News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by protomyth on Saturday May 07, 2011 @11:14AM (#2523849)
I'm glad that SpaceX is so concerned with cost. It is sometimes hard for a company to stay focused on that when they get a government contract.

As for the rest, I would imagine when robots get good enough, then the incentive to use cheap labor in China drops and factories in the US become more economically viable.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by pradocchia on Saturday May 07, 2011 @03:20PM (#2524359)
I have often wondered whether free trade of goods has retarded the development of more sophisticated automation & robotics. What technology advancements have we missed out on when it's been cheaper to move manufacturing to China, rather than make capital investments at home?

Note that any decision to off-shore is distorted by a) limits to the free movement of labor and b) currency manipulation. So at the margin, you might replace an efficient domestic operation w/ an inefficient foreign process, and make up the difference in currency and labor cost arbitrage. In such cases, free trade of goods alone has a detrimental effect on technological progress. Or at least that's the speculation.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by jerf on Saturday May 07, 2011 @09:08PM (#2525006)
"I have often wondered whether free trade of goods has retarded the development of more sophisticated automation & robotics."

I doubt the effect has been that profound. From what I can see of the history of robots and automation, the choke point over the past 50 years has not been cheap labor, but expensive real-time computation. We only recently got CPUs that we could really do anything with. Even 320x200x15fps in black and white, a resolution you'd have a hard time actually "living" in as your only sensory input (and if humans find it hard, computers even moreso), is about a million things a second. When you've got processors running at 33MHz, it's hard to get very far, just as one example.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by Dove on Saturday May 07, 2011 @05:47PM (#2524655)
I don't mind. Sending manufacturing jobs overseas raises the standard of living there and introduces technology and industry to the region. The folks doing those jobs won't be stuck at that income level forever.

I think my standard of living is pretty good. If I could have super robots next decade, or I could have them in three decades after conditions around the globe have equalized a bit . . . well, I don't mind the wait.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by pradocchia on Saturday May 07, 2011 @06:20PM (#2524730)
True, it's probably better to forgo a degree of technological progress in some areas while the rest of the world catches up. And as it does, technological progress will still occur, just in different areas, like energy, transportation and computers. Health too, maybe.

Actually, I have no idea what industries will respond to growing prosperity w/ higher capital investment in technology--at the moment it seems to be computers, but I don't know how far to project that into the future. I know some people project it off to a singularity. Time will tell!

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by JoeAltmaier on Sunday May 08, 2011 @10:06AM (#2525878)
I imagine the responders here are not blue-collar. So its easy to say "I don't mind that guy's job going overseas, it appeals to my liberal philosophy". While they lose their house, we feel warm inside.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by Dove on Sunday May 08, 2011 @12:37PM (#2526194)
Yeah, nobody ever outsources technical work. ;)

I don't think anyone is ever entitled to work, whatever the industry. Especially if someone else wants to do the same work for cheaper -- be it with a machine or in another country.

If you tell me someone lost their job and is having a hard time supporting their family, I do feel compassion. But the tool I reach for is charity, not a free job.

It's not like there's a shortage of opportunity. If your skillset doesn't support your desired income -- especially if you find yourself unemployed -- go get some new skills. Whether it's reading a book about PHP or learning to repair refrigerators at the local community college, someone can pivot in a few months' time. (I wish this were more of an expected fallback; it seems like simple common sense to me.)

In the mean time, the rest of us have cheaper products, and are that much richer.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by JoeAltmaier on Sunday May 08, 2011 @04:47PM (#2526696)
It might be possible to reach that goal without rapid destabilizing change. Some folks don't retrain as easy as us, and have a real hard time when we change society as fast and often as we do.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by Dove on Monday May 09, 2011 @01:29PM (#2529470)
You know, I would normally let this sort of argument go, but you've stepped on a pet peeve of mine and it's been a while since it got some fresh air.

I dislike arguments that focus on a particular consequence producing a particular strain of human misery, and dare the reader to disagree at the risk of being cold-hearted. I find the argument inappropriately personal -- focusing as it does on the virtue and piety of the person. But mainly I find it . . . well, myopic. Near-sighted.

Take the outsourcing we're discussing. The suffering of the fellow who loses his job and maybe his house and has to move back in with his parents is one piece of the equation. The other piece is his counterpart in China who lives in worse conditions, and wants to work hard to improve life for him and his family, but lacks the opportunity.

And then there's the cheaper product itself. There's the company that makes more money, which affects its shareholders and stock prices, which in aggregate affects people's retirement accounts. Perhaps one of them is in danger of losing a house? And then there are the customers, who can now afford the cheaper product, or who can afford more other things because it is cheaper. Perhaps one of them is in a tight situation, too?

