Even much-vaunted New York City is not as strong as it might appear at first glance. NYC in 2011 is a single-industry town... finance IS NYC. Even the feature that defined NY for centuries -- New York Harbor -- contributes almost nothing to the state, as the freight terminals fled overegulation to New Jersey (of all places) in the 1970's.
30-40 years ago, the city had a diversified mix of finance, manufacturing and service industries. There were over 10,000 manufacturing firms in the city in 1970. Now both the NY state and city are living off of a sole benefactor -- Wall St.
"why does New York have a substantially larger economy?"
Well, location, history (it was there first), a port (its not land-locked), huge population, and many other factors you've disregarded might be the reasons, for starters.
The only quote you give
'low taxes and corrupt government good, labor protection and regulation, bad'
is not in the article: it isn't a quote so why the quote marks? That's outright deception.
What an utterly ignorant and vicious post!
So I disagree that my post is ignorant or vicious. That is not a direct quote, sure, but looking at the how the various states were obviously 'scored' it is pretty clear what is going on: CEOs value short-term and unsustainable business incentives, which may be fine as far as it goes but if you can't see why that precludes them from having a good influence on government policy then I don't have much else to say to you, I'm afraid.
That is not true (as the article shows). CEOs use many factors in choosing a state within which to locate their business.
If everyone believed as you, would that be a good thing? Did you expect, in a democracy, that everyone else would see things as you do? If you are over the age of 12, it is late in life to realize that other people do not think as you do.
*The Political Mind: Why You Can't Understand 21st-Century American Politics with an 18th-Century Brain by George Lakoff
This is little more than another exhibit to show how little American CEOs do to earn their ridiculous salaries.