News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Reddit removed my permissions from my own legal, non-abusive community

My partner and I started a community on reddit more than 10 years ago. Nothing illegal or untoward, it's just a subreddit about a city and everything related to it.

We have had some issues with abusive commenting like many other places, but we've kept a good handle on it, with a combination of automoderator and manual moderation.

We had to add other mods over time, especially during election season and through covid and the riots, to keep up with the volume. Some have been helpful and respectful, and others have just given me nothing but abuse and criticism. Perhaps it was a mistake to keep them on, but they were good at their work otherwise.

Well, after a snafu (my fault, admittedly) reddit has now taken away my permissions as mod, effectively removing me from my own community that I started.

What was my mistake? I didn't post something illegal, nor anything abusive. I merely removed other mods, temporarily, and added an auto-moderator rule which warned users when their posts were reported.

This was reported to the admins through ZenDesk, and suddenly I'm caught in the middle of a "power struggle", I guess, to gain control of this subreddit.

Just a note to anyone wanting to start a community on this platform, you can spend years growing it (to 250K+ at this point) and then one day it can just be taken away from you with no recourse.

We are now waiting on a "decision" from the admin team, and I don't know what to expect as the outcome, but it seems even if you are not breaking any of the rules, you can suddenly discover that you've been removed from the community you started and maintained for years.

( 8 comments | 15 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Reddit removed my permissions from my own legal, ... by el_dev_hell on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @05:11PM (#25130620)
This is in Ask HN and you do have a question:

> What was my mistake?

I'll chime in with my 2cents.

Your mistake was pouring effort into building a community on Reddit for 10 years.

I hate to see work go to waste, but what did you expect? You don't own Reddit. Reddit doesn't owe you anything. You never had a contract with Reddit (and I strongly doubt there's a clause to protect your in their TOS). You built content for their platform that can be monetized by their ad infrastructure -- they weren't hiding that fact.

The same thing can happen if you have a Discord community, Facebook community, or even a Telegram group. That's the price you pay for free hosting, zero technical setup, and access to a built-in audience.

Take this as a learning experience. If you build another community on Reddit, perhaps funnel the users to a self-hosted platform. Alternatively, lower your expectations of "owning" a community.

Re:Ask HN: Reddit removed my permissions from my own legal, ... by alexfromapex on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:23PM (#25118929)
Reddit has gone downhill in the past year IMO. Would love to find an alternative with as large of a user base.
Re:Ask HN: Reddit removed my permissions from my own legal, ... by dyingkneepad on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @04:06PM (#25129835)
I hate to be the rude person, but I'll be it: it's not your community, it's Reddit's community. You just happen to be the person that created the sub and maintained it for a while. Your sense of ownership and attachment to it are just feelings that you have, they are not reality. If you want your community you'll probably have to setup something on forgotmypw17.com/forum.php.
Re:Ask HN: Reddit removed my permissions from my own legal, ... by forgotmypw17 on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @02:18AM (#25134035)
Physically you,re correct.

Verbally, I clicked a button titled "Create your own subreddit" when making it.

I thought the ad impressions and ads on my community were the price.

Re:Ask HN: Reddit removed my permissions from my own legal, ... by Darmody on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @04:36AM (#25134858)
They call it "your own" as a marketing strategy.

Same thing with other companies that say they want to empower the user or change the world. No. They want to make money and they make it by attracting users.

Re:Ask HN: Reddit removed my permissions from my own legal, ... by dyingkneepad on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @01:13PM (#25140199)
Well, the reddit menu that lists the communities I'm subscribed to also says "My Communities" yet I know none of them are, in fact, mine. The definitino of "your own" here is very subjective.
Re:Ask HN: Reddit removed my permissions from my own legal, ... by kleer001 on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @04:46PM (#25130348)
What's your question?
Re:Ask HN: Reddit removed my permissions from my own legal, ... by forgotmypw17 on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @06:47AM (#25135749)
Good question. I think it is, what do I do, how to recover, and how to avoid in the future?

Some good answers in here.