We should all rise up as one and really ask, if we are now paying $X for $Y GB of data, why doesn't it roll over like Minutes or a persistent commodity.
I'd also like to point out Charter Communications doesn't throttle nor cap their bandwidth and yet the service is great!
Because user bandwidth is not, by definition, a persistent commodity. ISPs do not accrue bandwidth every month they are under capacity, so why should users?
http://acompa.net/blog/2011/05/why-isps-will-not-offer-rollo...
How do you know Charter doesn't throttle bandwidth at peak times? Do you track packet loss, and would you notice if it went up by a percent or two?
Even if an ISP doesn't voluntarily throttle traffic, border routers automatically will with WRED or some other more modern queue management strategy if there's too much traffic buffered for the link it's trying to send on. It's more a question of whether packet loss is managed on a per-flow or per-ip basis, on egress, or whether it's managed on a per-port basis on ingress from the customers to their ISP.
Since they've finished the DOCSIS 3 rollout here last week I've considered upgrading to 60/5 from my 25/3 plan but it's pretty over priced and would be much more worth it at 60/10 or 60/15. During the period of trouble (not enough bandwidth for their inter city link where they actually do their peering) I was down as low as 1Mbit/s during peak hours on a 25Mbit plan.
This will usher in a 'pay what you use' scheme, not unlike long-distance phone bills back in the days of yore. (you transferred $Y GB this month, so you owe us $X dollars.)
You're paying for a service and if the company you're paying considers your use in violation of the terms agreed to they should indicate to you that you are in violation not some sneaky restriction you never know about. In fact I bet people have called their ISP and played the "it's not me it's you" game when it's actually the ISP throttling their customers.
http://www.myaccount.charter.com/CUSTOMERS/SUPPORT.ASPX?SUPP...
Be careful what you wish for. Once they start, they will not stop.
Rate limiting heavy users at peak times has exactly the effect on the customer base that an ISP should want. Exactly the subpopulation of users they don't want gets an incentive to leave, and everyone else stays and talks about the smooth, uninterrupted service and "unlimited" bandwidth.
That seems like a more reasonable option than hard traffic caps. It's no surprise more wired ISPs aren't using that strategy, though... hard caps generate revenue, while rate limiting heavy users doesn't. That wouldn't be such a problem if there were healthy competition in most metro markets, but there isn't.
Verizon FIOS is one of the few good [fast] U.S. wireline ISP options left that doesn't cap traffic. It's too bad many markets are still de-facto duopolies (from the days when there was a meaningful distinction between "telephone" and "cable" companies aside from layers 1-2). FIOS isn't available here, and if it were I'd switch in a heartbeat because of AT&T's incompetence [2].
[1] http://www.tekgoblin.com/2011/02/03/verizon-to-throttle-high...
[2] http://leaf.dragonflybsd.org/mailarchive/users/2011-02/msg00...