So scaling as fast as possible is the #1 goal, because if you don't someone else will and you'll go out of business.
Therefore sales and marketing is a huge factor in growth. Then the idea is, once you've grown as much as you can and it's too hard for others to compete because of your entrenched network effects, you can reduce sales and marketing to a a reasonable, highly profitable level.
That's it in a nutshell and it works in any market with strong network effects, which AirBNB strongly fits into, in facts it's a poster child for the concept. Yelp is another good example -- sign up all the restaurants before a competitor does.
There are a lot of different business models out there, which you can study (and MBA programs teach you). This is just one model, and it's a legitimate one. Google, Facebook, Microsoft and Apple all have different models from it (and all drastically different from each other as well).
To evaluate ad spend, you don't look at just short-term return. There's a reason that "lifetime value" is a critical concept for companies. It's fairly normal in large companies that, in a given year, you may spend more on ads than you gain from those ads - but you expect the customers you gain from them to continue spending over many years.
So you may spend $100 to gain a customer who spends $20 in the first year... then $40 in the second... then $80 in the third... now all of a sudden your return on that was positive, three years later.
These are the kind of ads you want to buy, even if in the short term it looks bad. These large marketing expenses should have compounding benefits over many years. The people who care about the short term like that are not the investors you want and not the people you're trying to please.
I don't know what AirBnB's numbers are, companies aren't required to disclose this and they guard it very closely :)
I am not saying they're doing a bad job, I am merely saying that it looks difficult to tell. Remember, the management has a huge incentive to sell you the stock regardless of the future value of the business, it's your job to figure out if it is a good idea.
[1] https://howmuch.net/articles/worlds-top-50-biggest-advertisi...
However, I think H8crila meant that they did not spend that much on advertisement around the time they ipoed.
If you're consumer focused, you spend on marketing, if you're business focused, you spend on sales. There are few examples to the contrary (Google, Atlassia, for example).
AirBnB early on was sniping Craigslist vacation listings[1], and now they have the resources, and scale to market directly. If AirBnB isn't doing it right, what constitutes the 'right' time to spend on marketing?
I'm curious as to how some folks would respond to this, and why.
I am not saying advertising is bad, or that it doesn't work, or that you shouldn't do it. Nothing of this sort. It's just unclear to me what's the plan for eventually returning anything to the shareholder. All of the eventual value depends on this.
How does one figure whether the business will keep growing without blasting people's faces with ads? If so much spend on ads is required to generate revenue growth then there will either never be profits or the revenue growth will stall (and thus the equity is worth rather little), if ads are not required then why are they spending so much on them, or maybe when will they stop spending.
All the "heroes" of the tech boom (Facebook, Google, Apple, Microsoft) did not suffer from this problem - they were profitable before going public.
It feels like this time we're in an advertising bubble. Nearly every single S-1 submitted to HN has this feature.
I am genuinely puzzled by this, if someone can offer some perspective on how can you model something like this I would be grateful - what assumptions you'd be making here.