News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by motohagiography on Monday November 23, 2020 @09:32AM (#25187092)
For island nations, it's not as bad an idea as it might sound. For all the bullshit about connectedness, the basic physical human urge social media stimulates is for conflict. All the other things like sentimentality, status signalling, attention seeking, are parts of the underlying addiction to conflict because in a lot of hind-brains, that sensation represents opportunity. It's a vice.

Outright bans are clumsy, but imposing a cost or bar to entry, like most societies do with alcohol and drugs, might be constructive.

I'm tired of meeting friends and family in person and listening to them spend 20mins one-way unloading all the shit they read on the internet. They're so indexed on things that aren't physically present in the moment it's like talking someone through a psychosis or reasoning with someone with schizophrenia. It's a mass hysteria machine. When I talk to some people, it's like I'm not even talking to people anymore, I'm talking to some node of the internet. We've basically invented language cancer, nice one guys.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by solarkraft on Monday November 23, 2020 @10:07AM (#25187451)
> I'm tired of meeting friends and family in person and listening to them spend 20mins one-way unloading all the shit they read on the internet. They're so indexed on things that aren't physically present in the moment it's like talking someone through a psychosis or reasoning with someone with schizophrenia. It's a mass hysteria machine. When I talk to some people, it's like I'm not even talking to people anymore, I'm talking to some node of the internet. We've basically invented language cancer, nice one guys.

It's easy to imagine this being about the news (in whatever format: TV, radio, newspaper) or even ideas in general. This very forum is dedicated to talking about things that aren't physically present.

Maybe I didn't understand your argument, but to me it sounds a lot like you're complaining about human nature.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by lainga on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:50AM (#25188684)
Do you spend 20 minutes expounding on HN articles to your friends and family without waiting for a response?
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by sixstringtheory on Monday November 23, 2020 @04:21PM (#25192062)
Anyone doing that is just a bad conversationalist. I bring up stuff all the time that I read about on HN/Internet, but I do it to foster discussion and keep things interesting, not to lecture people. Conversely, I know people who will talk for 20 minutes or longer on end, despite clear signals that I'm no longer interested, to the point where they have to be firmly interrupted.
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by TeMPOraL on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:51AM (#25188701)
There's a difference that's tricky to define. But when we talk about things "that aren't physically present", a good percentage of that talk can be useful to one or more of the participants; though we also do a lot of what the parent is complaining about.

That said, I do know what they mean. I also hate to see people getting almost traumatized by the random crap they find on social media. Especially if it's bullshit - and it's obvious that it's bullshit, but you can't say it, because that would invalidate the other person's feelings. So yesterday, it was "did you know our government wants to XYZ?!?!!" (no, they don't, the news article was lying, as usual). Today it's maltreated pets (could you please unsubscribe from the feeds that trigger you every couple weeks like clockwork?). Tomorrow it'll be a YouTube drama (between a very niche vloggers).

Perhaps it is human nature, perhaps it was also present with the old media. But what seems different is isolation. I remember that before the web became truly mainstream, people would talk a lot about bullshit they've heard on the news. But they would all talk about the same bullshit. People would ultimately take comfort in an understanding that they share the knowledge about the story. Today? Everyone has their own isolated social media feed. So you end up having people unload completely random and unexpected stuff at whoever is willing to listen to them.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by pembrook on Monday November 23, 2020 @07:01PM (#25193514)
...And ironically, OP was falling into the exact same hysteria machine that his/her friends have fallen into.

OP was so eager to regurgitate the popular news narrative that Facebook is ruining the world, he failed to see that in this particular case, Facebook is being banned over online leaks of documents proving government corruption with Covid-19 funds.

The government in this case isn't doing this because they want to protect people. They're doing this because they want to freely steal money without public scrutiny on social media.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by dsign on Monday November 23, 2020 @03:39PM (#25191514)
> I'm tired of meeting friends and family in person and listening to them spend 20mins one-way unloading all the shit they read on the internet...

