News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by cromwellian on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:42AM (#25264106)
Watch Robert Whyte's presentation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4 The basic problems have all been solved, the science has been solved too. Tokamaks have already made net fusion power. The only difference between JET, which already succeeded, and ARC, is using Magnets with 2.6x the field strength. The B^4 power scaling, gives you about 50x the power, so ARC will generate 500 MW of power whereas JET (remember, already proven engineering), generated 10MW.

So without a doubt, this is just an engineering problem at this point. A prototype device that didn't have to be maintained, could be built exactly like any other Tokamak, just with REBCO magnets, and you'd have the required fusion power.

To get the required electric power, and add in maintenance, you need to at the FliBe liquid blanket, replacable toroid sections, and a heat exchanger, but again, these are known engineering problems with known solutions, akin to knowing that landing a rocket is possible, but figuring out the grid fins, heat shield, landing legs, and guidance software.

Fusion devices on a small scale have been proving the plasma physics since the 90s. We don't have fusion yet simply because of people being conservative and sticking with traditional "known to work" magnets, which is why ITER is a huge, hulking monstrosity.

As Dr Whyte says, cost scales by R, R can be reduced by a factor of 10 from ITER simply by using different magnets, so ARC will produce the same power as ITER, but significantly smaller and cheaper.

The basic papers have been peer reviewed by Nature, and the science and engineering have been found solid, and thus, the economic arguments as well. Ergo, this is exactly like the SpaceX scenario vs ULA and NASA (e.g. SLS). Small allows fast iteration, fast innovation. ITER's going to spend $20 billion and 20+ years of development just to turn around a realize that the follow on to ITER will need to use HTS magnets and a smaller design.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by thinkcontext on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @09:16AM (#25265319)
> Tokamaks have already made net fusion power.

Nope. The record for Q is .67 set by JET in 1997. The whole justification for ITER is that it would be able to do Q > 1.

Why do you think that net power has been achieved?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_energy_gain_factor

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @08:56AM (#25265116)
> The basic problems have all been solved

The basic problems of power density and complexity have not been solved. Putative REBCO magnets do not solve these problems. Yes, these are engineering problems, but engineering problems are perfectly capable of being fatal. After all, fission has faced only engineering problems since 1942, and yet still has failed.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by rkangel on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @09:07AM (#25265212)
You could make an argument that Fission has succeeded on a technical front (large amounts of electricity are being generated for multiple countries at this precise moment), and that most of its problems are social.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @04:58PM (#25270540)
No, the primary problem of fission is economic, not social. That's why it's been a global failure. It simply has not been able to compete with the alternatives.

And this is why fusion is such a boondoggle. It's similar to fission, only even more complex and expensive. It's like the opposite of Keep It Simple, Stupid.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by cromwellian on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @03:18AM (#25274280)
No, Pressured Water Reactors (LPWRs) are large, expensive, dangerous, etc. Molten Salt Reactors, especially Thorium Molten Salt Reactors (e.g. LFTR) are much much smaller and passively safe.

What you're missing is that cost scales with volume. If you use a technology that allows you to reduce your reactor size by a linear factor of 2, you reduce its reduce volume and cost by a factor of 8.

Likewise, while ITER is uber expensive like large PWRs, ARC is 10 times smaller, and a factor of 30 times or more cheaper. It's also not as complex as some fission reactors, the most complex elements being the HTS magnets and the blanket.

This is the problem with ITER and PWRs, they have convinced the public that nuclear energy is inherently dangerous and expensive and impossible to make substantially safer, cleaner, and cheaper, but that is false.

You should look up at the history of LPWRs vs MSRs from the guy who invented them. There's a documentary on the Oak Ridge Molten Salt Reactor experiment. He himself thought LPWRs were too dangerous requiring ginormous size and shielding, but the US government and cronies, preferred LPWRs, and so MSRs were abandoned, despite successful trials.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @08:20AM (#25276077)
The Molten Salt Reactor designs I have seen have lower volumetric power density than PWRs. The MSRE reactor had a volumetric power density of 2 MW/m^3, a factor of 10 lower than a commercial PWR (counting the volume of the entire primary reactor vessel; the power density in the core of a PWR is a factor of 5 higher than that.) Of course that was an experiment, but look at something like Moltex's design and the power density is still lower than a PWR, last I looked.

> Likewise, while ITER is uber expensive like large PWRs, ARC is 10 times smaller, and a factor of 30 times or more cheaper.

The ARC design is smaller than ITER, but it's still very much lower (a factor of 40) in power density than a fission reactor.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by cromwellian on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @05:20PM (#25282494)
The power density isn't the only variable that matters. The difference doesn't matter if the cost to build a Thorium Molten Salt Reactor is much lower, especially in terms of safety and size. MSR's don't need enormous containment vessels, they also reprocess fuel.

