News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by jiggawatts on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:07PM (#25261850)
You're spot on, this is exactly the problem.

To use a physics analogy, gargantuan megaprojects like ITER develop their own selfgravitation that sucks in money and innovation, crushing engineers pitilessly under the weight of the bureaucracy.

To further abuse analogies, megaprojects suffer from something akin to the tyranny of the rocket equation: Because they're huge and expensive, they have to be broken up and doled out to disparate teams (countries even!), subcontractors, etc... Because there are many organisations involved, the friction of the interactions between force managers to plan ahead. Because planning ahead is required, only existing, established technologies can be used.

QED: It is not possible to do "innovation" with megaprojects, their mega size inherently prevents any possibility of true innovation occurring! The bigger they are, the less innovative they are.

I cannot emphasise this enough: Elements of the ITER project have been planned 30 years ahead! That's insanity. That's using 1990s technology in the 2020s! There is no possible path through ITER and then DEMO to achieve commercial power generation before 2050. None. There is not even a hope of such a thing.

Most critically, ITER used a legacy superconducting wire in their designs, which has a lower maximum magnetic field strength compared to more modern types. Because of the highly nonlinear scaling (quartic?) with increasing field strength, this is the fundamental limit to achieving break-even fusion, but they were forced to start planning without it.

They should have done what Tesla did: Focus on the batteries as the primary thing, everything else is secondary. ITER should have focused on the superconducting wires above all else for at least the first two decades of the project, before even thinking of actually opening a CAD program to design a Tokamak!

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by the_french on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @04:35AM (#25263806)
I think it's misleading to say ITERs technology is 30 years behind. A lot of the tech that has been going into the ITER design didn't exist 30 years ago! They didn't anticipate developments in super conductors but this is by no means a 90s machine built 30 years too late.

Part of the role of ITER was to fund the research to develop the reactor's components while giving everyone a concrete goal to work towards. The challenge with ITER is much more than construction.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by throwaway_pdp09 on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @04:35AM (#25263810)
Are you speaking from personal experience with ITER? You've said some damning things about projects in general but there's no backup for:

"crushing engineers pitilessly under the weight of the bureaucracy"

"Elements of the ITER project have been planned 30 years ahead"

"There is no possible path through ITER and then DEMO to achieve commercial power generation before 2050. None"

"ITER used a legacy superconducting wire in their designs"

Further

> Because planning ahead is required, only existing, established technologies can be used.

You can't plan to use nonexisting technologies when that tech (superconductivity) was so very little understood.

Your criticisms seem unwarranted and unverifiable.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mlindner on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:05AM (#25264209)
> You can't plan to use nonexisting technologies when that tech (superconductivity) was so very little understood.

That's exactly the problem. No one is allowed to fail so nothing is discovered.

And exactly how is superconductivity so very little understood? It's used in massive projects the world over from superconducting cables to maglev trains to numerous other things. And none of that has been figured out by ITER. ITER is the worst thing for fusion research in decades.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by throwaway_pdp09 on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:19AM (#25264285)
This is a ridiculous response.

> No one is allowed to fail so nothing is discovered.

2nd para in wiki article: "It [ITER] is an experimental tokamak nuclear fusion reactor" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER) It is an experiment, it was never expected to have certain outcomes.You don't seem to understand that.

> And exactly how is superconductivity so very little understood?

That's not what I said. Here "when that tech (superconductivity) was so very little understood"

Note: 'was'. Not 'is'. (see edit below)

As for the progression in their understanding I'll leave that for a physicist to discuss. You aren't.

Edit: see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconductivity#High-tempera... for a list of recent stuff (eg. last 15 years). And stop shouting about how stupid everyone else is.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mlindner on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @05:25PM (#25282561)
And ITER isn't using those newer superconductors. They're using outdated tech before it's even finished building.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by 14u2c on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @02:11AM (#25263117)
> It is not possible to do "innovation" with megaprojects

I generally agree but I think the are examples of some successful projects that did innovate. You could probably consider Gemini + Apollo a single megaproject as they were designed to run consecutively, building towards the moon.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by japanuspus on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:22AM (#25264009)
I think the key factor is not the size, but the type of management: Apollo, SpaceX (and the Manhattan project for that matter) all had technical leadership, and where headed by people who could basically have pulled the whole project off with a sufficient number of clones of themselves.

ITER is under MBA/Political management. Even if the management team had all the time in the world, they could not complete the project on their own.