One data point: I have family who have never logged in into Facebook or used the Internet. And they spend hours unloading all the rehashed sh*t that happened in their lives, in a one-way monologue.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by tubularhells on Monday November 23, 2020 @03:48PM (#25191644)
Yes, but that's their life, not random internet shit.
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by mullen on Monday November 23, 2020 @05:35PM (#25192771)
That's called connecting with people. They unload their shit, and you unload yours.
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by SuoDuanDao on Monday November 23, 2020 @10:08AM (#25187469)
>Language Cancer

I like the term 'autocult' myself, though it might be too pessimistic for what we're actually facing. Language Cancer implies there could be a cure, which is worth considering.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by pjc50 on Monday November 23, 2020 @09:37AM (#25187139)
> language cancer

Verbal coronavirus. Snow Crash was rather ahead of its time on this, although derailed by the author infodumping ancient Sumeria in the middle.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by garbagetime on Monday November 23, 2020 @09:43AM (#25187189)
The info-dump was one of the few enjoyable parts of the book.
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by jariel on Monday November 23, 2020 @01:12PM (#25189698)
Governments only interest in banning facebook is protecting their own corruption.

Facebook is not nearly as bad as the narrative driven tabloids would have us believe.

Most people get along with it just fine, it's mostly just social media.

It can have a downside, but it's better than having communications restricted.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by lostlogin on Monday November 23, 2020 @10:26AM (#25187678)
> For island nations, it's not as bad an idea as it might sound.

In this context, what is so special about islands? The porous nature of borders doesn’t relate particularly strongly to the presence or absence of water barriers.

This comes up a lot with pandemic arguments too.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by nstj on Monday November 23, 2020 @10:35AM (#25187787)
They’re small
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by lostlogin on Monday November 23, 2020 @12:43PM (#25189359)
That hasn’t helped an awful of a lot with COVID (the UK and Hawaii come to mind), and in terms of blocking Facebook, I’m not clear on the relevance? I think I need an eli5.
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7 on Monday November 23, 2020 @10:43AM (#25187905)
> Outright bans are clumsy, but imposing a cost or bar to entry, like most societies do with alcohol and drugs, might be constructive.

With requiring payment comes the ability to trace where the money came from.

So you're essentially demanding:

- that every social media account is easily connectable to the real citizen ID behind it.

- that governments should assist social networks in their already rampant tracking of users by even enforcing it through legislature.

- by that also that governments build infrastructure which can be used to track the political opinion of every citizen, because that's what they can do if every user account is linked to a real person.

I can understand that the goals behind what you say are noble, but please take notice of this:

When I use FB or whatever, I want to be completely anonymous.

I neither want FB, nor random strangers there, nor the government to track what the real person behind my pseudonym posts on FB.

And that should be the right of everyone. Mundane things such as posting your opinion on the internet should not have huge barriers of entry and possibly individual consequences attached to them.

To not become a fascist country, you cannot regulate social media access.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by adewinter on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:03AM (#25188166)
1) why are you defending Facebook?

2) Facebook demands and aggressively enforces that your profile represents you and has your real name and other credentials associated with your identity. If your pseudonym gets reported it will definitely get banned.

3)

> With requiring payment comes the ability to trace where the money came from.

Yes that's true for literally every transaction on the internet when done with a credit card. Not sure why that's a problem.

> And that should be the right of everyone.

Facebook is a company selling a product. You do not and definitely should not have any "rights" on their private platform. Just like you do not and should not have the right to force a local business to trade with you if they do not want to.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7 on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:36AM (#25188526)
> 1) why are you defending Facebook?

Because once such laws are enacted they surely will NOT only apply to FB but to all other social networks as well.

Classic "pandora's box".

> 2) Facebook demands and aggressively enforces that your profile represents you and has your real name and other credentials associated with your identity. If your pseudonym gets reported it will definitely get banned.

How does FB doing a bad thing currently justify demanding the government to even one-up them and make it legally mandatory to do that bad thing?

- I was aware of them doing this, and if that were the subject of the discussion I would have in fact demanded that they're legally forced to stop doing it.

> Yes that's true for literally every transaction on the internet when done with a credit card. Not sure why that's a problem.

