felt as a criminal after quitting his job (or after stealing himself from his employer as you put it).
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by barrkel on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:18AM (#2528592)
Gah! You've completely missed the point of my irony. There's scarcely any point discoursing with you.
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:47AM (#2528662)
Well, you're not talking about capitalism. Your whole reasoning is based on a false premise, because there are limits to the kind of transactions allowed in a free market. In a free market, you are free to do whatever you want as long as it doesn't interfere with someone else's freedom. Your freedom ends where someone else's begins.

Hence, slavery not being compatible with capitalism is a fact, not a distortion of the free market nor a mere opinion.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by barrkel on Monday May 09, 2011 @02:18PM (#2529630)
We're talking about market freedom not individual freedom. You're confusing the two. Companies owned by larger companies can still both operate in a free market. It's no different in principle for people. And my irony was about phrasing the ownership of people issue in free market terms to show how it is distorting (and it straight out is), not to argue for it or that there aren't other approaches to the same problems.
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by yummyfajitas on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:19AM (#2528435)
Our current quasi-free markets already do have "assassination" contracts - your supermarket pays a slaughterhouse to assassinate cows. We also have slavery - horses are forced to labor for whatever amount of money their owners give them.

I'm not making a "meat is murder" argument. I'm just pointing out that pretty much any conceivable capitalist system defines cows and horses to be property, not people. One can envision a capitalist system which does the same for slaves and assassination victims.

I.e., by tweaking the definition of "person" or "market participant", you can get all sorts of odd results.

(That said, capitalist advocates have never made such arguments, as far as I'm aware. Most early supply&demand types were abolitionists, and the phrase "the dismal science" was coined by a pro-slavery advocate.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_dismal_science )

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:36AM (#2528477)
True, but that's a problem of semantics which is not specific to the definition of capitalism. Whatever system you advocate, you'll have to define the terms you employ: "person", "market participant", "proletariat", "equality", etc.
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by v21 on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:19AM (#2528431)
Is capitalism the same as the free market?
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:59AM (#2528536)
There might be other definitions, but I was referring to free market capitalism.

Edit: Why the hell am I being down voted here?

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by v21 on Monday May 09, 2011 @03:21PM (#2529863)
No idea why you were being downvoted. I was just curious, as people were using the terms interchangably and they aren't always used that way.
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by jsn on Monday May 09, 2011 @01:29PM (#2529464)
"Free market" is defined as environment of voluntary transactions. Slavery is not voluntary, so it has nothing to do with free market. The same applies to assassinations (unless the victim voluntary agrees to be assassinated).

As for your argument wrt gold, it's inconclusive to say the least. Specifically, PIIGS has failed not because they can't expand their money supply at will now, but because they could (and very much did) extend their money supply before (using ECB as a source of cheap money, which would be impossible on gold standard).

But that's a century old debate, Austrian school has made their very convincing case about fiat money w/ goverment controlled supply causing business cycles in, what, 1912? Something like that.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by barrkel on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:09PM (#2530571)
Why do you think slavery isn't voluntary? Why can't you sell yourself? Do you not own yourself? Why can't you enter into a contract to sell yourself for a particular period of time, or to a binding set of responsibilities, etc.? Many (I've read some accounts that say most) slaves in history were willing slaves, in that they faced destitution and starvation outside slavery. Part of the implied contract of becoming a slave would be that your owner would look after you. And he would have every incentive to, of course - he doesn't want his investment damaged.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntary_slavery etc.

I'm not familiar with the situation in all PIIGS, mostly just Ireland (I'm Irish). The money came from British, German, French banks, over the course of a decade. ECB was the source of emergency financing when the bubble collapsed; i.e. you have your order of events backwards.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by jsn on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:42PM (#2530788)
For as long as they are willing to stay slaves, I see nothing wrong with trading them. Outside of that situation, though, the right to body is unalienable (according to many rights theories).

The money came from British (banks, sponsored by artificially expanded money supply of BoE), German, French banks (sponsored by artificially expanded money supply of ECB), etc. I've got my order exactly correct. Then, when the crisis hit, more money come from ECB. It's a little surprise that the problem caused by excess money is not exactly fixed (in PIIGS) by more excess money.

Seriously, it's ABCT 101.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by barrkel on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @01:48AM (#2531519)
See, I do see something wrong with trading in slaves; but not because it's contrary to free markets.

Re your selective fitting of crisis to monetary theory, I'm not going to comment; there are too many factors at work to be reductive about it.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by dualogy on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:04AM (#2528257)
"That's a market that includes slaves, child pornography, assassination contracts, etc."

Yes -- but by definition only if agreed upon mutually voluntarily.