Here's some links showing power densities inline with PWRs, or greater:

https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2013/12/molten-salt-reactor-ab...

"Extrapolating from other liquid-to-liquid heat exchangers, roughly 150 MW/m3 is a practical upper limit to the power density of a primary-to-intermediate salt heat exchanger. For comparison, pressurized-water reactor core power density is ~110 MW/m3." https://info.ornl.gov/sites/publications/files/Pub29596.pdf

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by ncmncm on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @04:12AM (#25274702)
The fact is, there is no reasonable expectation of ever getting viable commercial power from a tokamak-style fusion reactor. The density of energy production, in watts per cubic meter, is so low that an impractically large volume of confined plasma would be needed, requiring a reactor many times larger than a fission plant for the same power output. But fission-driven power is itself too expensive to produce to justify deploying on its own merits.

Furthermore, since the power must be extracted by intercepting high-energy neutrons after they have blasted through the plasma focusing apparatus, such a plant would destroy its most expensive parts in a short time, requiring frequent rebuilding -- by robots, because of induced radioactivity at the work site.

There has never been any expectation of practical commercial power resulting from plasma-confinement thermal-neutron fusion projects. Their only plausible budgetary justification is as a jobs program for high-neutron-flux physicists. They are called for by military policy as a population to draw personnel from for weapons work.

Coal has always been cheaper than fission. Solar and wind power costs are much less, and continue falling; and numerous viable energy storage methods, all demanding no fundamental research -- gravity (solid and aqueous), underground and underwater compressed air, LH2, ammonia, methane from captured CO2, even powdered iron -- vie only for which will end up cheapest to deploy and operate.

If a commercial reactor were ever built and made to work, it would take many decades just to break even on the money already spent to date, before bevinning to pay down its own construction -- even presuming it could find a market for its output. In practice, without continued public subsidy as long as it operated, its debt would continue to grow indefinitely.

The only responsible course for the future is to cancel all publicly funded thermal-neutron fusion work, immediately.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @08:23AM (#25276096)
I think there is a slim chance that nuclear could remain relevant. The key would be greatly reducing the cost of the non-nuclear side of the power plant. Perhaps the best approach would be replacing large steam turbines with far more compact supercritical CO2 turbines. This would require temperatures somewhat higher than from PWRs. And this (not thorium, not waste destruction, nor really even safety) is perhaps the best argument for molten salt reactors.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by ncmncm on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @02:55PM (#25280763)
Nukes remain potentially relevant for space systems.

For example, in the cloud tops of Venus, an air turbine may be constructed from a very large, balloon-supported polypropylene fabric tube with an air turbine on top as its only moving part, and a no-moving-parts naked atomic pile suspended near the bottom, heating air directly -- by neutrons colliding with atmospheric CO2 -- that rises to drive the turbine. Some of the air would become radioactive, but so what?

In free-fall, a reactor at the end of a long-enough tether would present no risk of environmental contamination or user safety, and so could dispense with both the containment vessel and shielding. Even there, though, pB seems a more atractive goal than thermal neutrons, because destroying your plasma focus apparatus every few months would get tedious.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by cromwellian on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @05:45PM (#25282774)
Nukes are absolutely needed for any deep space missions beyond Mars. Unless you're going with laser propulsion or solar sails.

Moreover, if you can fit a compact reactor (fission or fusion) on a space ship, then you can run nuclear thermal (ISP >800), or nuclear ion engines with extreme efficiency. (>15,000 ISP!) Considering NASA's Kilowatt reactor weights 2tons, assume a dry mass of 10t and a payload of 2%, you end up with a 500t ship (wow, do we even have 498 metric tons of xenon in the world?), but with a delta-v of 500,000 m/s. That gets you to Pluto flyby in 99 days. (I didn't count the Kilowatt reactor fuel weight, I'm not sure how much uranium is needed for a 15,000 Isp burn, I was just interested how much delta-v 15,000 Isp buys you.)

SpaceX starship, if it works, could launch this in about 4 refuelings. (>100-125t to LEO)

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @05:48PM (#25282803)
Space applications cannot justify any significant use of nuclear power on Earth. To the extent space uses are valuable, the relevant stakeholders can pay for it.

Nuclear reactors would be wonderful for use on Titan, btw. Simple open Brayton cycle systems would be highly effective at quite reasonable core temperature.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by DrNuke on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:10AM (#25264235)
It was mainly an engineering issue: materials, manufacturing and assembling. It is too big to fail right now, and most issues have been solved. It never was as simple as webinars from scientists would make it. The funniest joke within nuclear eng insiders is the marvels of paper reactors pretty always make real reactors just seem glorified boilers.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by cromwellian on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:28AM (#25264330)
ITER's too big the fail. But again, the parameters were known. The magnets give you the field strength, the field strength tells you the radius, the radius^3 gives you the cost, and also, some measure of the construction time.