Did you have to use your credit card to write this post?

To post on any other forum for the past few decades?

Would you be happy to give me your credit card data in real life before I start listening to anything you say there?

> Facebook is a company selling a product. You do not and definitely should not have any "rights" on their private platform. Just like you do not and should not have the right to force a local business to trade with you if they do not want to.

FB has taken possession of a now essentially public space of which the participation therein is a central component of having a social life. Try finding a party or any other kind of event to attend without FB access.

If you take possession of a part of the commons along with that possession comes the duty to provide proper access to the citizens which are reliant upon it.

E.g. if you own a piece of land below which there is an aquifer, the government will force you to provide access to the water so the public can drink.

There is no reason why this should be any different in cyberspace.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by motohagiography on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:53AM (#25188723)
Typically when someone uses the english idiom, "impose a cost," they are referring to adjusting incentives in a broader economic sense, and not payments.
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by beagle3 on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:34AM (#25188503)
> With requiring payment comes the ability to trace where the money came from.

There's this thing called "cash". There are (and have been for at least a century) ways to transfer it from place to place, even electronically, in a mostly anonymous way - as mobile minutes, through western union, etc. The farther it has to go, the easier it is to track, but locally, it takes non-trivial effort to track transfer to the point that governments mostly do it when they actually have a reason rather than "just because".

> When I use FB or whatever, I want to be completely anonymous.

Well then, you're doing it wrong. You are violating FB's "real name" terms of service. And also, rest assured that almost everyone of the people you've talked to on Facebook has de-anonymized you, by having your real name in their address book somewhere which they uploaded to FB/WhatsApp/Instagram knowingly or unknowingly.

> I neither want FB, nor random strangers there, nor the government to track what the real person behind my pseudonym posts on FB.

Then FB is the wrong venue. With FB, the only winning move is not to play. They do an enormous amount of work to connect your online FB account with a real world identity. And the almost always succeed.

If you care about your privacy, get off facebook.

> To not become a fascist country, you cannot regulate social media access.

To not become a fascist country, you have to regulate social media.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7 on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:41AM (#25188580)
> There's this thing called "cash". There are (and have been for at least a century) ways to transfer it from place to place, even electronically, in a mostly anonymous way - as mobile minutes, through western union, etc. The farther it has to go, the easier it is to track, but locally, it takes non-trivial effort to track transfer to the point that governments mostly do it when they actually have a reason rather than "just because".

You are right that this COULD be designed in an anonymous way, e.g. with cryptocurrencies, sure :)

It is however naive to believe that governments will actually do that if citizens allow them to require payment for social media access.

It will very certainly wind up being trackable.

> Well then, you're doing it wrong. You are violating FB's "real name" terms of service. And also, rest assured that almost everyone of the people you've talked to on Facebook has de-anonymized you, by having your real name in their address book somewhere which they uploaded to FB/WhatsApp/Instagram knowingly or unknowingly.

That only applies if I tell my real name to any of those people, which I don't.

> If you care about your privacy, get off facebook.

It is impossible to get off of FB without being denied access to things which are a central part of social life, e.g. events.

> > To not become a fascist country, you cannot regulate social media access. > To not become a fascist country, you have to regulate social media.

I'm sorry, my wording was imprecise!

Let me correct it please: To not become a fascist country, you have to regulate social media, but you MUST NOT deny access to it.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by beagle3 on Monday November 23, 2020 @12:18PM (#25189049)
I agree everything implemented will likely be more trackable. It's already trackable as far as governments are concerned - both FB and ISPs will gladly give any data requested by governments, and tracking is one JOIN away if you didn't use a good VPN. I was just commenting that it's possible to make the payment untrackable, and not very hard.

> That only applies if I tell my real name to any of those people, which I don't.

FB also correlates by a thousands items if you use the FB app, and (at least) by IP address if you don't.

Hopefully, you never ever logged in to any other website with the same browser (or are using a super strict uBO / uMatrix policy), because that website will likely correlate you through their embedded FB pixel/like button.