But you're probably still right when saying that (almost) "nobody wants" that.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by Symmetry on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:54AM (#2528693)
I think most people's definition of "free market" is that people can sell or not sell their property or services for whatever price they wish - not that any good or service is legal to own or produce. People sometimes, but not always, lump the right not to have your property or labour taken from you under the term "free market" and sometimes just lump not having it taken from you except for monetary taxes (as opposed to taxes in kind or forced labour). Some people also lump freedom of contract under the rubric of "free market".

The generally accepted term for everything, including murder and conspiracy to murder, being legal is "anarchy" and if people still have free markets in this anarchy thats generally referred to as "anarcho-capitalism". Though nothing about having a free market says that murder is legal and probably says that forcing another person to work for you using the threat of violence is illegal. I can certainly see arguing that a free market implies legal prostitution, however, since unmarried sex is legal in most places.

EDIT: And as to Capitalism, well to quote Wikipedia: "There is no consensus on the precise definition of capitalism, nor how the term should be used as an historical category."

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by barrkel on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:19PM (#2530596)
You keep coming in with this notion of what's legal. That's my very point exactly; what's legal and not is external to the free market itself. It is imposed from without, constraining it, and is not intrinsic to it. Whether contracts for assassination, or prostitution, or raw milk, or cigars from Cuba, etc. are legally traded is a matter of degree, not some self-evident binary choice. All constrain free trade.

People arguing for free trade are generally arguing for a particularly scoped subset of "free" trade, but they take as a relatively unexamined assumption that free trade is inherently good. Usually, there is some trade in particular that they would like to pursue, and they fight laws that inhibit it using free trade as a rallying cry, as if it were a self-evident justification. My point is that free trade by itself is not intrinsically desirable, and that we do in fact want all sorts of limits on what people are free to trade in.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:08AM (#2528134)
I think free software is at odds with certain capitalistic ideas:

As a private owner of a "production" factory, you have control over your products, and through this control you gain profit.

Contrast this with communism, which views private control over things which are needed by the public (like food) as a bad idea because the person in charge gets to limit the freedom of others (or some idea similar to that).

Free Software is similar in this regard: software is ubiquitous, and so it's unethical (according to the philosophy of the FSF) to let it be under the control of corporations. Apple has complete control over iPhones, and they decide what you can and cannot do with it: this is "evil", according to FSF's philosophy.

From a purely capitalistic point of view: a software developer gets an incentive to create and evolve software if it was closed source and hard to crack so that he could sell it and get profit. From a market perspective, this is more efficient.

But, from RMS's perspective, market efficiency shouldn't matter here because the act of putting artificial restriction on software usage is unethical.

While I don't agree with RMS about this thing being necessarily unethical in and of itself; I do find his arguments very compelling, and I'm inclined to say that it's best if one was able to make money doing open source. However, I think one has to be realistic, and in reality developers need money, and so it's ok to sell closed apps (as in iPhone apps, or SaaS webapps like 37signals).

As you can see, my position doesn't have anything to do with capitalism as an ideology.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by dalke on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:47AM (#2528218)
The issue is your statement "you have control over your products" does not apply.

Copyright law legally prevents you from including someone else's software in your work, unless you get permission. The GPL grants you that permission so long as you follow the terms of the license. In other words, it isn't "your products", it's a joint product, and the other contributor wants a say on how the joint product is delivered.

If your product doesn't use anyone else's license, then the FSF does say that it's morally reprehensible to not have free software, but they stay well within copyright law to change the system from within.

Have you considered that perhaps it's copyright's temporary monopoly grant which is "at odds with certain capitalistic ideas"? After all, copyright in US law comes from promoting "the Progress of Science and useful Arts", not making profit.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:04AM (#2528258)
> The GPL grants you that permission so long as you follow the terms of the license. In other words, it isn't "your products", it's a joint product, and the other contributor wants a say on how the joint product is delivered.

I've already responded to this in another comment.

The GPL doesn't "simply grant you this right". FSF think this right is essential and that it's unethical to not grant this right. If RMS simply wanted to give you a permission, he could've used a variation of the BSD/MIT licenses.

> but they stay well within copyright law to change the system from within.

But they still think the system is wrong.

> Have you considered that perhaps it's copyright's temporary monopoly grant which is "at odds with certain capitalistic ideas"?

I've heard this argument, and I don't think it's very compelling, but really what's the point? Why should anyone feel compelled to make such an argument? As if capitalism is the religion of the state, and every ideology must be compatible with it, or else!! So you have to go around and make these interpretation about what "true" capitalism is all about.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by dalke on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:11AM (#2528403)
Ahh, so you are arguing what would happen if the free software movement were able to change copyright law to what they wish. I thought you were talking about the world as it is now, and not the way the FSF would like it to be.

