https://slate.com/business/2020/01/private-equity-retail-fai...
The first theory is interesting: "sometimes, private equity firms really are just looters."
The high bankruptcy rate is not encouraging.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/07/24/private-e...
etc.
And some of Toys R Us' creditors aren't happy either:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-13/toys-r-us...
The question, however, is: given that all these companies are already on the brink of bankruptcy, how is it legal (and acceptable) that a 3rd party comes in, extracts hundreds of millions from the already bankrupt company, and when the bankruptcy does arrive, it is bigger and worse than what would have happened without the PE involvement? Basically everyone except the PE gets screwed.
I have not been following this closely, but if the 5-10 PE deals I’ve looked at over the years, it was clear from day 1 whether it was structured to have a chance at recovery, (some of which succeed, and some fail) or just to enrich the PE buyer.
I wonder why this isn’t clear to the creditors - my guess would be that an early legitimate creditor only uses “other peoples money”, which legitimizes it for others.
They have their share of failures like any other industry, but IME Hanlon's Razor - or just legitimate risk-taking that doesn't pan out - applies to most PE bankruptcies.
Looting implies that the objects didn't belong to you. If I buy a cheap crappy old car to sell of the spare parts, is that "looting"
> The high bankruptcy rate is not encouraging.
That doesn't have much to do with private equity, the entire sector is in deep shit. It's not like Toys'R'Us was a model of health...
> And some of Toys R Us' creditors aren't happy either:
That's a more serious question, and will need to be resolved. Keep in mind that if the creditors aren't happy, they won't lend money again to companies owned by those PE firms. So it's not like there are no consequences
When I buy a house on a mortgage, I (not the house) end up with the debt, and I don't get to transfer any of the assets associated with the house to myself in a way which makes them not subject to repossession if the mortgage isn't paid.
So, yeah, the deals we're talking about are very different.
12 out of 50 is not "most".
https://www.forbes.com/advisor/loans/recourse-loans-vs-non-r... ["In all but 12 states, home mortgages are also considered recourse loans. If a borrower is underwater on their mortgage—meaning the outstanding debt is greater than the value of the home—the bank may not be able to recoup all of its money from a foreclosure sale. In this case, the bank can get a deficiency judgment for the difference between the debt and the foreclosure sale price and then garnish the borrower’s wages or file a lien against other assets."]
If you find a bank that lets me pay myself a "tenant fee" for living in a house I bought on a mortgage, please let me know, I'm all ears...
It's very different. A PE firm borrows money, buys a company, transfers the debt to the company, strips the assets and then lets it go bankrupt, leaving them with all the assets and no debts. Rinse and repeat.
The PE firm should have more skin in the game, if they take out a loan to buy Toys R Us, they should be responsible if the company fails.
It's very different.
The mortgage equivalent would be an investor taking out a loan to buy out the mortgage, transferring the deeds of the house to themselves. And then transferring the loan into the mortgage-payer's name and making him responsible for paying it off.
They've really done nothing except use their superior credit status as abritage to obtain a tangible asset.
It is a well known phenomenon - the book Glass House covers the destruction of Anchor Glass this way in surprising detail.
More background: https://prospect.org/economy/last-legislation-stop-private-e...
None of this makes sense. if the company is profitable enough to be able to pay back its entire market capitalisation, why would they sell the assets off? If the cow is making that much milk, they'll keep milking it, or float it back and make a fortune
It is indeed the creditors money that is lost. And AFAIK it is legal. I just wonder why it’s legal.
Much like in the subprime crisis, the original creditor knows quite well the likelihood of recovering the loan is low, but they sell it to a dumber creditor (often pension funds) who does not.
Unlike toysrus and hostess, the subprime thing included a huge mount of illegal things by many of the parties, but still hardly any enforcement - so I guess it doesn’t matter all that much if it’s legal or not.
It sounds like a scam but apparently it is legal somehow.