> It is impossible to get off of FB without being denied access to things which are a central part of social life, e.g. events.

I guess you are in the US? That's not been my experience in other places. Everything still happens by email as well in other places. (The same cannot be said about WhatsApp - however - which cannot be escaped outside the US; If you meant "including WhatsApp" when you said FB, then I agree - though if you don't backup and don't use WhatsApp web, your copy of the conversation is still private. Metadata and the other party's is likely not.....)

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by thotsBgone on Monday November 23, 2020 @03:18PM (#25191230)
> When I use FB or whatever, I want to be completely anonymous.

Keep in mind it's already against the FB terms of service to use it anonymously. You're supposed to use your real full name.

> With requiring payment comes the ability to trace where the money came from.

One possible solution could be bitcoin. I'd be more worried about where the money is going, though. Do modern democracies need to be collecting even more money from us, to do god knows what with? Would this new tax come with a decrease in other taxes? Probably not.

I think disincentivizing social media is a good idea, but a social media tax isn't the right move. Brainstorming some other ways of doing so:

- Ban certain social media Skinner-box features like endless scrolling, recommendation algorithms, likes, whatever. This is more likely to get to the heart of the problem, but gives the government more control over the internet, private businesses, etc.

- Create alternative social media platforms which don't use the same rage-inducing and addicting mechanisms. These will fail because they are by definition less addicting than the alternative.

- Make current social media unusable by flooding it with spam. This could be accomplished "extra-legally", preferably using AI to make spam hard to detect. This is already being done to an extent by bad actors (Chinese Communist Party, though you don't need AI when you have over a billion cheap workers), but could be done on a larger scale not to sway opinion, but to ruin the platforms altogether.

- Social media companies could use semantic analysis to downrank rage-bait and negativity and up-rank positivity and thoughtful discourse (though hopefully not that hollow "you go girl!!!" faux-positivity you sometimes see on social media). This is uncomfortable because it means social media companies get to engineer our conversations to be whatever they want, but they are already doing this, they're just doing it in a malevolent way.

- Somehow educate the entire population on the dangers of social media the same way we did with cigarettes. Whether through a public information campaign, or by generally getting people to meditate and realize the true important things in life. This is a terrible solution, and obviously social media companies would fight it tooth and nail, but I only mention it because I've heard it seriously proposed too many times. If your solution is "educate everybody", but everybody is currently hooked up to disinformation machines, you're screwed.

That's all I've got. Anyone else have any ideas?

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by segfaultbuserr on Monday November 23, 2020 @09:50AM (#25187261)
> When I talk to some people, it's like I'm not even talking to people anymore, I'm talking to some node of the internet.

It's what they call a humanoid interface to the Data Integration Thought Entity.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by dane-pgp on Monday November 23, 2020 @10:48PM (#25195081)
I can't imagine Yuki Nagato getting all her news from Facebook.
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by kspacewalk2 on Monday November 23, 2020 @10:07AM (#25187458)
In corrupt hellholes, conflict is a good thing. There will be no change, no reform, no improvement ever without conflict. The key of course is to prevent violent conflict, but banning Facebook isn't gonna address the underlying causes of discontent, it'll just make things simmer under the surface until they explode into violence anyway.

You're thinking about this from a prism of a country with a generally functioning, competent government (i.e. any rich Western country). Solomon Islands isn't that.

Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by zarkov99 on Monday November 23, 2020 @07:38PM (#25193826)
Yes, but I do not think it had to be this bad. Thoughtfully mediating the communication of billions of people is a massive challenge but one that could be tackled by the sort of highly intelligent and well funded teams that abound in places like Facebook. Unfortunately Facebook leadership lacks the character to try to fix a problem that is making them billions of dollars. Even if that problem is making the whole world worse off. I think history will judge them harshly.
Re:Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'natio... by zehnfischer on Monday November 23, 2020 @04:40PM (#25192264)
To quote Niklas Luhmann: "Everything we know about the world we live in we know from mass media" He wasn't thinking about Facebook, but what would you expect people to talk about? Most lifes are not exciting enough to fill a whole conversation.