This is one of the great things about Elon Musk -- he looks at things from first principles. When it looked like he needed 1000 Gigafactories to reach his goal, he went back to the drawing board on decades of battery manufacturing, to come up with the Terafactory.

When carbon composite rockets looked to be too hard to manufacture, and have too many other detriments, despite the clear wins in strength-to-weight, he dropped it and went with stainless steel. I'm pretty sure if he was staring at the basic Tokamak equations, he would have long again saw the economic and time dependence on R, and the massive benefits to improving B, and that would have driven him to look for alternatives.

Too many researchers engage in sunk cost / dollar auctions, doubling down on obvious wrong approaches, because they've already spent so much.

This is also why DeepMind won CASP again, because rather than try to iteratively improve their 2018 result, they dropped it as a dead end and restarted with a completely new approach, even though the 2018 approach was also a revolutionary breakthrough.

What I'm getting at is, being able to let go of your previous projects if they are stalling, with huge cost over runs, and a mediocre future return, is a value we should seek in fusion research, and elsewhere.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by DrNuke on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:42AM (#25264382)
Ok but ITER was much more than engineering: soft diplomacy, supranational bureaucracy, manufacturing modernisation. Musk comes from a different era and a different environment but, again, launching rockets successfully, with humans in them safely going and coming back, was achieved well before him. Stable nuclear fusion is still unclaimed as a milestone, even if sustainable nuclear fusion might well come from different, smaller approaches the likes we are seeing from United Kingdom and South Korea.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:09PM (#25270668)
Going back to first principles is how you conclude DT fusion is a dead end. And this has been known for decades.

http://orcutt.net/weblog/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/The-Trou...

(That prescient article has stood the test of time, except that advanced fuels were mostly ruled out also.)

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by cromwellian on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @03:43AM (#25274479)
Except the article is wrong, because it makes fundamental assumptions about the vacuum wall and lithium blanket, and even the superconductors. The ARC reactor, for example, doesn't use a solid sandwich style blanket, it uses a volumetric blanket of FLiBe, a liquid that acts as the moderator that absorbs neutrons, the breeder, the magnetic shield, and the heat exchanger -- and has proven to work in molten salt reactor prototypes. And unlike the designs he claims that are "essentially unchanged", this significantly reduces the cost and mass of the reactor, reduces the so-called "danger" of lithium, and leverages the fact that high energy fusion neutrons travel further, as it increases the efficacy of the liquid blanket.

The claim that neutrons will damage the metal structure is also handled by many aspects of the design: easy reparability thanks to modular, segmented magnets, being completely submerged in the liquid blanket, low activation steel for structure, and the pulse design which runs the reactor in a way that reduces overall temperature of the walls.

Plus, he brings up the ole aneutronic fusion dream, except that creating a confined Boron-11 plasma is much more difficult, outside the realm of tokamaks, and typically proposes using laser internal confinement fusion at the Petawatt scale.

More than 20 papers were published on ARC, heavily vetted in journals like Nature, and pretty much all of the peer review concluded the design will work, and if it does work, then it will be much cheaper than ITER, simpler than ITER, and thus refute your paper.

We'll know in about 4 years.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @08:12AM (#25276007)
No. The article makes no assumptions about superconductors. The argument makes no assumption even about plasma confinement. It's all about the limits on areal power density at the reactor walls.

The conclusion he reaches, that fusion reactors will have a volumetric power density at least an order of magnitude lower than a fission reactor, is not contradicted by ARC. The volumetric power density of ARC (from the ARC paper I linked to elsewhere in these comments) is 0.5 MW(th)/m^3 (counting the volume of the entire reactor, not just the plasma) vs. 20 MW(th)/m^3 for the primary reactor vessel of a PWR -- a factor of 40 worse.

His suggestion to look at aneutronic plasmas didn't pan out, as you note, but that doesn't save DT fusion. I'll note that it's his PhD student Todd Rider who shot down the non-Maxwellian schemes that aneutronic fuels would have needed. After that, Lidsky switched to working on fission for the rest of career and life.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by cromwellian on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @04:43PM (#25282049)
The latest ARC claims from Whyte's last presentation was 3MW/m^3 density, and that's with currently achievable magnets, not those people believe are ultimately achievable. Counting just the PWR reactor vessel, and not the entire containment facility, seems a huge cheat.

We're talking economics of energy. PWR Fission reactors have enormous footprints, averaging 1 square mile. An ARC reactor wouldn't need anywhere need that size. The very nature of using pressurized water means your containment facility has to be a factor of 1000 larger than the reactor vessel to handle a flash boil over.

