News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lax oversight allows Chicago police to avoid turning on t... by Buttons840 on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:42PM (#25118019)
> Do the math sometime on what kind of bandwidth and storage capacity a large agency like NYPD

40,000 officers (rounded up)

8 hours of full HD video can be stored in 10 gigs of storage

do this 365 days a year for every officer

S3 standard costs less than 3 cents per gigabyte to store per month

result: about 50 million dollars to store 8 hours of FHD video of every officer every day for a year

The NYPD anual budget is 5 billion dollars. Thus, storing all this video would cost about 1% of the budget. I've made generous roundings in favor of overestimating this cost, and in reality it would be much less.

Re:Lax oversight allows Chicago police to avoid turning on t... by davidf560 on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:47PM (#25118069)
Now calculate how big of a data pipe you need to AWS to upload 400 terabytes of video each day and how much does that cost?
Re:Lax oversight allows Chicago police to avoid turning on t... by Buttons840 on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:08PM (#25118278)
I'm not proposing you store it on S3, but I used the price of S3 standard as a cost estimate. In reality I expect you could get the cost to be much less (I mean, even S3 standard is closer to 2 cents than the 3 cents I quoted) with on-premises storage. You also wouldn't need every minute of every video instantly available like you would get with S3 standard, further reducing costs.

I had a hard time finding the bandwidth costs, but since you've done the math already, I'd like to hear what you came up with.

Re:Lax oversight allows Chicago police to avoid turning on t... by henryfjordan on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:28PM (#25118959)
AWS has hard drives that they can send you empty and you fill em up and send them back for upload to S3. They even have semi trucks full of hard drives that will drive to you: https://aws.amazon.com/snowmobile/
Re:Lax oversight allows Chicago police to avoid turning on t... by heavyset_go on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:03PM (#25119200)
If you were storing large amounts of data on a budget, you'd be wasting a considerable amount of money on storage and bandwidth with S3.