News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by whyleyc on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:03AM (#2516848)

  "an industry that provides little value to society"
Whilst this is a nice popular statement to trot out in the current climate, it is simply not true, at least not in fiscal terms. Some facts:

  * The financial services industry accounted for 10% of GDP in 2009

  * It provides 4% of total employment in the UK (1 million jobs)

  * It contributes 28% of the UK’s total exports of services

  * It contributed £53.4bn in tax in 2009/10 (11% of total government receipts)
Much as everyone would like to say "sod the bankers, let them go elsewhere", the truth is doing so would likely torpedo the economy.

Source: http://217.154.230.218/NR/rdonlyres/E01CD45A-053F-4C9B-BDAA-...

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by thailandstartup on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:00AM (#2516977)
You need to think a little bigger to properly understand his point.

Humankind is mis-allocating some of its most talented labour to what is essentially an arms race in financial market predictive algorithms. It provides some benefit for humankind - increased liquidity in markets, but the value of the marginal liquidity is small compared to the talent that is wasted.

Salman Khan is an excellent example - he left his job as a hedge fund analyst to start Khan Academy. How many new Khan Academies would we have if the incentives were right to have talented people working on useful projects instead of the financial arms race?

Sure, the incentives are right for an individual or country to specialize in financial markets. Think bigger - an alien looking at what we're doing here on planet earth would say we're wasting a lot of our talent on stuff that just re-arranges the pie instead of making it bigger.

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by swombat on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:19AM (#2517024)
Trading algorithms is a minute portion of what a bank does. The primary function (and activity) of investment banks is to help clients raise money (via bonds issues, shares issues, etc). Some secondary functions include helping them insure against risks (e.g. with futures contracts), and acting as brokers for speculators (e.g. hedge funds), or as market makers to make the markets more liquid so that more trading happens.

I'm missing quite a few things, of course, but my point is: this "algorithmic trading arms race" that you mention is basically something like 1% of what the average investment bank does (and 0% of what retail banks do).

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by ThomPete on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:45AM (#2517131)
Yes but the question is not whether the banking industry is justified in it's existence. But rather whether they provide a value to society that is equal to what they take out of it.
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by swombat on Thursday May 05, 2011 @10:29AM (#2517467)
They absolutely do. Focusing on investment banks (I assume you have no problem justifying the existence of retail banks and insurers, the other two giant topics in financial services), what they do is effectively make the allocation of capital more efficient.

Without efficient capital allocation, most enterprise becomes extremely difficult. Without banks, there would be no stock market. There would be no way for companies to raise large sums of money to grow faster. There would be no one keeping markets liquid, which would encourage people to stick their money under the mattress rather than invest it. There would be no way for startups to exit, and so there would be no VCs, and no angels either (or at least, much more limited ones, making maybe one or two investments to help out a friend). All of this would massively reduce the amount of capital available to work with, and decimate the business world.

Now, you might take the view that "you don't need capital to do business", but that's just a very limited viewpoint that applies in very narrow circumstances, like some small percentage of internet startups. Almost all businesses need capital to get started. There's a good reason why microloans are so successful - they provide capital that helps enterprise. Think of the banking system as an equivalent of microloans for people who need more than $100 (for example, because they need to design and sell new products, build new factories, buy stock, make strategic acquisitions, etc).

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by barrkel on Thursday May 05, 2011 @12:41PM (#2517987)
Do you really believe that allocation of capital is in general so inefficient that it requires 10% (and rising) of GDP to be allocated correctly?
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by ThomPete on Thursday May 05, 2011 @11:02AM (#2517623)
I agree but I think it's a little more complicated.

The problem is that we we loosing developers to high paying jobs in the banking industry. I.e. not your average netbank developer but the developer who can develop for those 1% you talk about.

So the problem is that the developers in talk here are the talented ones that goes for those jobs within certain parts of the banking industry that certainly don't provide anything close to the value they extract from the market.

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by swombat on Thursday May 05, 2011 @12:27PM (#2517934)
Your argument only really stands if basically every single one of those programmers is Mark Zuckerberg, able to create a $50b company... I don't think that's a reasonable assumption.
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by ThomPete on Thursday May 05, 2011 @01:14PM (#2518126)
My argument is that the startup community is loosing good developers to a specific part of the banking industry which I fail to see provide much value other than to their bosses.

I have no problem with them making more money. I think it's obvious why they make the choices they do.

The problem is that the part of the banking world they go to. That part of the banking industry that can pay the high salaries aren't benefitting society.

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by whyleyc on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:21AM (#2517032)
A good point - I was looking at things from a purely fiscal perspective, and trying to challenge the prevailing opinion in the UK that banks == bad, but you are right that they suck up a disproportionate amount of talent and skill.

I guess for many graduates the banks seem to offer the best answer to the risk/reward question.

The challenge is how to change that mindset, in a way which doesn't just lead to all the qants leaving the industry to build another social photo-sharing app :)

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by arethuza on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:39AM (#2517110)
Do you think that the banks in Ireland and Iceland were equally valuable to their societies?
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by ThomPete on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:19AM (#2517023)
Economic value is not the only value society lives of.

The very fact that value is a subjective dynamic variable underlines the importance of not getting too focused on the actual fiscal numbers.

You can have societies where the oil industry makes up most of the value for the countries export but where the actual money does not benefit society in general.

And again I am not saying sod the bankers. I am simply questions whether they are making too much money compared to the value they provide to society.

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by wazzles on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:06AM (#2516860)
Um, nice try.

Takes a lot of 50 billions to add up to 1.5 trillion. Especially when you include interest.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfina...

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by whyleyc on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:57AM (#2516975)
You're assuming two things here:

(1) The country would have been better off financially not to bail the banks out and let them burn

(2) The nationalised banks won't end up turning a profit for taxpayers in the long run anyway

Both of which could be considered shaky assumptions. See Robert Peston's analysis on this very topic for more: http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/robertpeston/2010/03...

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by ThomPete on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:26AM (#2517054)
The day that the banks choose to bail out it's customers I might consider changing my opinioin about the value the provide to society. (not saying that they don't provide any)
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by whyleyc on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:45AM (#2517133)
"The day that the banks choose to bail out it's people"

Sounds like a nice catchy statement, but what do you actually mean by this ?

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by ThomPete on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:57AM (#2517175)
That it was the taxpayers who bailed out the banks and that I hope the banks will remember that.
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by wazzles on Thursday May 05, 2011 @10:39AM (#2517517)
Robert Peston is generally a waste of space.

UK GDP is around 1.5 trillion. Therefore we spent the equivalent of ONE WHOLE YEAR OF OUTPUT FOR THE WHOLE COUNTRY on bailing out the banks. You do not solve a debt crisis with more debt. You do not solve a financial crisis by supporting the financial institutions that caused it in the first place. Northern Rock has no assets other than a bunch of shit 125% mortgages and repo'd Barrats buy to let flats worth cents on the dollar. The idea this could turn a profit is absurd.

Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by whyleyc on Thursday May 05, 2011 @11:41AM (#2517765)
Not a great example to support your argument I'm afraid since Northern Rock was already back in profit over 8 months ago - http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-10848374
Re:Silicon Milkroundabout: Forget the banks, come and join a... by anamax on Thursday May 05, 2011 @11:52AM (#2517809)
> You do not solve a debt crisis with more debt.

You must be new here.

We solve everything with more debt.