And that doesn't even include tertiary effects. Perhaps this cheaper product is used as a component for something else new. Perhaps a whole new technology becomes feasible now. Perhaps it changes the world. Where does that fit in the equation?

That's why the argument strikes me as myopic. Our notional blue collar worker may indeed be miserable, but who is to say his misery outweighs everyone else's? Why is he special? In fact, I find the reasoning to be kind of . . . maybe not exactly racist, but kind of people-ist in some way or another. I'm sorry for the guy, but I don't feel his concerns ought to trump anyone else's.

I'm not saying you shouldn't try to figure out the impact of decisions on people at large. But I am definitely saying to have respect for how incalculable it can be, and to at least think in terms of all the people you can see right off will be affected -- and not just one class of them.

I'm also saying to use the right tool for the job. As a rule of thumb, I like industry to make progress, and charity to relieve suffering. Not that there aren't exceptions -- I myself am advocating the establishment of industry in a region as a way to improve conditions, and I certainly see the value of non-profit research.

But usually I don't want the wires crossed. If you're worried about the suffering of folks who have lost jobs and are having trouble making ends meet, the right approach seems to me to start or assist a foundation that helps those sorts of folks financially and educationally (or whatever). Limiting the help to, say, textile manufacturing workers, and having the help come in the form of keeping their jobs at the expense of jobs for folks in other regions, and ignoring an economic opportunity and possibly retarding progress in general . . .

. . . well, that seems to me really inefficient. And kind of morally dubious, too.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by pradocchia on Sunday May 08, 2011 @11:32AM (#2526062)
The counterpoint to "yeah it would be better for the rest of the world to catch up" would be multiple free-trade zones with a common currency, free trade in goods and free movement of labor within each zone, and then tariffs between them. So the US would be one such zone, the EU another, etc. Lowering tariffs between zones would be conditional on greater freedom of movement and coordination of monetary policy. In theory, this would allow each zone to prosper while preserving some degree of social stability.

China operates this way today, and the US operated this way in the 19th century. Not sure why the US gave it up. One can site economic theories, but economists don't make policy, coalitions do, and I don't know who the members were.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by speleding on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @04:01PM (#2533887)
You seem to imply that a blue collar worker in your country is somehow more important than a blue collar in another country. I'd take a liberal philosophy over scary nationalist tendencies any day.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by gaius on Saturday May 07, 2011 @08:28PM (#2524948)
Sure it has. But that's always been the case. Why didn't the Ancient Greeks have steam engines? Well they did! But since they had slaves, it was never worth developing them further.

http://library.thinkquest.org/C006011/english/sites/heron_bi...

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by jmaygarden on Sunday May 08, 2011 @07:17PM (#2526954)
20 AD isn't exactly ancient Greece, is it? That's Roman Empire territory. Of course, that doesn't really affect the point of your statement.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by mousa on Saturday May 07, 2011 @11:31AM (#2523886)
It's nice that we have freer enterprise and I'm happy to see SpaceX doing well, but China is pivoting hard. It's not a zero-sum game so it doesn't really matter who wins but they're not planning on being just the manufacturers forever. We have freer markets, but they have a big edge too in that they value education a lot more, especially now with the one child policy.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by techiferous on Saturday May 07, 2011 @12:18PM (#2523951)
I see a black cloud looming for China. The "One Child" policy is making their age distribution very top-heavy (much more so that the U.S. "Baby Boomer" phenomenon). Also, two-thirds of men in China smoke (and over half of male doctors). Furthermore, as a populace gets richer, its diet tends toward eating more animal-based products and obesity and cancer rates rise. I see a very large health-care problem in China's future that will certainly slow down their economy.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by stcredzero on Saturday May 07, 2011 @12:31PM (#2523983)
Furthermore, as a populace gets richer, its diet tends toward eating more animal-based products and obesity and cancer rates rise. I see a very large health-care problem in China's future that will certainly slow down their economy.

Is this going to be a competitive advantage for India, with its high population of vegetarians?

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by pdelgallego on Saturday May 07, 2011 @01:20PM (#2524103)
The competitive advantage in India in the long term is that their population will be significantly younger than China.

> India has more than 50% of its population below the age of 25 and more than 65% hovers below the age of 35. It is expected that, in 2020, the average age of an Indian will be 29 years, compared to 37 for China and 48 for Japan; and, by 2030, India's dependency ratio should be just over 0.4. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_India

In the other hand India is confronting other problems.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by mturmon on Saturday May 07, 2011 @09:57PM (#2525055)
Here's a nice, and recent article, by Amartya Sen, comparing development in India and China:

http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2011/may/12/quality...

