Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by jarin on Thursday May 05, 2011 @01:32PM
(#2518193)
I saw someone point out that DHS's seized domain page isn't very accessible due to just being an image.
I noticed that the image is always named something generic like banner2.jpg and there's no other uniquely identifiable information in the HTML. I think they do it specifically to make it very difficult to Google Search for seized domains.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by zbowling on Thursday May 05, 2011 @01:34PM
(#2518196)
Violation of government accessibility requirements. Oh and it's horribly compressed (150k+ IIRC), text stored on a JPEG (PNG is so much better for graphics), not hosted on a CDN, lacks etags so there is no caching, and the background image of the "seized" text in red is just as bad. Wasting my tax money on massive bandwidth drain to host the page and wastes my bandwidth caps to load it. Makes me angry.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by jimktrains2 on Thursday May 05, 2011 @01:44PM
(#2518227)
> Violation of government accessibility requirements.
I've always wondered if they could be sued for that.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by jrockway on Thursday May 05, 2011 @02:04PM
(#2518310)
I'll throw in a few bucks if you want to try.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by jimktrains2 on Thursday May 05, 2011 @05:57PM
(#2519063)
IANAL and don't have the time to arrange something like this or I would def try.
PS: I would throw money someone's way to do this too.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by rhizome on Thursday May 05, 2011 @02:25PM
(#2518385)
It may violate the ADA, but the lack of accessibility only prevents a visitor from benefiting from the DHS's message, not a site that they would otherwise use without trouble (as is done for IRL ADA complaints). Even if someone could get in front of a judge with this, I'm sure the DHS has absolute immunity for stuff like this.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by jimktrains2 on Thursday May 05, 2011 @05:56PM
(#2519058)
If they can't see, they can't be told what this image says on the page, the only image on the page. Imagine if there were important information in it or something other than just a warning.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by rhizome on Thursday May 05, 2011 @06:26PM
(#2519149)
Imagine if there were important information in it or something other than just a warning.
Sure, but there isn't. :)
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by nicw on Thursday May 05, 2011 @03:31PM
(#2518639)
Don't think they'll find anyone willing to contribute design effort. No graphic designer would want to add this page to their Design Portfolio.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by bad_user on Thursday May 05, 2011 @04:32PM
(#2518799)
If I did graphics design, I would have no problem with it -- heck, I would even tell people about it :)
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on
by sudonim on Thursday May 05, 2011 @06:05PM
(#2519094)
Unless some other smartass is doing it too, it was probably me. Every time one of these domain seizures comes up I point out that the page you're redirected to isn't accessible to Americans With Disabilities. Petty? Maybe. It would be nice to force their hand once in a while.
They have already got in to some hot water when they seized a dynamic dns domain that was hosting thousands of subdomains (only one was accused of pedophilia trafficking). They wildcard redirected the domain to an IP that hosts a page saying that domain was seized because the site was hosting pedophilia. Pedophilia labeling was strung across a lots of personal sites, church websites, and radio station websites in the processes. It took days for them to revert it and have all the DNS records propagated but the damage was partly already done as it labeled innocent parties as pedophiles without due process.
Not sure who is doing oversite of the DHS/ICE's efforts here. Probably best not to buy .COM/.NET domains, especially if you register it with US address in the WHOIS.