Three of the above are notoriously difficult to scale individually. For spatial computing we need to scale all three simultaneously in a single computational construct. And if that wasn't enough, these are real-time systems that need to support extremely high write throughput while all of those operations are happening -- offline batch reorganization isn't an option. These are petabyte scale systems in the trivial case (tens of TB in the most minimalist data models), so you aren't going to be building a bunch of indexes or similar.
It is a vexing computer science and architecture problem. And even if you solved that elementary computing infrastructure problem, there are several more hard/interesting computer science problems related to topological types and conflict resolution that you'll likely need to solve before you have a useful system. It is headaches all the way down.
Personally I don’t see a need to this “maximizing efficiency” paradigm for spatial computing, which seems to be mostly driven by industry (the potential for making billions of dollars) not as an inborn desire to better this world. It’s not that I decline it, but the need seems somewhat artificial in a way.
The problem already exists at scale today in many, many companies that everyone has heard of. Mitigating and working around this has been a large part of what I do for many years. If such a platform came into existence today, dozens of companies would each happily spend tens of millions per year to use it tomorrow; they are all ready lighting similar amounts of money on fire in this area on infrastructure that doesn't work.
The business challenge is that the engineering effort required to build such a platform is simply too large to easily fund, even inside large tech companies. There is no appetite for that scale of investment in infrastructure software anymore, everyone kind of waits around for something to show up in open source that they can re-purpose. Less risk and less cost. In this particular case, that is unlikely to happen for the foreseeable future, someone will need to make a real investment.
Adoption of spatial computing will not be binary "once someone pulls it off". It's going to be gradually, step after step.
You might be considering a lot broader things to be spatial computing that are short of the sense being considered here.
Yes, representing objects and annotating trivial scenes is interesting and is starting to happen today.
But free-form automated representation of the environment in ways that the spatial shortcuts we rely upon ("inside", "on top of", etc) can be used, (non-graph) paths of different types can be solved, and actuator kinematics can find and interact with things, etc: it's really hard.
AR and VR and being able to interact with object meshes and geometry is a start. But computational geometry and encoding world constraints in a useful way is really hard. We'll snatch some incremental parts from AR and vision research, but we'll need some breakthroughs in the space, too, to do the really cool stuff.
At its core, spatial computing is about queryable reality. 3D scanning of objects, AR/VR, etc are all adjuncts to this. They are ways of consuming the data model or synthesizing non-real parts, not creating the base model of reality. The latter is the hard part, the rest doesn’t matter in the big picture.
What you describe is a broad vision that may or may not happen at some point in the future. I agree about the queryable reality part but disagree that AR/VR, 3D scanning etc. "don't matter". Because in a lot of real-life use-cases you don't need the "real-time 3D mirror" but instead can get 80% of the value with something 10% as complex.
Spatial Sieve Tree (Inventor J. Andrew Rogers) https://patents.google.com/patent/US7734714B2/en
https://www.jandrewrogers.com/2015/03/02/geospatial-database...
https://www.jandrewrogers.com/2015/10/08/spacecurve/
These might give a hint at why cs101 might not be enough for the scale and kind of systems he is talking about.
Back then, it was a bit of a “blind men and the elephant” case with some really interesting computer science constructs. Now we have a pretty pure theoretical model of the elephant, and so an elegant implementation is not the sum of what the blind men would have described. Much more capability, far fewer lines of code, albeit completely opaque to someone that doesn’t understand what they are looking at.
(space (longitude, latitude), time, DATA)
is readily addressed by the ideas in that patent:
- hierarchical partitioning of space, each node storing the data for the regions represented by a number of leaves. shard per leaf and adaptive rebalancing (merge,split, move shard) as necessary.
- within each shard, partition by time
With this you can gang together any number of nodes that you need to hit the aggregate ingestion rate requirement.
The query
"give me all the data that occurred in this region of space in this time period"
is readily supported as well. Applications (shard aware or hitting some stub proxy aware of the sharding) sitting on top of this datastore can use this repeatedly to build arbitrary logic (though you would have to query all the nodes if you don't have a space region, which is fine if your query rate is low).
Likely my mental model of applications consuming spatial data is too simple, but what other innovation would be required beyond this for ingestion and querying? What kind of interface does the datastore provide to the application?
Would also love to hear more about the comment you made above
"there are several more hard/interesting computer science problems related to topological types and conflict resolution that you'll likely need to solve before you have a useful system"
Eventually, things you ordinarily assume you can cache in memory don’t actually fit in memory. It forces changes in the computer science strategy.
It happens to be called something a bit different: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geographic_information_scien...
I'm skeptical. Seems like a solution in search of a problem. Who is willing to pay money for this?
A question I ask when doing due diligence on "spatial computing" technology is what computer science problems did you solve to create the technology? The common answer is "none" and most people dabbling in the space aren't even aware hard computer science problems exist as prerequisites to building such technology unless they've been banging their head against it for a while. That's the state of the spatial computing market today. We also know that it is (currently) impossible to build such a thing by sprinkling some magic spatial computing dust on open source technology stacks -- they can't express the necessary mechanics. You'll be writing a lot of code from first principles, it isn't a business execution problem.
We've had petabytes of this type of sensor data for decades, and the vision and desire to build digital twins with that data, that part isn't new. There are hardcore technical reasons this doesn't exist as a real thing, it isn't that no one has ever thought of spatial computing before. To make matters worse, most of the companies with the expertise and desire to use such a platform lack the expertise and execution to create it. Creating such a platform has to come from somewhere else.
It is possible to build a spatial computing platform today that actually works, the computer science challenges have solutions, but the combination of domain expertise and computer science skillset to execute it is extremely rare at the moment. That said, spatial computing will be a trillion dollar platform business once someone pulls it off.