Sen wrote the book "Development as Freedom" after winning the 1998 Economics Nobel prize. He's known for the general observation that famines occur seldom in democratic societies because politicians are at a gross level accountable for outrageous mismanagement of resource allocation.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by pbreit on Saturday May 07, 2011 @02:02PM (#2524209)
These countries have had centuries to progress. Why now?
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by Sudarshan on Saturday May 07, 2011 @02:59PM (#2524305)
India got independence only in 1947. All growth till then made the British richer. Till the 1990s india had a strange cross breed b/w socialism and capitalism where large govt factories and govt organization employed most people and had low productivity.

One major gain was a strong focus on education many of them learning English. However most of it is rote learning centric. It is only in recent years that India has been able to make a place for itself in the BRIC economies.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by jerf on Saturday May 07, 2011 @03:59PM (#2524444)
Everywhere in the world has had millenia to progress. Progress appears to be the exception, not the rule, and to be somewhat splotchy in general.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by acgourley on Saturday May 07, 2011 @01:10PM (#2524079)
At least in the obesity case, the larger problem is sugar not animal fat.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by stcredzero on Saturday May 07, 2011 @01:26PM (#2524126)
An American-style diet will bring that as well. However, China's system is well positioned to avoid the subsidies which caused the American obesity disaster.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by nostromo on Saturday May 07, 2011 @02:57PM (#2524299)
China also has farm subsidies -- and like the US not always for the most healthy of foods. (http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870371690457613...) However, your point still stands because I'm not sure (and doubt) they subsidize corn to the extent the US does.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by pradocchia on Saturday May 07, 2011 @03:25PM (#2524368)
He may be referring to the claim that greater consumption of animal proteins, not fat, leads to higher incidence of cancer, heart disease, etc. It's a controversial claim, of course.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by mousa on Saturday May 07, 2011 @01:29PM (#2524136)
The Chinese government is banking on having a smarter working population being more valuable than a larger working population. With more and more blue-collar work being automated it will get harder to find jobs for everyone.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by ajkessler on Saturday May 07, 2011 @04:58PM (#2524538)
A link on the front page aptly illustrates China's coming population problem: http://www.economist.com/node/18651512
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by protomyth on Saturday May 07, 2011 @11:59AM (#2523920)
I'm not sure valuing education is enough. Japan didn't pass the US and it surely valued education more than the US. It is the combination of virtues and the chaos of individuals that allows the US to work. If the US gets its debt under control, I don't really see the "win" being China's. China is chaos adverse.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by Retric on Saturday May 07, 2011 @12:19PM (#2523954)
China has a significant population advantage and the US has a huge physical and social infrastructure advantage, but who is on top nominally is far less important than avoiding a Russia or Japan style collapse. The US and China are both having issues with letting their well connected elites fail. Taking risks is good for society but trying to get state support for risk taking causes huge market inefficiency and eventual failure.

PS: The specific US issues like healthcare, ridiculous military spending, and debt are still easily fixable as are China's corruption and Pollution issues the problem is forcing people who benefit and influence the current system to suffer. EX: Removing the mortgage interest subsidy would be a huge long term boon to the US but good luck getting that passed.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by pradocchia on Saturday May 07, 2011 @03:37PM (#2524397)
The difference I see here is that the governing coalition in America seems to be shrinking, while in China it seems to be growing. In a broad coalition, there are too many people to just buy off, so you have to invest in public goods that benefit the people generally. In a narrow coalition, supporters can be bought off directly, through government-enabled rent seeking and the like.

You might see evidence of a broadening coalition in China, with high investments in public infrastructure. You might see evidence of a shrinking coalition in America, with the failure to pass effective health care, patent and telecommunications reform, in favor of greater rent-seeking.

Not to say China doesn't have rent-seeking, not at all. It's arguably worse than the States, I'm sure. But the trajectories appear to be different.

Side note: in the Chinese village my wife is from, the central government is now paying for the construction of new land fill. Currently all trash gets thrown in the river, and it creates an awful mess. The local government would never come together to provide trash remove services, so the central government has stepped in. They recognize the intractability of the issue locally, and the strategic importance to do something about it nationally. It's encouraging to watch.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by olifante on Saturday May 07, 2011 @04:10PM (#2524458)
so broad coalitions are forced to favor the public interest, while narrow coalitions can afford to serve only their sponsors and ignore the public interest -- very interesting thesis.

Do you have any links to more detailed discussions of this theory?

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by pradocchia on Saturday May 07, 2011 @04:26PM (#2524480)
I got the kernel of the idea from Bruce Bueno de Mesquita, in this podcast:

http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2007/02/bruce_bueno_de.html

I'm sure you can find more material on the subject from there.

Since I heard this, I have found it very profitable to think of public policy in terms of coalitions.

Interestingly, one of Madison's arguments in favor of union at the Constitutional Convention was what that a United States would create broader coalitions, and thus a more stable government. This was to head off arguments at the time that republics had always been geographically limited, and any large state necessarily tended towards empire. (My source for that is Joseph Ellis, btw.)

