News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @09:35AM (#25209608)
Lying to the customer about what your product does, or having secret functionality, should be a criminal offence in the same way as breaking and entering or stalking are.

Then, we would find out very quickly what people value.

I firmly believe this ecosystem (as in privacy violating ad and data selling business model) is only dominant because companies are able to mislead with impunity, so it's basically a form of fraud

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by samatman on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:41PM (#25212642)
I agree with this, to some degree.

But I've also known that macOS verifies signatures for as long as it's been doing it. This was no secret, it was advertised as a feature.

I assumed it wasn't being done in plaintext, because who would be so foolish as to code it that way? and I'm still plenty mad about that. Anyone could have checked this at any time, presumably people did, and the only reason it became a story is because the server got really slow and we noticed.

Apple says there will be a fix next year, which... eh better than nothing, not even 10% as good as shipping the feature correctly to begin with.

But of the many things about this episode which are worthy of criticism, Apple being deceitful is nowhere among them. Never happened.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by saagarjha on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @05:31PM (#25215012)
It was mentioned in a developer presentation with very few details as to how it worked. Apple did not go into details; the information presented here was mostly reversed by app developers and security engineers.
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by egsmi on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @06:02PM (#25215261)
What details were missing from the WWDC talk that you would've liked to have seen?
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by kelnos on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @08:12PM (#25216010)
Was it widely known that this feature was implemented as a privacy-leaking phone-home feature? Simply saying "macOS verifies application signatures before running them" doesn't necessarily imply that it's shipping execution data to Apple. All of that can happen offline, if Apple had chosen to implement it that way.
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by loa_in_ on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @05:18PM (#25214906)
> This was no secret, it was advertised as a feature.

I wish you could prove this.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by egsmi on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @05:57PM (#25215220)
https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2019/703/ The second half of the talk is about the "hardened runtime"

And in the wider tech press

https://appleinsider.com/articles/19/06/03/apples-macos-cata...

"Mac apps, installer packages, and kernel extensions that are signed with Developer ID must also be notarized by Apple in order to run on macOS Catalina"

Even on hacker news https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21179970

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by ClumsyPilot on Thursday November 26, 2020 @07:59AM (#25219633)
Firstly, this is not 'advertised' - this is not a material average apple consumer reads.

Secondly, it does not actually say anything about the OS phoning home and preventing the user from launching an app. The appleinside talks vaguelt of 'Notarisation', something thay can be inplemented in a variety of ways, like signing application with a certificate

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by egsmi on Thursday November 26, 2020 @12:35PM (#25221989)
Here is a Forbes article (do “normal” people read Forbes?) that says to run apps in Catalina one will need permission from Apple. It even anticipated this problem with the server. Sure, it doesn’t mention sockets but remember this is for normal people and I think people are smart enough to assume that Apple is probably not giving permission to launch an App by carrier pigeon.

There are 100s of articles like this. Gatekeeper was a keynote feature.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2019/12/28/apple-mac...

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by ethbr0 on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @09:49AM (#25209779)
The act of breaching privacy is technically difficult to prohibit in a way many of us would find palatable.

What should be targeted is the product of said breaches. Something like the blood diamond approach.

If your company has PII, then you by law must be able to produce a consented attestation chain all the way back to the source.

If you do not, then you're charged a fine for every piece of unattested PII on every individual.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by _jal on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @12:05PM (#25211422)
- Can you demonstrate the provenance of every phone number, email address and other contact mode on your phone? Note people's birthdays? Sure, you only want to target companies. Make sure you choose your acquaintances wisely, I guess, or make sure you record their grant of permission to email them, because people abuse laws like this to harass each other every single day.

- This also punishes possession, not use. If you think about that for a minute, it should become clear both how this doesn't attack the right problem, and how companies would evade it.

- Finally... how are you going to audit Ford or Geico? Honest question. Who pays for the audit of "every piece of unattested PII on every individual"? How often, what is the dispute mechanism, and who administers that? Seriously - this sounds like a job for a new agency combining significant portions of the IRS, the FBI and PwC.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by kelnos on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @08:15PM (#25216027)
> This also punishes possession, not use.

If companies were immune to data breaches or leaks, then maybe this wouldn't be such a big deal. But I don't trust most companies to securely hold my data, even if they don't use it at all.

And besides, by the time a company uses the data in a privacy-destroying way, it's too late. The cat is out of the bag. Sure, the law against use could serve as a deterrent, but companies will push the law past the breaking point all the time. If you make possession trigger legal action, you can mop these things up before they get to use your data. Sure, you still have the problem of finding out about that possession. But also consider that if you have laws against possession and "bad" use, and a company does something, you can charge them for both things and hurt them more. That's a larger deterrent.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by ethbr0 on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @12:26PM (#25211691)
> Sure, you only want to target companies

Yes. There are many laws (e.g. accounting) that only apply to companies, when it's scale that amplifies harm.

> possession, not use

How are they different, in this context? The latter requires the former, and the former is unprofitable without the latter.

> how are you going to audit Ford or Geico?

As you note, similarly to how we audit now, albeit hopefully more proactively. If the law requires a signed off third-party PII audit, and holds an auditor legally liable for signing off on one... I expect the problem would (mostly) take care of itself.

PII is always going to be a game of edge cases, but we've managed to make it work with PCI and PHI in similarly messy domains.