Current costs to build a 1GW fission plant are $6-9 billion. Predicted costs to build a 200MW ARC reactor are $4-5 billion, so the ARC reactor costs ~5x more at the high end, and 77% more at the low end, for the same output (e.g. build 5 ARC reactors to equal one fission plant). The economics are still viable, and your costs for storage, disposal, and de-comissioning are far lower, as is your land footprint. Note that these ARC costs are for the first reactor, include the sunk development costs, and not the economies of scale that would occur from dropping HTS costs.

> It's all about the limits on areal power density at the reactor walls.

No, he makes lots of assumptions about how the magnets are shielded, how breeding works, and how heat transfer works. All of these are addressed by FLiBe, there's no "structure" to the heat blanket to damage, it acts simultaneously as radioactive shielding for the magnets, heat transfer, and a breeder. The "blanket" in ARC isn't a surface sandwiched with a super structure, it's a volume that's continuously pumped and recirculated.

He also makes the implicit assumption that reactor wall damage is a huge problem. Instead of seeing it as a problem, you should see it as a solution, like an ablative heat shield on a rocket or capsule. As long as the cost of maintenance or replacement is low, and reactor downtime is limited, it is not a problem. Current estimates for ARC, which is designed to be modular, so it can be easily maintained, is that the reactor walls will last about 1 year.

He doesn't even mention the biggest unsolved engineering problem, removing the "ash" (Helium) that accumulates in the plasma.

His article has all the trappings of reusable rocket naysayers in the 80s and 90s, who claimed reusables could never work, because carrying wings, landing legs, heat shielding, and structural reinforcement to make rapid reusability would cut down on your usable payload, and thus doom reusable rockets to always be substantially inferior. And this is because of an obsession with a single variable, like power density, or payload fraction, and ignoring the end to end economics of the entire system, including safety margins, maintenance, footprint, etc.

And that's why I believe ARC will prove Lidsky wrong.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @05:30PM (#25282606)
> The latest ARC claims from Whyte's last presentation was 3MW/m^3 density,

That's per volume of PLASMA, not volume of REACTOR. Since we're talking about the size of the things we have to pay for (the reactor) the latter is appropriate.

> Counting just the PWR reactor vessel, and not the entire containment facility, seems a huge cheat.

Fusion reactors will also require containment vessels, to prevent escape of tritium in accidents (unless you're ok with an accident rendering ground water in a large area around the reactor undrinkable for decades.) The containment vessel will have to be large enough to contain all the cryogens heated to accident temperature. Unlike in a PWR like the AP1000, these volatiles cannot be condensed by water cooling. In ITER, for example, complete volatilization of the cryogens would requires several times the volume of the AP1000 containment building.

The ARC design adds to accident fun by having a large volume of titanium hydride shielding near the molten salt. TiH2 decomposes to Ti and hydrogen gas at 450 C, well below the temperature of the molten salt blanket. Fully decomposed, this TiH2 would release 15 tonnes of hydrogen, occupying 180,000 cubic meters at STP.

Beyond that, the containment building around a fusion reactor will have to mitigate tritium leakage by many orders of magnitude. This will be expensive (in particular, polymer seals cannot be used on penetrations as they permeate tritium.)

ARC will also require a large volume for disassembly of the reactor for vacuum vessel replacement, and for remote control demolition of activated vacuum vessels for disposal. All that volume will become contaminated and off limits to human access.

> PWR Fission reactors have enormous footprints, averaging 1 square mile. An ARC reactor wouldn't need anywhere need that size.

Really good farmland in the US is less than $10K/acre, or about $6M/square mile. Cheap range land is an order of magnitude less; really useless land another order of magnitude cheaper. The cost of land there is a very minor part (0.1%) of the cost of the power plant.

https://www.howmuchisit.org/acre-of-land-cost/

> No, he makes lots of assumptions about how the magnets are shielded, how breeding works, and how heat transfer works.

Again, you have not understood his argument. His argument would apply even if you had 100T magnets made of unobtainium and a plasma configuration with beta = 1. All that he requires is an upper limit on how much energy per area can be transmitted through the surface of the reactor. This is a function of the materials of the first wall, and has absolutely nothing to do with magnets or breeding.

> Predicted costs to build a 200MW ARC reactor are $4-5 billion

If you are referring to the cost estimate from the arxiv paper, that is just the estimated cost of the reactor itself, not the power plant containing the reactor. I will admit I found the estimation methodology in that paper very cursory, so it's possible they were overestimating the cost (80% of the cost was the stainless steel magnet support structure.)

A fission reactor core is much cheaper than that estimate, per MW.

> He doesn't even mention the biggest unsolved engineering problem, removing the "ash" (Helium) that accumulates in the plasma.

And why should he? I mean, why does he have to kill the corpse a third time (after the power density and reliability arguments)?

> And that's why I believe ARC will prove Lidsky wrong.

As I said earlier, the power density figures from ARC show he was right.