Re:Free and liberated e-books, carefully produced for the tr...
by richardjs on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @12:29PM
(#25139573)
It looks like the subject has come up a couple times on the mailing list [1] [2], but in my (admittedly casual) searching I didn't find anything since 2017, with the most relevant answer being "not at the moment". Since it has been a couple years, maybe it's worth bringing up again on the mailing list?
[1] https://groups.google.com/u/1/g/standardebooks/c/JdVpCm3ckGg...
[2] https://groups.google.com/g/standardebooks/c/osOEfs5HdLo/m/2...
Re:Free and liberated e-books, carefully produced for the tr...
by ronjouch on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @12:53PM
(#25139921)
Thanks for the ML digging :) .
Agreed, it's worth bringing up again on the mailing list; will do this week and post here a link to my message.
Re:Free and liberated e-books, carefully produced for the tr...
by derbOac on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:47AM
(#25147149)
I was thinking that one of the problems with a lot of public domain translations is that the translations are extremely dated. So you're reading this text that you almost need a translation of that itself is a dated translation.
This isn't the fault of Standard Ebooks, but it's an elephant in the room of public domain texts in general. In many ways I'd rather see effort put into crowdsourced or volunteer modern translation than into improved copyediting.
It's especially problematic if you consider that the original text in the foreign language isn't available as well, as you're noting.
1. Discover / browse / search.
2. Expect high quality text & typography.
3. Be part of a high-volume community that archives and refines texts year after year.
"Then build your own similar site with high-quality titles in French!" , I hear some say. Sure, but I see tons of excellent marketing & infrastructure already done by Standard Ebooks, which could be reused for non-English books!
Said differently, mid/long term I see the greater good being achieved by supporting non-English titles in Standard Ebooks itself, not in one satellite mimic site per language, of varying maintenance quality. To compare with the domain of online encyclopedias, these are the same reasons to have en.wikipedia.org and fr.wikipedia.org maintained under one (Wikipedia) umbrella sharing infrastructure, not wikipedia.org and frenchwikipedia.org maintained by entirely different teams.