News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by Traster on Friday November 27, 2020 @06:10PM (#25233403)
This is really stupid. They've managed to take stuff that's so difficult to find that you literally have to go to the freaking moon to get it, and turn it into something that is literally everywhere all over earth. What a bunch of idiots.

On a more serious note, is the high energy demands of this process a blocker at all? Or can we just assume that energy (solar) is abundant on the moon?

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by Zenst on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:16PM (#25234231)
Oh this is probably going to be more practical than another British invention https://worldwide.espacenet.com/publicationDetails/biblio?CC...

I'd say solar panel output would be way more predictable than upon Earth as no chaotic weather systems at play, also larger unfiltered spectrum would mean panels could be tailor made to get higher efficiency than you get per m2 anywhere upon Earth with its atmosphere.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by dmurray on Friday November 27, 2020 @09:44PM (#25234757)
Wouldn't an unfiltered spectrum mean you'd need to tailor your solar panels less, and likely get lower efficiency (fewer watts of electricity per watt of sunlight) than on Earth? You'd still get more watts per square metre, because the atmosphere wouldn't be in the way.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by Zenst on Friday November 27, 2020 @10:28PM (#25235003)
I'm sure the moon has it's own environmental factors that would impact materiel choices and make some more suitable than others. So having a wider spectrum of light at suitable levels to tap into, whilst that opens up the possibility to tap into a larger spectrum at the required power levels to generate electricity. It maybe that being able to use some materials have advantages and tap a part of the spectrum that would not be viable upon earth proves more suitable.

you can visualise it better here and whilst this is measuring upper atmosphere levels and not space - you get an idea: http://butane.chem.uiuc.edu/pshapley/GenChem2/A2/1.html

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by NullPrefix on Friday November 27, 2020 @07:12PM (#25233821)
What if, just hear me out, what if the end goal is to use this process one the moon where the input stuff is abundant and the output is going at premium rate?
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by Invictus0 on Friday November 27, 2020 @07:37PM (#25233976)
The parent is obviously being sarcastic.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by satvikpendem on Friday November 27, 2020 @07:40PM (#25233994)
That is not obvious from the parent comment at all.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by Traster on Friday November 27, 2020 @07:43PM (#25234015)
I hereby confirm I was being sarcastic, I really would like an answer to the second part though.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by freen on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:59PM (#25234477)
The failure mode of sarcasm is either asshole or idiot.

Generally speaking, it’s a high risk, low reward mode.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by hinkley on Friday November 27, 2020 @09:45PM (#25234765)
What stops solar collectors on earth from working consistently is atmospheric interference diffusing the light.

If you can figure out how to avoid creating dust clouds on the moon, which is not a small if, solar concentrators could provide a lot of the heat for the process, reducing the power needs to the electrochemical part.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by abnry on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:32PM (#25234318)
Confirmation not accepted unless notarized.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by ct520 on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:10PM (#25234204)
Not sure why this makes me laugh, maybe because I know all to well how you got to be explicit with development teams.

On serious note isn’t there some type of future plan to put nuclear reactors on the moon in this decade?

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by garmaine on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:45PM (#25234384)
I haven’t read the original article, but there have been processes for extracting oxygen from lunar regolith for a half century now. I’m not sure what’s new about this one.

In general these processes are energy intensive because they involve temperatures high enough to melt rock. On the Earth that is difficult to achieve because you need to keep the furnace hot. On the Moon with its hard vacuum, a large chunk of rock moved onto insulating material doesn’t radiate much heat. So all you’d need, really, is a large parabolic mirror. The Sun is your power source.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by anoncake on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:38PM (#25234345)
I think "on a more serious note" implies that what precedes it isn't serious.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by nojokes on Friday November 27, 2020 @11:29PM (#25235277)
He was obviously sarcastic.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by rtkwe on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:13PM (#25234217)
There's a lot of options for getting that energy on the moon mostly various versions of solar either by traditional solar panels or you could use mirrors to concentrate sunlight to provide heat directly.

The latter works pretty well on the moon because the day is pretty long at almost a month. If you get really creative the slow speed means it might be possible to build a giant tracked refinery that slowly circles the moon so it has continuous daylight.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by whoisthemachine on Friday November 27, 2020 @07:58PM (#25234117)
While I appreciate the humor, the crowd here doesn't typically take to it. To answer your question - I do not have much knowledge of available solar energy on the moon versus the Earth, but I think it's safe to assume it would be much less impeded on the moon than on Earth, which has an atmosphere, magnetosphere, and ozone layer at the very least getting in the way of solar rays.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by jws on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:04PM (#25234168)
It looks like about 1/3 more energy per area than the surface of Earth at noon. On the moon you should get about a 50% duty cycle of that as opposed to about 20% on Earth (the edges of the day and weather eat a lot of power), so it's safe to say "about three times as much" energy per year.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by andai on Friday November 27, 2020 @07:16PM (#25233849)
Solar is abundant, the panels are not... yet!

