One difficulty is that language-specific tools (language servers, linters... etc) are standalone pieces of software with their own dependencies, requirements... etc. It's hard to bundle together a fully "batteries-included" Emacs without figuring out a way to manage native software and services.
I think this is one place where Nix can be a real advantage: even if you don't care about Nix's reproducibility, it's ability to manage Emacs, Emacs packages and language-specific tools is pretty unparalleled. If I had some more time on my hands, I would try putting together a Nix-based Emacs "distribution" with some easy way to configure which languages you want to work with. Coupled with lsp-mode and language-servers, this has some real potential!
Totally down to try it if anyone has it.
One thing good about just standalone vim though is how portable it is. I can ssh into any server and fire it up. I also want this for a IDE. I want a console level IDE to fire up on any server I ssh into and if it's not in that server I want to be able to use any package manager to DL it easily.
I can't see any editor/IDE solve the above problem unless the editor becomes the ssh client itself. With that setup in place then my IDE can go anywhere.
This capability, plus "frame" management commands and the various terminal modes make my use of Emacs roughly equivalent to they way I see colleagues (I'm an ops/sysadmin type, not really a developer) using vim + tmux.
Nix had a learning curve, but once I got over the initial hump, I stopped wanting to manage software any other way.
To get from my setup to what I'm thinking of here, I'd need to organize it as a package that's convenient for others to depend on, fill in a bunch of missing systems and factor out support for specific languages and tools into some kind of module-style config system. Thinking about it now, it's probably just a few days' worth of work.
Emacs, by the way, does work as an SSH client (via TRAMP). I do all my work on remote servers by SSHing from a local Emacs. It's not perfect, but it works well enough in practice that I haven't tried finding anything better.
It would probably be doable for other languages, if you were so inclined
As a bonus, using Nix to manage Emacs dependencies would also give me full control over exactly which version of each package to pull in. This would create much more of a "distro" experience without needing any extra infrastructure.
https://micro-editor.github.io/
HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23334190
But, even so, Emacs will still not be an actual IDE like those made by JetBrains.
You sacrifice some specificity for a world of flexibility.
An IDE-like Vim would be a negation of everything that Vim stands for. I don’t see any point in that.
If you really need an IDE, just use one.
No it's not. Why are you telling me something I never said? I believe you are utterly mistaken to believe that I hold this opinion.
>If you really need an IDE, just use one. >I don’t see any point in that.
You don't see the point because you completely missed the point.
I want an IDE that is as lightweight as vim/emacs and as powerful as a Jetbrains IDE and lives on the console.
So right now if I "just use" an IDE it's not lightweight as it likely runs on the JVM, I can't fire it up on a console when I'm ssh-ed into a server.
If I fire vim up on a server I can't get any code highlighting or code following or integrated graphical debugging without a lot of yak-shaving and even after I do the yak-shaving it's still not done as well.
I want both on one app. Now you may not like this idea, you may be opposed to it. But this is what I'm asking for and this is my opinion. I respect your opinion but please don't tell me to "just use" an IDE when that is not the topic of the conversation.
For clarity maybe? Relax dude. You are not on trial.
Uh. I am relaxed. I'm trying to get you to relax. You should be more self aware as you're actually the one that kind of seems on edge with your initial post.
You barge into this thread with a tone that is dismissive, opinionated and wrong. You're telling me to "just use an IDE" and also that "emacs is not an IDE." I'm just telling you to stop doing that.
I usually won't tell someone to "relax" or that they're "not on trial" because it's kind of insulting and dismissive. It's also a strategic move used to flip the script to make another party seem overly emotional.
Just Read the thread next time before you respond so aggressively with your opinionated views.
>For clarity maybe?
Nah not for clarity, this is a lie. People aren't stupid and they know why they say the things they say.
You said it because you believed that I held that opinion and you wanted to dominate the conversation by telling I'm wrong. You made a mistake and you didn't really read my post. Don't do it again.
> Onivim 2 aims to bring the speed of Sublime, the language integration of VSCode, and the modal editing experience of Vim together, in a single package.
Currently in alpha, but according to this blog [2] pretty usable and has support for VSCode plugins too.
[1] https://github.com/onivim/oni2 [2] https://seanchen1991.github.io/posts/onivim2/
No, it doesn't. There are probably other reasons to try emacs but 'as capable as a JetBrains IDE' is not among them.
As it stands right now I end up using both an IDE and vim.
If you think of it not in terms of text editing but as "tool that operates on files" and "tool that operates on 'projects'", it makes more sense that many (most?) people end up doing something like this.
Currently you see a bunch of programmers divided into two camps. Those that prefer the vimish style and those that don't want to deal with the yak shaving and prefer tons of features.
The thing is these qualities are not actually tradeoffs in principle they are only tradeoffs by circumstance.
However, it VS Code didn't convince me to give up my regular tmux+vim combination.
I see no reason why something as lightweight as vim or emacs can be configured to be as powerful as vscode while being much more lightweight.
Vim IDEA
As it stands right now I end up using both an IDE and vim.
Maybe emacs is the answer but honestly if I look past all the yak-shaving to get emacs to the power level of an IDE does it really get to the point where it has everything that say CLion has?