News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @12:51AM (#25262750)
And ARC "work" in the sense of a reactor having the weight of a couple of WW2 destroyers.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by jabl on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:25AM (#25264025)
Well, ARC is supposed to produce an order of magnitude more power than a WW2 destroyer power plant produced, so I'm not sure why that comparison is relevant. The first application of fusion reactors will presumably not be naval ships.

Anyway, assuming your 4000 ton figure is correct, that works out to 125 kW/ton. For comparison, a quick googling suggests a wind power plant is around 3 kW/ton, excluding the rather massive foundation of the tower.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @08:45AM (#25265032)
That weight figure (7190 tonnes, not 4000) for ARC is just for the reactor.

https://arxiv.org/pdf/1409.3540.pdf (page 30)

The net output of ARC in that design is 190 MW(e), which comes to 26 kW(e)/tonne.

It doesn't include anything outside the reactor, which would likely increase the weight by at least an order of magnitude. It doesn't include (for example) the cryo plant, tritium processing, heat exchangers, turbines, cooling system, the BUILDING, and facilities for installation and disposal of vacuum vessels.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by jabl on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @12:36PM (#25267473)
> That weight figure (7190 tonnes, not 4000) for ARC is just for the reactor.

https://arxiv.org/pdf/1409.3540.pdf (page 30)

Thanks. As I hadn't seen that paper, I used the Fletcher class destroyer, which was the most numerous class the US built, and it was slightly on the larger side at about 2000 tons; common destroyers were around 1500 tons IIRC. I also assumed, wrongly it seems, that 500 MW was the electrical power.

Anyways, if we're really interested in material requirements for various power plant types, one can check e.g. the DOE quadrennial energy review 2015, Table 10.4 on page 390. One can see that fission does pretty well, about an order of magnitude better than wind (and solar being somewhat worse than wind). I would guess fusion wouldn't do as well as fission, but it shouldn't be a huge difference either considering that except the reactor itself it should be pretty similar.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @10:29AM (#25265985)
Why are we examining weight, when the cheapest source of electricity is hydroelectric, and they are the heaviest structures ever constructed?

The Hoover Dam weighs like 120 battleships.

Its just the wrong metric to measure.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by HPsquared on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:53AM (#25264151)
That's an improvement on ITER, which weighs as much as a WW1 battleship.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @09:04AM (#25265179)
ITER is so horrendously far from competitive (in power density, in cost) that a fusion reactor can be much better than ITER and still be completely impractical.