With that in mind I think you can see how I interpreted your comment to mean that the legal expression of free software ideology embedded in the GPL, which depends on current strong copyright law, is at odds with capitalism. If that were the case then strong copyright is at odds with capitalism.

I personally can consider a set of laws in which distributed software must be distributed as free software. I agree that such would be a limitation of the sorts of economics decisions you can make. As such, I can agree that it would be against "certain capitalistic ideas."

However, since we (as a general culture) agree that Mr. Factory Owner may not employ child labor, may not have slaves, may not dump toxic wastes in the water system, must have a safe working environment, and so on, we are already at a point where we (as a culture) agree that "certain capitalistic ideas" are either morally toxic or at least subject to trajedy of the commons oversight.

Since we (as a culture) don't have, and don't want to have, a "purely capitalistic point of view", arguments grounded in that premise are at heart faulty.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by Duff on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:36AM (#2528474)
Here's what what said about the gold standard to differentiate from Bitcoin: "There was no choice in how one could pay, payments were made in a vacuum. All transactions had to be made in a currency backed by gold. That meant that any abuse of the Standard could affect the economy negatively and runs on banks were almost inevitable."

So what? People were and are always free to transact business in any way that they would like, but the coin of the realm that you are required to accept and pay taxes with is/was gold. That doesn't mean that I can't exchange a few bushels of wheat for a goat. Or some coupons for car washes for a sandwich. Or some bitcoin for a webhosting, or whatever you buy with bitcoin.

Bitcoin is only against capitalism in the sense that nobody is going to make a significant amount of money from it.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by kolinko on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:58AM (#2528533)
Saying that "bitcoin means freedom to choose a form of payment" is naive. Let's say that Bitcoin is success, and 98% of internet merchants accept bitcoins as a mean of payment.

This will mean that once I open up a shop, I have to accept it as well, or I'll lose sales. Of course, in theory, nobody would force me to accept Bitcoins, but so is the case today - nobody forces me to use Dollars, or PayPal.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by dpatru on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:55AM (#2528697)
> nobody forces me to use Dollars

Actually, if you're in the US, you do have to use dollars. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_tender#United_States and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_Dollar.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by Duff on Monday May 09, 2011 @10:19AM (#2528772)
You don't have to pay in dollars, but you must accept dollars to settle a debt.

You and I can have a contract where I buy a cow from you today in exchange for an iPod next week, that's a valid contract. But if I cannot produce the iPod next week, you must allow me to give you a quantity of legal tender currency (US coins or paper dollars) to settle the debt.

If you require payment upon receipt, however, you can refuse to exchange the cow for cash.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by Duff on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:51AM (#2528679)
But again, barring some magical event that entices 98% of merchants to accept Bitcoin, why would you accept it versus gold, silver etc?

You still need a middleman to broker the transaction to whatever the legal tender currency is, so why not just exchange shares of GLD or SLV online?

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:27AM (#2528048)
Free software isn't at odds with capitalism. In fact, right of property is what makes free software possible (otherwise you couldn't enforce any free software license).
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:33AM (#2528056)
GPL is a hack; its existence is not an approval of the system in any way, shape or form.

That's not the point though.

Whether Free Software is at odds (or not) with capitalism shouldn't matter at all in any intelligent discussion.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:49AM (#2528088)
You're right in the sense that the free software movement as advocated by Richard Stallman is at odds with capitalism. I really meant "Open source software isn't at odds with capitalism".

But I don't think we should exclude the capitalism debate from an intelligent discussion since it has pretty huge implications. If you're advocating a system that is incompatible with capitalism, you have to first make the case for an alternative to capitalism.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:24AM (#2528170)
It's not as if we live in a purely capitalistic system. In a pure capitalism, there would be no taxes. Yet here we are living in a system where the government takes money from you, specially if you're really rich.

It's not as though any idea that's at odds with capitalism will require "an alternative system". There's not gonna be any change to the system that requires a new theory of economics.

Suppose bitcoins are at odds with capitalism because they're just like gold (yes I know this is ridiculous, but just for argument's sake). What now? Should bitcoiners make a case for an "alternative to capitalism"? No. You will still be able to buy and sell and own property and trade and own factories and rent an office space and build a company and hire employees.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:33AM (#2528191)
I agree that we don't live in a purely capitalist system and in fact, I don't like to call it that way as it undermines its meaning. In a truly capitalist system we wouldn't have this discussion at all since there'd be no federal reserve and currencies would be free to compete against each others. In my opinion, Bitcoin (and the gold standard in some ways) is as close to capitalism as it gets.
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by Amincd on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:29AM (#2528315)
" As someone else pointed out, in a pure capitalism, we'd have slaves, child porn, thugs for hire, assassination contracts, etc."

