News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by 3np on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @06:44AM (#25122611)
I have mixed feelings about what you wrote.

100% with you that by itself, browser HTTPS-only mode (even by default) is A Good Thing. In isolation, this is a no-brainer and Mozilla's doing the right call.

I'm not happy with DoH though, at all. I fall in the crowd who wants to control my own DNS on my own devices (and I do realize that for those less technically knowledgeable, the status quo is putting that in the hands of the network admin or even ISP, but at least in principle they have the means to do so if they just figure out how, which is relatively trivial). DoH effectively completely cripples things like pihole. I'd have to start whitelisting IPs/hostnames for port 443 :/

Another practical negative consequence is the further centralization of TLS termination in (most notably) Cloudflare and Akamai, as I am sure this will de the default for those who are now rushed to TLS-enable currently uncompliant endpoints. Great sieves for XEyes and private tracking industry.

Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by emn13 on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @09:15AM (#25123930)
I don't understand this criticism at all; could you clarify what the issue is?

None of this - DoH, nor HTTPS-only - is required. It's not even on by default (yet). If you have some specific wishes; it's trivial to pick a different DNS system, or leave https-only off.

Additionally, DoH and https-only aren't really closed or locked in in any way. There's a cloudflare-base DoH option that's used by default, but just as you can pick your own DNS servers, you can also pick your own DoH servers. Sure, it's new (and thus not on by default), so selection is still fairly limited. But even ISPs are starting to offer DoH, and surely others will too. There's no reason to assume that you won't soon be able to pick from several choices for your DoH setup, including local or LAN options.

You mention pihole; and though I've never used it, they do have a page on DoH, and a superficial skim doesn't have any huge issues: https://docs.pi-hole.net/guides/dns-over-https/ - and looks like it's based on code described here https://developers.cloudflare.com/1.1.1.1/dns-over-https/clo... - and that supports upstream and downstream DoH, by the looks of it.

In other words: all change has some friction, but if you want local control: you still have it. The only thing you really lose is the ability for networks to hijack DNS of devices that don't trust it. And that's a feature, right? If you trust the network; sure, use that DNS if you want. But if you don't: better that its easier to avoid control by that network.

What downsides does DoH have?

Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by cptskippy on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @10:14AM (#25124620)
> None of this - DoH, nor HTTPS-only - is required. It's not even on by default (yet).

I had to disable DoH on all 5 of my machines because it was enabled automatically.

> You mention pihole; and though I've never used it, they do have a page on DoH

pihole supports using Cloudflare as an upstream DoH provider, not acting as a DoH provider.

Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by emn13 on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @11:13AM (#25125437)
> I had to disable DoH on all 5 of my machines because it was enabled automatically.

Some googling: it's on by default in the US now, not yet globally.

> pihole supports using Cloudflare as an upstream DoH provider, not acting as a DoH provider.

That's unfortunate; are you sure it's not just a little poorly documentend? At least the underlying software they link to https://developers.cloudflare.com/1.1.1.1/dns-over-https/clo... clearly mentions a proxy functionality, but maybe that's not on yet?

In any case: the point is that just as DNS proxying became easier over time, so will DoH proxying. There's nothing wrong with sticking to old tech as you chose to if it's not yet convenient for you to switch; especially if pihole supports upstream DoH, since presumably you trust the network between your device and your pihole ;-) - rendering the rest of the DoH benefits moot.

I'm sure time will resolve issues like that, but in the meantime, the vast majority of people that didn't customize their DNS and don't choose at all, or choose based on privacy or performance get a more private & secure option by default. I mean, it's transition pains are annoying, but it sounds like a good idea in general, so I suppose the transition costs are worth it in the long run, especially since the vast majority of users won't even notice. It's annoying to be in the camp that gets to bear the burden, for sure.

Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by cptskippy on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @02:36PM (#25128560)
My objection is that the change was made without notice or explicit permission, and changed the chain of trust. Mozilla decided that I should trust Cloudfare and that I should not trust my own network or the corporate network.
Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by emn13 on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @04:03AM (#25134606)
Yeah, the rollout (as opposed to the feature) sounds poor. Since I didn't experience this - you're saying you upgraded FF and without notice your DNS settings were replaced? I.e. anything only resolvable on your LAN suddenly stopped working? That's pretty annoying to debug!
Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by 3np on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:05AM (#25146963)
That's indeed what happened but only for US users.
Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by zo1 on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @09:55AM (#25124356)
Not OP. Did we ever allow browsers to set their own DNS server for plain DNS requests? (Let's ignore IE and it's mess of mixing OS settings + browser settings a la "Internet Settings").

For me at least, the biggest criticism of DoH is that it's not necessarily a centralized config at the OS level and seems to be a step in the direction of the general theme "Browser As Your OS".

Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by kd913 on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @07:28AM (#25122952)
Firefox DoH easily works with DNSCryptProxy. https://github.com/DNSCrypt/dnscrypt-proxy/wiki/Local-DoH

You can easily set it up to contact that, but enable some exclusions for specific domains if you wish to fallback to pihole.

It's probably not that efficient anyway to be using pihole's filtering in Firefox compared with just ublock origin anyway.

Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by cptskippy on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @10:20AM (#25124716)
> It's probably not that efficient anyway to be using pihole's filtering in Firefox compared with just ublock origin anyway.

Pihole operates at the network level. It can block Windows Telemetry, ads on your Roku, smart devices trying to phone home, etc. Any guest devices that connect to your network also benefit without you having to install blockers on them.

It's not a replacement for ublock, it's used in conjunction with it.

Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by kd913 on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @06:36PM (#25131353)
Yea, I understand that which is why I keep pihole.

My argument though is in the context of Firefox, in which case the benefit of the pihole bit is dubious when you can install ublock origins. Pihole doesn't provide much additional benefits that can't be achieved with ublock origin advanced filters.

Granted someone could argue what would be the benefit of using the dnscrypt-proxy at that point. In that context, you benefit from better privacy (DNS requests aggregated) and caching benefits.

Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by josephcsible on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @01:53PM (#25127962)
Your Pi-hole working on other people's devices is a bad thing. After all, there's nothing stopping you from configuring your Pi-hole to filter political content you disagree with instead of just ads, trackers, and malware.
Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by cptskippy on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @02:23PM (#25128385)
> Your Pi-hole working on other people's devices is a bad thing.

No, it isn't. Never mind the fact that that isn't how PiHole works, I'm perfectly within my right to control how my home network functions.

Re:Firefox 83 introduces HTTPS-Only Mode by 3np on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @08:18AM (#25123376)
I wasn't aware of this part of dnscrypt-proxy, thanks for sharing. I find network-level blocking and browser extensions work complementary.

In a broader sense, I guess the larger concerns is malware and trackware on various devices where DoH is used maliciously. Especially smartphones. Granted there is nothing stopping them today, but the normalization of DoH will put it in arms reach for everyone.