Right now, companies have GDPR & CCPA to nudge them in data architecture. National laws would just further that. I can attest to major companies retooling how they handle and track consumer data just due to the CCPA.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by zepto on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @10:11AM (#25210012)
By the time someone is charged with a crime, the damage is already done.

And, there will be many scammers who are simply out of reach of meaningful legal remedies.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by ben509 on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @10:28AM (#25210193)
That's true of virtually all criminal laws, though. If you're beat up and your assailant is charged with assault, you've already been beat up.
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by zepto on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @11:20AM (#25210824)
Yes, which is why you need both laws, and prevention methods.
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @10:47AM (#25210434)
I thonk we are both arguing that clear consent must be present, and the customer must have clearly agreed to whatever you are doing with the data - that appears similar to GDPR.

However, how do you prove John Doe has actually agreed to this? What if John says he did not click accept button? Do we require digital signature with certificates, given that most people don't have them or know how to use them?

I think the problem is more tractable for physical products running firmware - there you have real proof of purchase, and, at present, firmware that does whatever it wants.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by ethbr0 on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @12:17PM (#25211577)
It's analogous to the credit card fraud problem, no? E.g. disputing charges and chargebacks?

I don't work in that space, but my understanding is that the card processors essentially serve as dispute mediators in those instances.

So it would seem unavoidable (although not great) to have some sort of trusted, third-party middle person between collectors and end users, who can handle disputes and vouch for consent.

Blockchain doesn't seem like a solution, given that the problem is precisely in the digital-physical gap. E.g. I have proof of consent (digital) but no way to tie it to a (disputed) act of consent (physical).

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by IfOnlyYouKnew on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @04:43PM (#25214625)
This is civil law. You find out by asking employees in court. They aren’t going to risk perjury, a criminal offense, to spare their employer.
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by AshWolfy on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @09:50PM (#25216418)
Or perhaps change the system that incentivizes companies to violate privacy over and over again
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by merijnv on Thursday November 26, 2020 @04:52AM (#25218480)
> If your company has PII, then you by law must be able to produce a consented attestation chain all the way back to the source.

So...basically the GDPR? Well, not quite, since the GDPR doesn't require consent attestation, "merely" a legal basis. Of which consent is just one (the most useless one to use as a company).

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by valuearb on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @10:35AM (#25210284)
Yes because there are never unwanted side effects from more laws.
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by oblio on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @11:38AM (#25211070)
That's human nature. As soon as something beneficial to few and detrimental to others is banned, those who benefit seek to find other ways to continue benefitting, again to the detriment of others.

This doesn't mean we shouldn't continue trying to stop them.

And we stop them through laws.

Common sense is not that common and human decency doesn't scale.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by valuearb on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:23PM (#25212416)
In the US, the typical citizen commits an average of a felony a day. The legal code and associated regulations are so lengthy no one can read all of them. The tax code alone is 2,600 pages and associated rulings 70,000 pages.

When you have so many laws, they can be applied selectively depending on your political status, or to benefit the regulators or their friends. We just caught the sheriff of Santa Clara extorting citizens for tens of thousands of dollars to get concealed carry permits, which is why many people carry illegally, just like criminals.

Creating a law where non-disclosure of the smallest feature opens you up to government regulators harassment is another avenue for graft and corruption. Like when the EU selectively prosecutes US companies, or US regulators selectively harass companies not in lock step with the current administration.

I think if you really need a nanny state to protect you from your own decisions you should be required to give up all your decisions to the state.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @04:13PM (#25214350)
For your argument to make sence you have to demonstrate that this amounts to nanny state.

I don't think it does, I think is fraud. For it to be consequences of of my choices, what choice do I make to select a mobile phone carrier that does not sell data of my location? Such choice does not exist.

You can't 'non-disclose' some 'small feature' of a mortgage contract, of a loan, etc. Personal data deserves similar respect.

Lastly, we can and do have different laws for individuals and multi-billion dollar corporations - you cant use this as an argument when we are discussing securities fraud and banking regulations.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by oblio on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @03:37PM (#25214020)
Laws can always be applied selectively. They have always been applied selectively.

The point of laws is statistics: you can't discourage everything, you need to discourage enough to have order.

And there is a middle ground between no laws and giving everything up.

Also, I give up my liberties and obey laws in exchange for protection from many nasty things people do when there are no laws.

Based on your examples and vocabulary ("nanny state" is a clear giveaway), you're American. Go live for 5-10 years in a country with lax or non-existent laws and law enforcement. We call those countries bad names for a solid reason.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by IfOnlyYouKnew on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @04:49PM (#25214673)
> In the US, the typical citizen commits an average of a felony

Sorry but that’s just obvious BS. If it were true, you’d include examples and far more people a certain world leader doesn’t like would be “locked up”.

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by jamesgeck0 on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @03:31PM (#25213960)
> In the US, the typical citizen commits an average of a felony a day

This is surprising to me. Could you provide examples of such common felonies US citizens commit in ignorance?

Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by oblio on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @03:40PM (#25214052)
I think felony is the more serious one? Misdemeanor being stuff like parking violation? I'd definitely want to see some examples for felonies, too :-)
Re:macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years by kelnos on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @08:16PM (#25216031)
Sure, but that's not an argument to give up.