No you wouldn't. All of those things are the exact opposite of capitalism, since they prevent voluntary association and threaten body, liberty and property.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olavk on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:15AM (#2528581)
So in a capitalist society there will be no pollution?
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:15AM (#2528286)
"as close to capitalism as it gets" is not necessarily a good thing. As someone else pointed out, in a pure capitalism, we'd have slaves, child porn, thugs for hire, assassination contracts, etc.

I just got this idea right now, but I think a pure capitalism will deteriorate very quickly into a dictatorship. All it takes is for someone to accumulate enough military power so that he can take over. Assuming you can buy/sell groups of armed people and/or hire them.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:53AM (#2528363)
You've got it all wrong. Those things are the antithesis of capitalism. I really don't know where to start... May I suggest you watch this documentary: http://www.freetochoose.tv/
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by nazgulnarsil on Monday May 09, 2011 @10:09AM (#2528749)
I can summarize.

in a purely free market people won't want to do business with people who violate others' property rights since you have no guarantee they won't violate yours.

traditionally, guarantees against this have been ethnic. "well I know he won't enslave me since the norm is to only enslave blacks, therefore we can both happily profit from the slave trade and are no threat to each other."

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by Amincd on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:27AM (#2528314)
Capitalism means non-government intervention in your voluntary agreements and interactions with others. In other words, it's freedom.
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by _delirium on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:31AM (#2528464)
There's a lot of disagreement over that word "voluntary", though. People who emphasize the "capitalism" part, as in anarcho-capitalists, tend to take a very loose view of what constitutes voluntary agreement, which is basically anything short of initiating actual physical violence, or perhaps direct threats like putting a gun to someone's head. Others, from the more left-leaning parts of voluntaryist circles, require a stronger definition of voluntary.

The standards of traditional western contract law for what counts as a voluntary agreement (i.e. not one entered into under coercion or duress) are somewhere in between.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by chc on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:29AM (#2528051)
Your viewpoint is only sensible if one is neutral or negative toward capitalism and assumes everyone else must be as well. If you think capitalism is a good thing, then of course something being at odds with it is problematic.
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by m0nty on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:37AM (#2528061)
"If you think capitalism is a good thing, then of course something being at odds with it is problematic."

Something can be problematic but that still doesn't make it a bad idea. It might be a brilliant idea which challenges you to modify your viewpoint - perhaps you end up questioning the particular form of capitalism which you think is good. Perhaps you end up endorsing your former viewpoint and discarding the new idea. hasenj's point is perfectly valid: "If an idea is at odds with capitalism, that doesn't necessarily make it a bad idea" (even if it might be problematic).

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:38AM (#2528071)
Even if you think it's a great idea; it's still possible to be ok with new good ideas even if they happen to be at odds with capitalism.

For instance, I think Open Source is a great idea, but this alone is not good enough reason to think that selling iPhone apps is evil.

Acting very cautious and defensive around capitalism makes it look like a holy untouchable ideology; this is what annoys me.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by olalonde on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:53AM (#2528099)
Again, Open Source is not at odds with capitalism. Capitalism doesn't mean making money or selling stuff. In fact, charities aren't at odds with capitalism. Did you know that Wikipedia's founder, Jimmy Whales, is a libertarian?
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:12AM (#2528145)
Ah careful. RMS's Free Software is not the same thing as Open Source. Open Source in and of itself is not at odds with capitalism. But Free Software is at odds with some ideas of capitalism. (In my humble opinion anyway, which is really irrelevant to my original point).
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by dfox on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:38AM (#2528199)
can you point out the difference between "free software" and "open source" that causes one being at odds with "some ideas of capitalism", while other is not? Apart from "free software" being connected with RMS's ideology.
[deleted]
Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:40AM (#2528075)
This is not RMS's point of view.

RMS doesn't care if you give him back your changes; he cares that you have the freedom to make any changes you wish. He wants you to be free from artificial restrictions imposed by copyright laws. He doesn't care if you share your changes with him.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by geon on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:02AM (#2528119)
> He doesn't care if you share your changes with him.

Well, he does care if you make your changes available to the users of your software so that they too can make the changes they need. That's the whole point of the license, or you should just use MIT/BSD.

Re:Bitcoin money ≠ the Gold Standard. by hasenj on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:16AM (#2528151)
Yes, so he cares about the freedom of the user to change software. He doesn't care whether or not these users share these changes with each other and collaborate to develop the software. Although he thinks that's a nice-to-have side effect.

He cares that this freedom propagates to all users, not just you, and so just like he gave you this freedom, you also must pass on this freedom.