Especially in ground-breaking projects, this makes a huge difference. With many options open, deciding on how to proceed requires cross-subsystem trade-offs and weighing many different risks and challenges against each other: things that will grind any non-technical leadership to a halt as they request piles upon piles of reports from their underlings.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by henrikeh on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:58AM (#25264435)
I don’t think it is fair to say that Apollo could have been pulled off by a few kind of people. It was a massive undertaking spanning almost all fields of science and engineering. Just read a book like _Stages to Saturn_ to see what an undertaking it was to just conceive, design, implement and _manage_ the Saturn rockets.

But I’m more curious about your second statement. Could you back that up with some evidence? How is ITER’s management and leadership “MBA/Political”? Is it really different from the other projects’? Such a statement needs to be backed up with some evidence.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by kaibee on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @07:27AM (#25264570)
> But I’m more curious about your second statement. Could you back that up with some evidence? How is ITER’s management and leadership “MBA/Political”? Is it really different from the other projects’? Such a statement needs to be backed up with some evidence.

Maybe a bit conspiracy minded, but maybe the real purpose is to give nuclear physicists something to do, so that the brains to make nukes are still around in case we ever need to start doing that again?

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by kortex on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @08:18AM (#25264844)
This is absolutely an element at play at NIF. In fact not just the physics brains, but the experiments themselves, play a role in getting around test bans. To the point where nuke stewardship (ensuring aging warheads still will work) interferes with fusion physics.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by Zardoz84 on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @10:07AM (#25265784)
if that the case, a totemak fusion reactor it's totally unrelated to how a nuclear bomb works.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by emteycz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @02:29AM (#25263196)
Now imagine Apollo was planned as a gargantuan Warp 6-capable starship with 500-man crew instead of the several smaller rockets progressively building towards an achievable goal.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by bserge on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @04:07AM (#25263699)
It would probably be more correct to say there is no incentive.

Gemini and Apollo had a nice one - the space race, more specifically, the fear of being bombed into oblivion from orbital stations without being able to do anything about it.

There's just not much incentive today, it makes business sense to use that funding as long as possible.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by satellite2 on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @04:06AM (#25263687)
Did anyone said CERN?
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by heavenlyblue on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:31PM (#25261991)
The corrolary to your message is “don’t build mega-projects” which doesn’t make sense to me.

And no, Tesla didn’t start by selling batteries: they started by selling expensive cars which didn’t need the batteries at the same scale as mass-produced car; which kind of destroys the meaning of whole of your initial message.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by dralley on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:43PM (#25262060)
Also, Tesla didn't start by using any fancy battery chemistries, they started by packaging cheap "shitty" commercial cells alongside enough monitoring and management hardware to keep them from catching fire or damaging themselves.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by YetAnotherNick on Monday November 30, 2020 @11:04PM (#25262185)
> The corrolary to your message is “don’t build mega-projects” which doesn’t make sense to me.

I think the two posters meant that size of the people working on a single thing is negatively correlated with innovation. The analogy was that Tesla is less ground breaking now compared to when it was experimental.

> The corrolary to your message is “don’t build mega-projects”

Mega projects are more optimized for delivery and leaving lesser things on luck and it is beneficial in most of the cases. But posters are saying given the vast scope of things that could be tried in fusion space, mega projects likely won't be touching those.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by kiba on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:34PM (#25262013)
I don't think that's necessary the case.

Instead, you approach the megaproject as a series of prototypes, spending large sum of money in the hope of quick advancement and iteration cycle.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by Retric on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:51PM (#25262106)
That already happened in the ITER development process with early version safety sitting on people’s desks. Sometimes you get an awesome breakthrough that makes everything work, other times no so much.

ITER is designed to be a test bed not the final design. Plenty of advancements have taken place after the design was essentially finalized, but none of them actually help test things like heavy neutron bombardment of a lithium blanket.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @08:53AM (#25265091)
That really isn't the major problem. The major problem is that a large institutional effort has gone down a blind alley. It's not that it's making inefficient local choices; the global choice to pursue fusion at all is to blame. The badness of the top level goal will seep down to the rest of the program.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by derivagral on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @11:08AM (#25266389)
Could you elaborate on why you consider fusion as a dead end?
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:04PM (#25270612)
For fundamental reasons (see footnote), the power density of a fusion reactor will be bad compared to a fission reactor. And because the fusion reactor will also be much more technologically intricate, it will necessarily be much more expensive. Since the balance of plant will be similar (or favorably to fission also; no cryo plant or tritium recovery needed, for example), fission will be cheaper than fusion. And fission is already losing economically.

