News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by Duff on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @12:52PM (#2510735)
I'd accept that nuclear can be safer, if I had any faith in the operational model for the plants.

I live in Albany, NY about 80 miles from the Vermont Yankee nuclear plant, a Mark 1 GE reactor whose operator has a history of bad practices, like operating at 120% of capacity for extended periods and regularly releasing tritium into the Connecticut River. The facility has exceeded it's service life, and the operator is suing the State of Vermont for a license extension to make some more money on the place before having to clean up the site.

While coal plants in Ohio and Western NY probably pose a greater health hazard, there are other risks as well -- if a black swan event causes a serious incident at this aging facility, I live just outside of the "no humans allowed" zone. My family and relatives are in that radius and would be financially ruined by such an event.

I want a non-profit, quasi-military like organization operating plants in a transparent manner. I want aging reactors replaced by designs where operating safety was a bigger consideration in the design of the reactor. Operating these facilities with a bias towards making money for the operator is not in the public's interest.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by bgentry on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @12:58PM (#2510752)
I want a non-profit, quasi-military like organization operating plants in a transparent manner.

A quasi-military / government organization operating transparently? Good luck with that.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by jrockway on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @01:44PM (#2510923)
My family and relatives are in that radius and would be financially ruined by such an event.

Isn't this exactly the case that insurance is designed for? A catastrophic event that is exceedingly unlikely to happen?

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by Duff on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @02:00PM (#2510993)
Nope. Insurance companies explicitly exclude these type of events. That should tell you something -- insurance companies don't like open-ended, catastrophic risk.
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by jrockway on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @02:42PM (#2511135)
Fortunately, the US government has $12 billion to help people out in the event of a catastrophe:

http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/fact-sheets/fu...

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by Someone on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @06:14PM (#2511855)
In some way, that is honest, too. Very low-probability, but highly correlated risks (if it happens to you, it likely will happen to your neighbor, too) simply aren't a good fit for a capitalist system that does not look ahead more than say ten years.

If an insurance company were to insure against such risks it would happily collect money from its customers. After a couple of years, its shareholders would force it to make dividend payouts.

Then if the 'un'thinkable were to happen, it would go broke, and the customers would not get the money they paid for.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by Derbasti on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @01:02PM (#2510766)
Any technology that makes human interaction and even plain observation impossible in the event of failure is a bad thing.

To my mind, No One can be responsible for something that is impossible to control when things go bad. It is not that I don't trust engineers, but you can not compare profit vs. risk when you can not control risk.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by tjogin on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @01:11PM (#2510805)
Sure it's a bad thing, but how can anyone possibly rationalize away the fact that coal plants kill more people than nuclear plants per kilowatt hour produced?

For every one person killed by nuclear plants, thousands die because of coal, and other kinds of power plants don't stack up well against nuclear either.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by rbanffy on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @01:22PM (#2510836)
> coal plants kill more people than nuclear plants per kilowatt hour produced

Not to be picky, but we are seeing some of the first aging nuclear facilities being operated beyond their designed lifetime by people who don't deserve to be qualified as competent. Coal has killed more people than nuclear, but it certainly seems nuclear power operators are well prepared to close that gap. :-/

I worry about future failures as those reactors grow old.

Having said that, it would be much wiser to build more modern, resilient, nuclear power plants than the equivalent capacity in coal.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by tjogin on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @02:16PM (#2511035)
Well, why do reactors grow old to begin with? Because nuclear isn't an area where funding for research is pouring in. Had we not pulled the nuclear handbreak, we wouldn't be stuck with aging reactors in the first place.

Now that we have them though, why can't we just shut them down? Because of the energy deficit that would create since we're still pulling on the nuclear handbreak.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by rbanffy on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @03:54PM (#2511396)
You've got a point, but we still need to use these reactors while we build more modern, safer ones to replace them.

It won't be pretty.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by extension on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @04:31PM (#2511527)
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by rbanffy on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @05:53PM (#2511802)
You underestimate the power of a good couple INES-7 incidents.
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by tjogin on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @01:29AM (#2512894)
I think you underestimate the power of coal plant incidents and hydropower incidents. They're no joke.

Chernobyl, an INES-7 killed 56 people. Plus another 4000 from radiation.

As previously linked, check these out: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Smog http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banqiao_Dam http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minamata_disease

The Great Smog of London killed twelve million people. Banqiao Dam killed 171 000 and destroyed homes for another eleven million people.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by rbanffy on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @06:46AM (#2513415)
Minamata and Bhopal were chemical plants, not power generation plants. Dam failures are always ugly, but they are rather predictable and preventable. And the Great Smog of London killed more people than Chernobyl but was caused by low-grade coal burning in low-tech furnaces. Even if we buy the suspicious number of 12 million, it's not a coal power plant accident.