I wonder if arrays of mirrors (aimed at a heat engine or whatever they use to generate electricity from molten salt) would be cheaper to scale up there.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by rtkwe on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:20PM (#25234256)
This process just needs heat so why not skip the electricity step entirely and just have a big refinery follow the sun around the moon. With a 29.5 day... day and a small circumference the you only need to move ~9.5 mph to stay in constant sunlight on the moon.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by chongli on Friday November 27, 2020 @09:14PM (#25234561)
I wonder if arrays of mirrors (aimed at a heat engine or whatever they use to generate electricity from molten salt)

That seems like a great idea. Find a nice big crater in an area that gets a lot of sunlight and polish the walls of the crater into a parabolic mirror. Put your heat engine at the focus and collect tons of energy. The one drawback: how do you provide cooling? Heat engines are only efficient with a large temperature gradient (Carnot's theorem).

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by thereisnospork on Friday November 27, 2020 @09:42PM (#25234745)
You misspelled nuclaer.

First step to an exo-earth settlement is going to be sending the biggest reactor that will fit on a rocket. Two of them, actually.[1]

Whether its digging, breathing, or making rocket-fuel pretty much everything is going to require, by earth standards, gobs of power. Last thing you'd want to do is operate in a power-starved or even power-adequate environment.

[1]Plus, to be fair, enough backup solar or RTG to keep people alive in case of reactor failure.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by anoncake on Saturday November 28, 2020 @10:41AM (#25238181)
Is that feasible? The container for the radioactive fuel must be robust enough to survive a catastrophic failure during launch followed by an an impact on Earth without releasing its contents. Which is possible (RTGs are built that way), but adds a lot of weight.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by rkagerer on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:24PM (#25234277)
Not sure, but the article does indicate they're working on reducing energy requirements with a view to making it lunar-feasible.

Engineers will tinker with the process by adjusting the electrical current and reagents to boost the amount of oxygen while trying to reduce the temperature needed to produce it. This will help bring down the energy required, which is already at a premium on the Moon.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by ne9xt on Friday November 27, 2020 @07:42PM (#25234013)
I can’t believe so many people are not picking up your humor! XD
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by Traster on Friday November 27, 2020 @07:45PM (#25234031)
Either people didn't read the article, or assumed I hadn't read the article.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by seneca on Friday November 27, 2020 @07:47PM (#25234046)
"Cute" reddit-style posts are generally not well received here.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by FaultsOfDang on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:18PM (#25234243)
Who's fault could this be?
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by edgyquant on Friday November 27, 2020 @10:22PM (#25234967)
It’s the fault of the creator and the community and is on purpose. This site is meant to be for more intellectual discussion and not cheap quips. If you want threads full of one sentence and derailing comments you can visit Reddit: this site is engineered to /not/ become like Reddit.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by delecti on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:23PM (#25234271)
It's not really fair to pin "fault" on anyone in particular for the culture that develops on any given social media site. These things just kinda emerge.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by artifact_44 on Friday November 27, 2020 @09:35PM (#25234689)
I think hn itself is a counterpoint to your assertion. The toxic culture hasn't really "emerged" here as it has on countless other platforms, due primarily to ruthless call-out/moderation/shadow banning etc.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by krapp on Friday November 27, 2020 @09:53PM (#25234810)
Humor isn't toxic. What's toxic is the vituperative snark, contemptuous elitism, low-effort cynicism and outright hatred this community breeds and that dang constantly has to put down because (among other reasons) we have to be pedantic humorless prigs about everything.

I'll take more dumb jokes over yet another diatribe on how Twitter's latest moderation policy changes will lead to mass graves and white genocide any day.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by delecti on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:42AM (#25237795)
I didn't mean to imply that the particular cultures of the various social media websites are "toxic", they're just all different. Each site has their own style of talking, peculiar grammar rules, appropriate topics, and memes, and all of those things exist on HN too, at least to some extent.

HN post topics are restricted, usually to technical stories or less controversial political topics. Comments tend to be precisely worded, and are often more pedantic. Because of how linking works (or rather doesn't), citations often use a particular format. Comedy is generally discouraged, though is accepted more if (like in Traster's top-level comment in this thread) there's also "legitimate" point attached. If that comment hadn't included the second paragraph, it would probably have been downvoted. All of that is part of the culture of HN, and I wouldn't necessarily call any of it toxic. Some of it follows directly from the site rules and moderation, some follows from the technical limitations of the site, and some just emerges from the sorts of people who happen to use the site.

Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by sksnskkcahan on Friday November 27, 2020 @09:28PM (#25234644)
While occasional humor is welcome, if we reward it too much, then the comments will be full of low-quality jokes. I think most readers here aren’t looking for that.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by anoncake on Friday November 27, 2020 @08:56PM (#25234452)
The point is, obviously, to fight global warming. By importing additional oxygen from the moon, we dilute our CO2.
Re:British engineers develop process to turn moon dust into ... by geuis on Friday November 27, 2020 @09:23PM (#25234614)
How this extremely biased and negative comment hasn’t been downvoted, I have no idea. Or perhaps there’s some kind of double sided irony here I’m missing.

Either way, what’s being described is a process to refine materials to be used in space, where currently sending similar materials from the is prohibitively expensive.