News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by gaius on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:06AM (#2516859)
No - my point is that countries that have sophisticated financial services industries have historically been extremely unlikely to make catastropic errors of asset allocation resulting in famine, etc.

If we had a group - let's call it The Party - deciding what to invest where, and they ballsed it up, then you get the Great Leap Forward (30M starving to death is half the population of the UK).

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by geebee on Thursday May 05, 2011 @05:25PM (#2518975)
I'd rather live in a country with lots of lawyers and bankers than none. And some of these lawyers and bankers are, without question, very valuable to society.

People who look favorably on these industries would probably describe the rent-collection or wealth-destroying activities of these sectors as the regrettable but minor (and maybe inevitable) byproduct effect of an activity that is, on the balance, very positive. We all have these types - high tech has patent trolls (er, innovative technology development partnerships), but nobody would say that the tech sector is a rent-collecting segment of the economy (though many would say that patent trolls are part of the legal industry, not the high tech industry).

Other people like Wooley at the LSE (quoted in the article) take a far dimmer view:

“The amount of rent capture has been huge,” Woolley said. “Investment banking, prime broking, mergers and acquisitions, hedge funds, private equity, commodity investment—the whole scale of activity is far too large.” I asked Woolley how big he thought the financial sector should be. “About a half or a third of its current size,” he replied"

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by ThomPete on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:13AM (#2517008)
And where exactly did I promote such a solution?
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by Nrsolis on Thursday May 05, 2011 @05:29PM (#2518982)
Right where you made a value judgement about the "value" the algorithmic component of the financial services sector provides to society.