Don't get me wrong. I like nuclear. I just know it's dangerous and the consequences of one accident can be pretty scary and long lasting.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by extension on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @09:21AM (#2513713)
Actually, it's twelve thousand. That was a typo.
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by Duff on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @01:31PM (#2510869)
Where did you find statistics on deaths attributable to waste stored in holding ponds over the next few centuries? How did you roll that figure into the per-kilowatt death rate?
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by state_machine on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @01:55PM (#2510970)
It's not like coal's figures have deaths attributable to massive CO2 emissions dramatically changing the climate over the next couple centuries factored into them either.
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by enko on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @01:38PM (#2510901)
He didn't do either, of course, because those "statistics" would be pure speculation.

Let's stick to the current facts please. When someone dies from exposure to one of these "holding ponds" then we can update the model.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by Duff on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @02:11PM (#2511021)
Note that I'm not arguing in favor of coal by any stretch of the imagination.

But, you can accurately quantify the risks of coal using current facts, because the direct effects of coal power are measurable. When you stop using coal, the effects start to go away.

Even with rooftop solar, you can measure the risks of maintenance personnel falling off of roofs and production accidents. Again, current risks that can be measured and evaluated. If you take the panel off of your roof, there is zero risk of someone dying as a result of your panel. In the year 2200, I can say conclusively that no human will be injured as a result of the solar panel on my roof.

Nuclear is different, because while the operating lifetime of the plant is dozens of years, it leaves behind waste products which introduce life-threatening risks for hundreds or thousands of years. Nobody on earth has a viable long-term strategy for managing waste products today, nor an ETA for when that strategy will be devised and implemented.

That doesn't mean that nuclear energy is evil or otherwise morally reprehensible -- it is not. But ignoring obvious long term risks by narrowing the scope of what you consider a risk to be is not an apples to apples comparison.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by enko on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @02:45PM (#2511154)
I'm not trying to say you support coal. However, you are trying to saddle the nuclear option with future problems which have not actually happened yet. How is that fair?

FWIW I do not see what is so hard about long term storage of nuclear waste. 1. Go to somewhere which never has earthquakes 2. build a shed 3. put the waste in it

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by markbnine on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @04:49PM (#2511596)
Build a shed? Obviously you do not know about Yucca Mountain. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_re...
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by jpk on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @02:45PM (#2511151)
There are, in fact, perfectly good methods for permanently disposing of nuclear waste, but the Nuclear Regulatory Commission requires that the waste material be retrievable for a certain period after emplacement. So we have to get rid of it... but keep it close. Therein lies most of the long-term safety issues with storing/disposing of it.
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by glhaynes on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @05:05PM (#2511660)
Why do they have that requirement?
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by bdunbar on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @05:58PM (#2511818)
From 'Retrievability of high-level nuclear waste from geologic repositories - Regulatory and rock mechanics/design considerations' by Naiem S.Tanious, Mysore S.Nataraja, US Nuclear Regulatory Commission; Jaak J.K.Daemen, University of Arizona

"The NRC will require retrieval to protect public health and safety in the event the site, design, or operations proves to be unsuitable. Based on performance confirmation data, the NRC will determine whether the repository system or subsystem (natural or engineered) has failed or is expected to fail to meet the performance criteria. If such failure is determined at any time during the preclosure period, the NRC may direct the DOE to retrieve the waste. The DOE could retrieve waste for its own reasons without being directed by the NRC. Such activity, however, must be carried out under applicable NRC regulations governing movement of waste. It should be noted that the NRC retrievability provision in Part 60 is only intended to protect the public radiological health and safety."

Summary: in case the repository method is all screwed up and we gotta put it somewhere else.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by bdunbar on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @05:09PM (#2511668)
<I>Nobody on earth has a viable long-term strategy for managing waste products today,</i>

IIRC this is not true. There are, however, a strategies that people don't like.

Doesn't mean they're not viable.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by pjscott on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @03:59PM (#2511404)
The phrasing of that is a bit odd, so in case anybody is unclear on this, I'd like to note that it's common practice for spent fuel to be kept in a cooling pool for 10-20 years while the more radioactive isotopes decay away, then moved to dry cask storage (or recycling, in countries like France).

However, there are designs which would keep the fuel underwater for longer periods of time, like the B&W mPower modular reactor, which has a cooling pool in the containment structure with enough capacity to hold all waste generated during the 60-year design lifetime.

All this is, of course, figured into the per-kilowatt-hour death rate when it actually hurts someone. The spent fuel pools are considered part of the plant for the purposes of risk assessment. In normal operation, of course, the spent fuel pool keeps the radioactivity nicely contained and doesn't hurt anyone.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by saraid216 on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @06:39PM (#2511939)
<i>I want a non-profit, quasi-military like organization operating plants in a transparent manner.</i>

The lack of people who can reliably operate in a perfectly incorruptible governing capacity, whether governing people, budgets, or nuclear power plants, is precisely why we had to invent democracy.

If you find a non-profit, quasi-military like organization working in a transparent manner, give them the freaking world.