(*) The fundamental reason is that the power from the fusion reactor must radiate through the wall of the reactor, while the power from fission is transferred into coolant flowing through the reactor. As a result, the volumetric power density will be lower by roughly a factor of (diameter of fusion reactor) / (spacing of fuel elements in fission reactor), for equal power/area through the walls of the fusion reactor and fuel rods. ITER, for example, has a power density 400 times worse than a commercial PWR primary reactor vessel.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by xyzzyz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @07:08PM (#25271763)
You make good points, but I think you should revisit your assumptions.

Fission is so expensive mainly because of safety and regulatory concerns: radioactivity scares people, and so safety requirements are cranked up to 11: everything is overdesigned just so that current regulator is confident enough (next one might one up anyway), lots and lots of concrete and steel is used for containment etc. Additionally, the whole construction process is hopelessly bureaucratic and takes forever, requiring inspections of inspections, redesigns for things that in, say, coal plants would just be redone differently by contractor on site and so on. We most definitely could make fission significantly cheaper, and in fact it has been so in the past.

Now, fusion does not have similar safety requirements. If the plant blows up for some reason, there's no significant radionuclide contamination. Therefore, there's little reason to require safety standards significantly higher than those for coal plants (the boilers of which can also catastrophically blow up). This makes it significantly cheaper, due to reduced material use and construction time/labor for containment, and reduced regulatory delays.

Your point about power density is also good, but I don't think it matters very much in practice. Sure, fusion reactor might have significantly lower power density than fission reactor, but so what? Renewable plants are even worse when it comes to power density, yet it doesn't stop them from being rolled out. We don't lack space for fusion plants, even if they are much larger than equivalent fission ones.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @08:29PM (#25272278)
Fission is expensive because all the components have to be highly reliable, for safety reasons.

But in a fusion reactor, all the components also have to be highly reliable, because they will be so radioactive that repair will be difficult or impossible. The stuff that's hot in a fusion reactor will be far more complex than the stuff in a fission reactor, which is technically very simple.

The reliability is costly, regardless of the reason for it.

Of course power density matters. The cost of manufactured items is related to their size, and fusion reactor cores will be far larger than fission reactor cores (as well as being far more intricate). Are you saying this 10-100x larger size will NOT be reflected in the cost?

Renewables have lower power density, but also allow omission of entire parts of a thermal power plant. No steam turbines, no heat exchangers, no cooling systems. They also tolerate far less reliable components, because failure affect just a small part of the overall output of a field of turbines or PV modules.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by choonway on Monday November 30, 2020 @11:31PM (#25262312)
yep. should be focusing on the monkey, not the pedestal. but it's hard to convince unenlightened bureaucracy.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by __jf__ on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @12:25AM (#25262616)
Thanks for the rabbit hole. It made me discover an interview [0] with Googles captain of moonshots. In it he also discusses other interesting moonshot management strategies, besides the monkey-pedestal one.

[0] https://www.wsj.com/video/astro-teller-on-moonshots-for-alph...

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by TaylorAlexander on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @03:41AM (#25263557)
I worked as a contractor at X for two years and one thing that really contributes to their success is the fat dump trucks of money they have to spend on things. Astro is a super nice guy, but I worry that X gives themselves lots of credit for being master innovators when in reality their secret may be that they have a firehouse full of hundred dollar bills they can point at things and see what sticks.

Tbh I may be way off base but I was really surprised at how much money they spent on things.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by choonway on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @09:09AM (#25265235)
I also worked at an institute which badgered us to go after 'low hanging fruits' and build a whole bunch of pedestals and ended up with a tv screen and a CGI monkey reciting Shakespeare on a shoestring budget.

I'd would have worked on training the monkey to press buttons the same way they domesticated the fox in siberia, but it would take too long and they didn't want to deal with the hard regulatory stuff.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by layoutIfNeeded on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:52AM (#25264148)
Strange, we used to be able to pull of megaprojects like the Manhatta Project or the Apollo Program.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mlindner on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:03AM (#25264203)
The Manhattan project actually had a relatively small number of physicists driving the program. Additionally they decided to allow failures. There were dozens of other projects under the project that all ended up as failures that no one really has heard about.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by shireboy on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @08:00AM (#25264724)
That’s a really interesting point. Do you have info on those failed projects? Would love to read more about that.