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by karamazov on Saturday May 07, 2011 @02:24PM (#2524242)
Physical infrastructure in the US has not been heavily invested in for decades. China, on the other hand, is aggressively building up its infrastructure.

If the US waits until China's advantage from this becomes apparent, it'll probably be too late to catch up.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by nostromo on Saturday May 07, 2011 @03:05PM (#2524314)
Yes, but the US infrastructure is largely intact and well maintained. We can keep building roads and bridges, but we don't need any more. We could rebuild our airports/seaports, but the impact there would be more efficient air travel, not the economic boom you get from the original port. Commuter rail is a pretty good option, but only in certain regional areas and perhaps some municipal areas. Libraries, jails, courthouses, schools -- maybe there are some projects there, but again I don't see those as leading to an economic boom.

I really don't see as many good options for infrastructure spending as a country like China has (who, let's be honest, is playing catch-up). Perhaps we could do something real crazy, like build a space elevator, to create new markets rather than trying to build stuff for the sake of building stuff.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by coenhyde on Saturday May 07, 2011 @10:39PM (#2525102)
First a little bit of anecdotal evidence:

I'm from Australia and I just finished a 10,000 mile road trip around your nation with some mates. I can assure you your road network is falling apart. A lot of the time I felt like I was driving in a 3rd world country. While it is evident that the US has invested a lot in infrastructure in the past they are certainly not well maintained. From my limited experience Illinois had the worse road conditions and New Mexico and Texas has the best.

Here's what the economist has to say:

"Total public spending on transport and water infrastructure has fallen steadily since the 1960s and now stands at 2.4% of GDP. Europe, by contrast, invests 5% of GDP in its infrastructure, while China is racing into the future at 9%."

and

"In 2008 the commission (National Surface Transportation Policy and Revenue Study Commission) reckoned that America needed at least $255 billion per year in transport spending over the next half-century to keep the system in good repair and make the needed upgrades. Current spending falls 60% short of that amount."

You can read more here: http://www.economist.com/node/18620944?story_id=18620944

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by SamReidHughes on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:08AM (#2528013)
Maybe you overvalue good road conditions because you've been driving so much.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by nazgulnarsil on Sunday May 08, 2011 @07:04AM (#2525694)
china and india are investing in LFTR reactors. The US is going to look rather silly when the rest of the world starts producing massive amounts of cheap energy.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by Retric on Saturday May 07, 2011 @11:33PM (#2525183)
Physical infrastructure is more than just roads, and bridges. Fiber optics, and safe homes that people want to live in are both huge economic gains. The real secret to infrastructure is balancing utility with the cost to maintain vs simply building them. Unfortunately for China their demographics are in a rapid transition so they are going to be force to invest huge amounts of capital in new homes simply to keep up with changing customer demands. The US is facing similar issues based on long term energy trends, however that's a much more hypothetical issues so it's hard to predict what needs to be done.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by jbjohns on Sunday May 08, 2011 @03:04PM (#2526493)
Homes isn't really a strong point of the US. They are extremely cheaply built and leak temperature like a sieve.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by forgottenpaswrd on Saturday May 07, 2011 @06:56PM (#2524803)
What makes the US to work is too:

1)That USA is enormously resource rich, like natural gas,helium, oil, coal, enormous extensions with wood,cotton, cattle... while Japan has no resources at all.

2)That USA has an enormous population that is mobile(could move from west coast to east coast) speaking only one language while places like Europe or India has every country(or subcountry state) speaking its language and making not so easy the people to move(protectionism).

3) That USA got the world hegemony since WWII and everybody in the world needs dollars to buy oil, so USA can live from other countries work, just printing dollars.

While 1,and 2 will continue, 3 could end soon, because USA had abused so much it and is abusing it that things could change.

Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by bzbarsky on Saturday May 07, 2011 @10:00PM (#2525058)
You may have #3 backwards (and also have the reason people want dollars backwards; it has very little to do with nominal oil pricing). I suggest reading http://mpettis.com/2011/05/is-it-time-for-the-us-to-disengag... for the former and any competent explanation of international trade mechanisms for the latter.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by tel on Saturday May 07, 2011 @11:52AM (#2523907)
I'm going to keep that line in hand for the next 20 years: "China is pivoting hard". Anyone who's thinking of them as merely cheap labor for much longer is going to be very surprised.
Re:Why the US can beat China: The Facts about SpaceX Costs by nl on Sunday May 08, 2011 @08:54AM (#2525796)
It's not just that the robots need to be good enough - in fact they are already for most areas.

The problem is that using robots in manufacture involves large upfront capital costs, and that can be avoided using human labor.