News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by andrewflnr on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:52PM (#25116189)
No one benefits from painting vaccines as invincible magic. We don't want to give the actual crazies any more fuel then we have to. Realism is important for restoring the "credibility of science" after the flailing contradictory guidance we got from official sources early in the pandemic.
Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by folli on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:54PM (#25116882)
As a general statement, I have to disagree. Vaccines indeed are close to invincible magic. Maybe only antibiotics are similarly magic.
Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by tomp on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:10PM (#25117031)
Vaccines are literally just triggering the human immune system. That is the real magic.
Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by andrewflnr on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:47PM (#25118074)
95% success is not invincible magic. The 85% success rate for MMR cited downthread is definitely not invincible magic. "Close" is highly debatable. They're still a good idea, but let's use honest arguments.
Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by xiphias2 on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:57PM (#25118180)
95% means that if most of the population is vaccinated, the virus will probably disappear. The magic works not by not getting infected, but by not infecting other people.
Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by dragonwriter on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:33PM (#25118485)
> 95% means that if most of the population is vaccinated, the virus will probably disappear.

"Most" (>50%) is likely not enough.

Based on estimates of R0 for SARS-CoV-2, if its 95% effective lifelong immunity, then about 63%-75% need to be vaccinated for herd immunity; that number goes up if the protection is shorter-lived:

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... (the article provides computed values for a hypothetical 80% effective vaccine, but also provides the basic formula and parameters from which you can calculate at other efficacies.)

Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by to11mtm on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:09PM (#25118286)
> 95% means that if most of the population is vaccinated, the virus will probably disappear. The magic works not by not getting infected, but by not infecting other people.

This is a good time to note that AFAIK the Pfizer vaccine will not do a whole lot for preventing spread, so much as preventing an infection from breaking out into the disease (i.e. not all people infected with COV-19 wind up with COVID)

Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by bjt on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:00PM (#25118723)
Source?

Once your immune system is trained to attack the known pathogen, it should be doing that before the virus is ever able to gain a foothold in your body and spread from you to someone else. People who have been vaccinated will not spread the virus.

Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by emn13 on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @05:17AM (#25122017)
Yeah, these claims are FUD. Yes, there are theoretical concerns; as with all new things, there is no complete certainty. But we should be absolutely clear that immunity usually reduces transmission. That that's at least very common is trivially observable in the real world too; no need for fancy statistics: just note that anything we have effective vaccines for has dramatically reduces spread in societies using those vaccines broadly.

Additionally, vaccine transmission reduction worries can be conflated with direct vaccine risk worries. There are risks to untested vaccine candidates, and some can even cause more severe illness. That's why we test, surely? And though I can't find the citation off the top of my head, there are even cases where a vaccine might enhance spread in extremely peculiar circumstances; I found a paper documenting such effect when vaccinating animals vs. an otherwise generally fatal disease; the vaccine simply delayed the inevitable and that delay caused a measurable increase in spread - but that's not at all like covid 19, which is not usually fatal. These theoretical concerns do not appear likely to be a factor this time, and most remaining doubt will clear up once phase 3 trials are complete: in particular, you'll know before you're vaccinated.

Whether the vaccines will reduce spread is obviously we don't know for absolutely sure; but reduced transmission does appear to be the most likely outcome. We should definitely act and plan as if it will (while measuring and hedging to detect if we're wrong). If new data appears that undermines this assumption, then we should adapt - but that's not likely. Much more likely is that the exact details of how much spread is reduced is unknown (so a 90% effective vaccine might reduce spread by less than 90%; or even by more; and we don't know those numbers).

So for example, when a paper like this https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... points out the limitations of currently knowledge, you should interpret that as just that - a limitation of current knowledge, not that it's very likely that a vaccine will leave spread mostly unaffected.

The final nail in the coffin for this FUD is that it's not actionable. Attempts to vaccinate - with the hope of reducing transmission - won't be ill-advised in retrospect in the unlikely event it turns out not to; it still reduces severity safely. So in terms of policy after phase 3 trials are complete and before mass-rollout: who cares? At worst vaccines will reduce disease impact with a good chance to reduce spread too. But if people start thinking the vaccine is likely useless, uptake could drop, which is throwing away such a great chance. This is classic FUD: doubt that's simply undermining rational action, without cause.

Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by dragonwriter on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:22PM (#25118386)
> i.e. not all people infected with COV-19 wind up with COVID

Nitpicking, but "not all people infected with SARS-CoV-2 wind up with COVID-19".

https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2...

Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by senectus1 on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:38PM (#25119023)
this is a really important subject that isn't getting enough air time.

The difference between a vaccine that stops the infection and a vaccine that stops the disease.

The later is definitely not as useful in the early days. because you end up with lots of people operating on a "pre-covid" normal behavior basis when they could be infecting lots of people that are unable to get vaccinated.

The Former is a much better solution. Stop people getting infected, then they can't wander around shedding and spreading.

Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by xiphias2 on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:37PM (#25118518)
Wow, that's a huge difference that people talk about, I didn't know that the 2 mRNA vaccines are so different. Actually it means that the title is wrong!

Somebody asked what happens if somebody uses both vaccines, it's a really interesting question, but I think we won't have enough data.

Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by andrewflnr on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @12:13AM (#25120482)
But oh, what a big if! There are still a lot of details and failure modes that need to work out to get the happy ending. That's why we need to set realistic expectations.
Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by tachyonbeam on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:39PM (#25116723)
I don't think anyone with any amount of scientific background thinks that these first-generation vaccines will eradicate COVID, but IMO the actual data says immunity is likely to be very good and last for 6+ months, probably more. Then, in 2022, we'll get new vaccines that account for new COVID mutations, and we'll make another big dent in the number of cases again.
Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by ksenzee on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:34PM (#25117245)
"Eradicate" is a very strong word. We haven't eradicated measles or diphtheria, either. I think everyone would be pretty happy to get covid-19 down to the same incidence as measles.
Re:Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, tri... by emn13 on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @05:37AM (#25122160)
I hope we have a better chance of eradicating covid, than we do measles. A first factor making measles harder to eradicate is that it can strikes fairly early in life, and covid appears to affect young children much less and not to be as transmissable either (studies show schools are a source of transmission, but that's largely 15+ yro teenages AFAICT). Transmission in necessarily vaccinated very young children won't be as much of an issue. Secondly, measles is much more infectious. People that come in close contact with contagious measles cases almost always get infected (90%), whereas with covid there are clearly many cases in which people get lucky. Over the course of the cov19 disease it may be likely you'll infect people, but each short exposure by itself is a fairly low risk; unlike with measles. And that helps, because it means that with measles you'd expect to need a much higher degree of vaccination to achieve herd immunity that with a less contagious virus like cov19. Intuitively: when a case does slip through it's much more likely to explode and infect many others when the virus is measles, than when it's cov-19.

Of course, just because it's an easier problem - hopefully - than measles eradication doesn't mean it's achievable. But at least it's plausibly achievable.

(There are warning signs too; like animal reservoirs which are a factor for cov-19 but not measles, so it's not all roses.)