Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti...
by alphaBetaGamma on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @12:45PM
(#2510705)
If you think that nuclear power has a fair amount of tail risk (very small probabilities of catastrophic accidents) then any safety considerations based on historical data is meaningless.
In that case, most of the deaths & cost that occurred in the past would come from the single most sever accident (and this seems to be the case [1])
Moreover, the worse accident (Chernobyl) is not a good guide of how bad things can go: if the probability distribution of number of deaths per accident is fat tailed, then if an accident occurs that is worse than Chernobyl it will probably be much worse.
In that case, most of the deaths & cost that occurred in the past would come from the single most sever accident (and this seems to be the case [1])
Moreover, the worse accident (Chernobyl) is not a good guide of how bad things can go: if the probability distribution of number of deaths per accident is fat tailed, then if an accident occurs that is worse than Chernobyl it will probably be much worse.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_and_radiation_accidents