Their reputation is so poor among some circles now that I don't see them staying in power 10 years out. They're going the way of the BBB.
As a result, you're safer searching for certain types of businesses on Google Maps, but even Google has "GOOGLE GUARANTEED" and possibly other paid-for indicators which make me not trust their results.
The market incentives are so bad among rating and business directory sites that I can only imagine that at this point, only a mutual company dedicated to business directory services can survive long-term. I don't think any exist right now.
EDIT: In fact the background check and screening are free. The Guarantee only appears to refer to the refund guarantee.[2]
Disclosure: I work at Google, and knew some people on the team.
1. https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/7549288?hl=en
2. https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/6226575?hl=en&r...
It’s absolutely incredible that there’s no real recourse for these things either.